Abstract
The ocean, serving as the cradle of life on Earth and the regulator of global climate, constitutes an invaluable resource repository for human survival and development. The preservation of ocean health is pivotal for the sustainable progression of human society. This study chose Dalian in China to assess the marine health using the Ocean Health Index (OHI) at the city-level by selecting appropriate parameters and reference points to align with data sources. The results indicated that the overall OHI score declined by 5.81 in Dalian from 2012 to 2022. For decades, the scores for Clean Waters and Coastal livelihoods and economies had consistently maintained perfection. The scores for Food Provision, Natural Products, and Carbon Storage increased, while those for Tourism and Recreation, Coastal Protection, Sense of Place, Artisanal Fishing Opportunities, and Biodiversity experienced decline. Food Provision saw the most substantial growth, increasing by 16.44, while Tourism and Recreation experienced the steepest decline, dropping by 30.57. It was indicated that the quality of seawater had consistently remained at a high level, and the economy developed well. However, there was a slight decline in marine health, with a notable downturn in tourism. Coastal ecosystems still face ongoing risks of degradation. For the next steps, the focus should be on coastal zone protection and revitalizing the tourism industry. Greater support and effective management should be provided to traditional fisheries. We recommend that parameters and reference points be standardized, and emphasize the importance of prioritizing the use of official data for calculations and assessments when applying the OHI at the city-level to ensure comparability.
Introduction
The Ocean Health Index (OHI) is a comprehensive framework designed to quantify the benefits that oceans provide to human society. While typically applied at global or national scales, its application at the city level is crucial for local policy-making where environmental management is often implemented. Dalian, often referred to as China’s "Northern Pearl," serves as a vital maritime hub. However, it faces significant pressure from rapid urbanization and industrial expansion. This study adapts the OHI to Dalian’s specific context, providing a decade-long assessment (2012–2022) of its marine health.
Methodology
Adapting the OHI to a city-level analysis required several localized adjustments to account for data availability and regional priorities:
- Proxy Variables: In the absence of specific marine employment data after 2016, total new job data and provincial ratios were used as proxies for coastal livelihoods.
- Localized Indicators: The "Natural Products" goal was narrowed to sea salt production due to a lack of granular data on marine pharmaceuticals.
- Reference Points: Benchmarks were established based on historical maximums and regulatory targets from China’s 12th and 14th Five-Year Plans for Marine Ecological and Environmental Protection.
- Weighting: A "preservationist" scheme was employed, prioritizing ecological integrity over extractive uses to reflect sustainable development goals.
Key Results and Trends
The overall OHI score for Dalian decreased from 74.55 in 2012 to 68.74 in 2022, representing a total decline of 5.81 points over the decade.
Significant Gains and Losses
- Food Provision (+16.44): This goal saw the most substantial growth, driven by the expansion of sophisticated mariculture and marine ranching initiatives.
- Tourism and Recreation (-30.57): This area experienced the steepest decline, largely attributed to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on international and domestic travel.
- Ecological Health: Both Coastal Protection (-18.23) and Biodiversity (-12.91) showed downward trends, indicating the ongoing degradation of natural habitats like wetlands and seagrass beds.
The "Perfection" Paradox
Scores for "Clean Waters" and "Coastal Livelihoods" consistently reached 100. While this reflects Dalian's success in sewage management and economic stability, it also underscores how city-level OHI results are highly sensitive to the selection of local reference points and the granularity of available data.
Discussion and Future Directions
The study reveals a complex trade-off: while Dalian’s "Blue Economy" (specifically food production) is growing, it may be occurring at the expense of natural coastal buffers. The dramatic drop in tourism highlights the vulnerability of coastal service industries to global shocks.
To improve future assessments, the authors emphasize:
- Data Standardization: Establishing a unified set of parameters for city-level OHI to allow for cross-city comparisons (e.g., Dalian vs. Shanghai).
- Official Data Prioritization: Governments should prioritize the collection of standardized official data to ensure year-over-year comparability.
- Restoration Monitoring: Continued tracking of "Beautiful Bay" initiatives and wetland restoration projects is essential to see if recent conservation efforts can reverse ecological declines.
Conclusion
While Dalian maintains high seawater quality and a stable coastal economy, the overall decline in marine health—particularly in biodiversity and tourism—signals a need for targeted intervention. Future management should focus on revitalizing the tourism sector and strengthening the protection of coastal ecosystems to ensure long-term sustainability.
Summary updated