A Damage Constitutive Model for Rock Considering Crack Propagation Under Uniaxial Compression

Shengnan Li, Yang Hao, Yu Li, Xianglong Liu, Jun-Hao Tan, Y. B. Guo, Qiao Liang, Yaqian Shen, Xingxing Wei, Cun‐Gen MaModelling—International 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel constitutive model for rocks that accurately captures their complex stress-strain behavior during uniaxial compression, specifically by incorporating the physics of crack propagation. By bridging phenomenological theory with fracture mechanics, the model provides a more physically grounded understanding of rock failure, particularly in soft rocks, and its parameters have clear physical interpretations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rocks, especially soft rocks, exhibit highly nonlinear stress-strain behavior under compression, characterized by stages like compaction, elastic deformation, crack initiation and propagation, and post-peak softening. Accurately modeling this behavior is crucial for geotechnical engineering applications such as tunnel design, slope stability analysis, and reservoir engineering. Existing models often struggle to capture the intricate interplay between internal rock structure (pores, microcracks), crack propagation dynamics, and the resulting macroscopic mechanical response, particularly during the critical compaction and softening stages. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a constitutive model that explicitly accounts for the physics of crack propagation at the mesoscopic level.

Methods

The authors propose a mesoscopic rock structure model that generalizes the rock into three types of "unit cells": intact rock, crack propagation damage, and pore unit cells. They then establish a stress model based on the static equilibrium of these unit cells.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Fracture Mechanics for Damage Unit Cells: Instead of relying solely on traditional continuum mechanics, the paper uses fracture mechanics to determine the damage and failure strength of the crack propagation damage unit cells. This is a significant departure from many previous models.
  • Geometric Damage Theory and Energy Conservation: These principles are employed to derive a damage evolution equation that quantifies damage based on crack propagation length.
  • Integration into Constitutive Model: The effective stress of damage unit cells and the damage evolution equation are integrated into the mesoscopic static equilibrium equation.
  • Consideration of Compaction Stage: The model explicitly accounts for the nonlinear deformation during the soft rock compaction stage by introducing a pore deformation parameter.
  • Parameter Determination and Analysis: Methods for determining model parameters are proposed, and their influence on the stress-strain curves is systematically explored.

Datasets

The paper utilizes experimental stress-strain data from triaxial compression tests on moderately weathered non-layered carbonaceous mudstone, as reported in a previous study [32]. This dataset was used for model validation and parameter determination. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Scales: The model effectively bridges the gap between mesoscopic crack behavior and macroscopic rock response by integrating fracture mechanics with continuum damage mechanics.
  • Physical Meaning of Parameters: A key strength is that the model parameters are shown to have clear physical meanings, relating to material properties (elasticity, toughness), initial damage (porosity), and crack behavior (propagation speed, length, angle).
  • Importance of Compaction: The accurate representation of the compaction stage, often dominated by pore collapse and microcrack closure in soft rocks, is highlighted as critical for overall model accuracy and engineering relevance.
  • Crack Propagation as Damage Driver: The study reinforces the idea that macroscopic rock damage is a direct consequence of the evolution of internal crack propagation.
  • S-shaped Crack Growth: Crack propagation length exhibits a characteristic S-shaped increase with strain, reflecting initial slow growth, rapid acceleration, and eventual stabilization.

Key Results

  • The developed constitutive model shows excellent agreement with experimental stress-strain data, particularly in capturing the nonlinear characteristics of compaction, hardening, peak strength, and post-peak softening.
  • The model's predictions are found to be more consistent with experimental results compared to some existing statistical damage models.
  • Parameter analysis reveals that increasing elasticity modulus and fracture toughness leads to higher peak stress, while increased initial damage and crack radius reduce peak stress.
  • Crack propagation speed and initial crack length parameter significantly influence the rate of damage accumulation and thus the overall stress-strain response.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumed Crack Angle: The model assumes a constant crack propagation angle of 45°. The paper acknowledges this simplification and its potential impact.
  • Experimental Data Source: The validation relies on data from a single type of rock (carbonaceous mudstone) from a previous study.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore the application of this model to more complex loading conditions (e.g., cyclic loading, dynamic loading) and a wider range of rock types. Investigating the influence of different crack geometries and distributions could also enhance the model's predictive capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aims to accurately characterize the nonlinear stress–strain evolution of rocks under uniaxial compression considering crack propagation. First, the rock meso-structure was generalized into intact rock unit cells, crack propagation damage unit cells, and pore unit cells according to phenomenological theory. A mesoscopic rock stress model considering crack propagation was established based on the static equilibrium relationship of the unit cells, and the effective stress of the crack propagation damage unit cells was solved based on fracture mechanics. Then, the geometric damage theory and conservation-of-energy principle were introduced to construct the damage evolution equation for rock crack propagation. On this basis, the effective stress of the damage unit cells and the crack propagation damage equation were incorporated into the rock meso-structure static equilibrium equation, and the effect of nonlinear deformation in the soft rock compaction stage was considered to establish a rock damage constitutive model based on mesoscopic crack propagation evolution. Finally, methods for determining model parameters were proposed, and the effects of the model parameters on rock stress–strain curves were explored. The results showed that the theoretical model calculations agreed well with the experimental results, thus verifying the rationality of the damage constitutive model and the clear physical meaning of the model parameters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025damage,
  author = {Shengnan Li and Yang Hao and Yu Li and Xianglong Liu and Jun-Hao Tan and Y. B. Guo and Qiao Liang and Yaqian Shen and Xingxing Wei and Cun‐Gen Ma},
  title = {{A Damage Constitutive Model for Rock Considering Crack Propagation Under Uniaxial Compression}},
  booktitle = {Modelling—International},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/modelling6040116},
}
Figure