A Cultural Philosophical Study of Wushu's Modernization and the Basis of Its Universal Value

Zhanyu LiuInternational Journal of Sport and Health Science 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study examines the public debate triggered by private folk fights in recent years and the failure of wushu to become an Olympic sport. The study highlights that the root causes of traditional wushu's crises of practicality and authenticity are related to the essential nature of sport wushu. Since modern times, to become a so-called “living tradition,” wushu has continuously remade its value orientation. However, the modernized version of traditional wushu and sport wushu have the following problems: both are losing or have lost the original essence of Chinese martial arts. After analyzing the crisis faced by wushu from the perspective of the cultural philosophy of intimacy/integrity, this study proposes that the modernization of wushu and the invention of its universal value should be based on its particularity.

Introduction: The Identity Crisis of Modern Wushu

Wushu, the traditional Chinese martial art, currently finds itself at a crossroads. On one side, "traditional Wushu" faces a crisis of practicality. High-profile defeats of traditional masters by amateur MMA fighters have gone viral on social media, leading to widespread public skepticism regarding the art's combat effectiveness. On the other side, "sport Wushu" has repeatedly failed to secure a spot in the Olympic Games, often due to criticisms of its subjective and opaque judging systems.

This research argues that these issues are not merely technical or regulatory but are rooted in a fundamental philosophical mismatch. In the effort to modernize and globalize, Wushu has attempted to fit into a Westernized framework of "objective" competition, inadvertently stripping away the "intimate" cultural essence that defines it. By trying to become a "universal" sport, Wushu has risked losing the very particularity that gives it value.

Theoretical Framework: Intimacy vs. Integrity

The study utilizes Thomas P. Kasulis’s cultural philosophical framework of "Intimacy vs. Integrity" to diagnose Wushu's identity crisis. This framework provides a lens through which we can understand how different cultures conceptualize knowledge and value.

  • The Integrity Model: Predominant in Western thought, this model views knowledge as external, objective, and publicly verifiable. In the context of sports, this translates to measurable metrics like time, distance, or weight. The relationship between the knower and the known is external and interchangeable.
  • The Intimacy Model: Common in many Eastern traditions, this model views knowledge as internal, tacit, and accessible only through lived experience and mentorship. Value is found in "inward transcendence"—the relationship between the practitioner, nature, and ethics. This knowledge is non-interchangeable; it belongs to the specific person who has cultivated it.

Historical Context: The Post-Boxer Rebellion Shift

The modernization of Wushu began as a response to national trauma. Following the Boxer Rebellion (1899-1901), where traditional mystical beliefs and physical practices failed against modern weaponry, there was a desperate push to make Wushu "scientific" and "nationalist."

This shift aimed to transform Wushu into a tool for mass physical education, but it required the marginalization of the internal, sensation-based aspects of the practice (such as Qi and internal alchemy) in favor of external, gymnastic-like movements. This "wholesale Westernization" was intended to prove that Wushu could be a modern sport, but it effectively uprooted the art from its philosophical foundations.

The Epistemological Clash: The 0.05-Point Problem

The tension between Intimacy and Integrity is most visible in the Rules for International Wushu Taolu Competition. In an "Integrity-based" sport like sprinting, a 0.05-second difference is objectively measured by a clock. In Wushu, a 0.05-point difference in a score (e.g., 9.5 vs. 9.55) relies on the "tacit knowledge" of expert judges evaluating subjective criteria like "rhythm," "style," and "spirit."

To an outsider or an Olympic committee member, this appears unscientific and lacks transparency. To an insider, however, this subjective evaluation is the only way to judge the "intimate" skill of the athlete. By trying to quantify these subjective qualities into a pseudo-objective scoring system, Wushu satisfies neither the traditionalists—who find the modern forms hollow and performative—nor the modernists, who find the system unscientific and prone to bias.

Conclusion: Reclaiming Particularity

The study concludes that Wushu’s failure to achieve Olympic status or maintain its traditional reputation stems from its attempt to mimic Western sports to prove its "universal value." In doing so, Wushu lost its unique cultural subjectivity.

The path forward lies not in further refining rules to meet Western standards of objectivity, but in embracing Wushu's particularity. Its true universal value is found in its unique understanding of the human body and its relationship to the world through the lens of "intimacy." Future modernization efforts must focus on creating a value system that respects "intimate knowledge" while still functioning within a globalized society, rather than continuing the cycle of hollow Westernization.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study examines the public debate triggered by private folk fights in recent years and the failure of wushu to become an Olympic sport. The study highlights that the root causes of traditional wushu's crises of practicality and authenticity of are related to the essential nature of sport wushu. Since modern times, to become a so-called “living tradition,” wushu has continuously remade its value orientation. However, the modernized version of traditional wushu and sport wushu have the following problems: both are losing or have lost the original essence of Chinese martial arts. After analyzing the crisis faced by wushu from the perspective of the cultural philosophy of intimacy/integrity, this study proposes that the modernization of wushu and the invention of its universal value should be based on its particularity.
BibTeX
@article{liu2022cultural,
  author = {Zhanyu Liu},
  title = {{A Cultural Philosophical Study of Wushu's Modernization and the Basis of Its Universal Value}},
  journal = {International Journal of Sport and Health Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5432/ijshs.202129},
}
Figure