A cross-sectional study on the need for and utilization of assistive walking devices by people age 55 and older in Shanghai

Wendi Cheng, Yifan Cao, Hua Wang, Xin Peng, Chunyan Xie, Changying Wang, Duo Chen, Lingshan Wan, Jia Xue, Yunwei Zhang, Hongyun Xin, Wei Zhuang, Hansheng DingBioScience 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a significant gap in elderly care in Shanghai: nearly 43% of seniors who need assistive walking devices (like canes or wheelchairs) do not use them. The research identifies critical social and environmental barriers—such as living only with a spouse or residing in community health centers—that prevent the elderly from accessing tools essential for their mobility and safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China is facing a rapid "silver tsunami," with Shanghai at the forefront of this demographic shift. As the population ages, the prevalence of physical disabilities and mobility issues naturally rises. Assistive walking devices (AWDs) are vital for maintaining independence and preventing falls, yet their actual utilization remains poorly understood in the Chinese context.

The authors set out to quantify the "unmet need"—the gap between those who clinically require a walking aid and those who actually use one. By identifying the specific risk factors that lead to this gap, the study aims to provide a roadmap for policymakers and engineers to improve the accessibility, affordability, and social acceptance of these technologies.

Methods

The researchers conducted a large-scale cross-sectional survey across all 16 districts of Shanghai between July and October 2019.

  • Screening: They used a multi-stage screening process. First, they assessed physical and cognitive health using standardized tools like the Barthel Index (for daily living activities) and the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE).
  • Exclusions: To ensure the data focused on those who could benefit from AWDs, they excluded individuals who were bedridden, blind, or had severe cognitive impairments.
  • Statistical Analysis: After collecting data from over 11,000 participants, the team employed logistic regression analysis. They used univariate analysis to find broad correlations and multivariate analysis to isolate the specific factors (like residence type, disease count, and living situation) that independently influenced unmet needs.

Datasets

The study relied on a primary dataset generated specifically for this research:

  • Sample Size: 14,944 questionnaires were distributed, with 11,193 valid subjects remaining after exclusions.
  • Demographics: Participants were aged 55 and older, living in both community settings and nursing homes.
  • Benchmarks: While the study generated its own data, it compared Shanghai’s utilization rates (13.15%) against previous studies in other Chinese provinces (10.9%) and the United States (16.6%).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Spouse as a Crutch" Phenomenon: One of the most striking findings was that seniors living only with their spouse were 2.9 times more likely to have an unmet need for a device compared to those living alone. The authors suggest that spouses often act as "human walking aids," which may delay the adoption of actual mechanical devices.
  • The Institutional Gap: Seniors in community health centers had significantly higher unmet needs than those in private dwellings. This suggests that even in "care-focused" environments, the focus may be more on medical treatment than on mobility and independence.
  • Severity Drives Utilization: Counterintuitively, those with more diseases (3+) or severe impairments in Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADL)—tasks like shopping or managing money—were less likely to have an unmet need. Essentially, when a disability becomes severe enough that it can no longer be ignored or compensated for by family, the elderly are finally pushed to use a device.
  • The Stigma and Quality Barrier: The paper highlights that many seniors have a low "self-perceived need," likely due to the social stigma of looking "old" or "disabled." Furthermore, the authors critique the current market, noting that domestic devices are often low-quality imitations of foreign products, lacking the performance and diversity needed to appeal to users.

Key Results

  • Utilization vs. Need: 13.15% of the total sample used an AWD, but 17.39% actually needed one.
  • The Unmet Need Rate: Among those who needed a device, 42.58% were not using one.
  • Significant Risk Factors:
    • Living with spouse: OR = 2.901 (95% CI: 1.641–5.126).
  • Community health center residence: OR = 1.956 (95% CI: 1.171–3.267).
  • Protective Factors (Lower Unmet Need):
    • Severe IADL impairment: OR = 0.139 (95% CI: 0.05–0.386).
  • 3+ diseases: OR = 0.577 (95% CI: 0.418–0.796).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Cross-Sectional Nature: The study provides a snapshot in time, meaning it can show correlations but cannot definitively prove that one factor causes the lack of device use.
  2. Self-Reporting Bias: Data relied on questionnaires, which can be influenced by the participants' memory or desire to appear more independent.
  3. Economic Barriers: While the study mentions affordability, it notes that AWDs are currently not covered by most insurance in China, representing a major hurdle for future policy.

Future Work: The researchers call for better education to heighten "self-awareness of need" among the elderly, improved diversity and performance in device manufacturing, and the integration of assistive devices into national insurance schemes to improve affordability.

Summary updated

Abstract

We conducted a study to analyze the unmet needs of and risk factors for use of assistive walking devices by the elderly based on sample survey data from Shanghai, China from July to October 2019. Among a total sample size of 11,193 people age 55 and older, 1,947 people (17.39%) needed assistive walking devices, 829 (42.58%) of whom needed but did not use those devices. Multivariate analysis indicated that residence, living alone or cohabitating, indoor handrails, the number of diseases, and IADL were factors influencing the unmet need for assistive walking devices (p < 0.05, respectively). People who lived in community health centers (p = 0.0104, OR = 1.956, 95% CI: 1.171-3.267) and those who lived only with their spouse (p = 0.0002, OR = 2.901, 95% CI: 1.641-5.126) were more likely to have an unmet need for assistive walking devices. People without indoor handrails (p = 0.0481, OR = 0.718, 95% CI: 0.517-0.997), those with 3 or more diseases (p = 0.0008, OR = 0.577, 95% CI: 0.418-0.796), and those with severely impaired IADL (p = 0.0002, OR = 0.139, 95% CI: 0.05-0.386) were less likely to have an unmet need for assistive walking devices. Self-perceived needs of the elderly, the diversity and performance of assistive devices, and the accessibility and affordability of assistive walking devices may lead to unmet needs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2023cross,
  author = {Wendi Cheng and Yifan Cao and Hua Wang and Xin Peng and Chunyan Xie and Changying Wang and Duo Chen and Lingshan Wan and Jia Xue and Yunwei Zhang and Hongyun Xin and Wei Zhuang and Hansheng Ding},
  title = {{A cross-sectional study on the need for and utilization of assistive walking devices by people age 55 and older in Shanghai}},
  booktitle = {BioScience},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5582/bst.2022.01515},
}
Figure