A cross-organism framework for supervised enhancer prediction with epigenetic pattern recognition and targeted validation

Anurag Sethi, Mengting Gu, Emrah Gümüşgöz, Landon L. Chan, Koon‐Kiu Yan, Joel Rozowsky, Iros Barozzi, Veena Afzal, Jennifer A. Akiyama, Ingrid Plajzer-Frick, Chengfei Yan, Catherine S. Pickle, Momoe Kato, Tyler H. Garvin, Quan Pham, Anne I. Harrington, Brandon J. Mannion, Elizabeth Lee, Yoko Fukuda-Yuzawa, Axel Visel, Diane E. Dickel, Kevin Yip, Richard E. Sutton, L Pennacchio, Mark GersteinbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, cross-organism framework for predicting gene enhancers using epigenetic patterns. By leveraging data from Drosophila and applying machine learning, they developed a model that accurately identifies enhancers in mammals (mouse and human) and can distinguish them from promoters based on transcription factor binding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Identifying gene enhancers, crucial noncoding elements that regulate gene expression, has been a significant challenge. Traditionally, experimental validation of enhancers is laborious, leading to a scarcity of data for training predictive models. This lack of data has historically forced researchers to rely on heuristic approaches based on observed genomic features, which often lack generalizability. The advent of high-throughput assays like STARR-seq has enabled the characterization of thousands of enhancers, providing a richer dataset to overcome these limitations. However, a key challenge remains in developing models that can accurately predict enhancers across different species and cell types without extensive re-training.

Methods

The core of this work is a shape-matching and filtering approach applied to epigenetic data. Instead of just looking for signal peaks (like in previous methods), the authors developed a way to identify specific "double peak" patterns in histone modification signals (e.g., H3K27ac) that are characteristic of active regulatory regions.

  1. Metaprofile Creation: They aggregated epigenetic signals around thousands of experimentally validated enhancers (from Drosophila STARR-seq data) to create "metaprofiles" that capture these characteristic shapes, effectively increasing the signal-to-noise ratio.
  2. Matched Filtering: These metaprofiles were then used as "filters" to scan entire genomes, identifying regions that exhibit similar epigenetic patterns.
  3. Machine Learning Integration: The scores from these matched filters, along with other epigenetic features, were fed into supervised machine learning models, specifically Support Vector Machines (SVMs), to build predictive models.
  4. Cross-Organism Transferability: A key innovation is demonstrating that a model trained on Drosophila data could be effectively applied to predict enhancers in mouse and human without significant re-parameterization, highlighting the conserved nature of epigenetic patterns.
  5. TF Binding Analysis: They further analyzed transcription factor (TF) binding patterns at predicted enhancers and promoters to build a secondary model that could distinguish between these two types of regulatory elements.

Datasets

  • Drosophila STARR-seq data: Used extensively for training the initial models and creating metaprofiles.
  • Mouse ENCODE and Roadmap Epigenomics data: Used for tissue-specific epigenetic signals to predict enhancers in mouse.
  • VISTA Enhancer Browser data: Used for validating mouse enhancer predictions.
  • Human ENCODE data: Used for epigenetic signals in human cell lines for prediction.
  • ENCODE and Roadmap Epigenomics ChIP-seq data for H1-hESC cells: Used for analyzing TF binding patterns.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather leverages existing large-scale datasets to build and validate its model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Epigenetic "Shapes" Matter: The paper highlights that the pattern or shape of epigenetic signals, not just the presence of peaks, is highly informative for identifying regulatory elements. This is a departure from previous methods that focused primarily on signal enrichment.
  • Cross-Species Conservation is Powerful: The remarkable success of transferring a model trained on Drosophila data to predict enhancers in mammals underscores the deep evolutionary conservation of epigenetic mechanisms that govern gene regulation. This allows for building robust models with less species-specific data.
  • TF Binding Heterogeneity Distinguishes Enhancers: The study reveals that enhancers exhibit more heterogeneous TF binding patterns compared to promoters, which tend to bind to a more conserved set of TFs. This difference is a powerful feature for distinguishing between the two.
  • A Universal Framework is Achievable: The development of a transferable, six-parameter SVM model demonstrates the feasibility of a generalized framework for enhancer prediction across diverse cell types and species.

Key Results

  • The developed framework achieved high prediction accuracy, with AUROC values around 0.96 and AUPR values around 0.91 for predicting STARR-seq peaks using multiple core promoters.
  • The model demonstrated strong performance in predicting enhancers in six mouse tissues (AUROC ~0.76-0.85) and four human cell lines (e.g., H1-hESCs, with 16 out of 20 tested predictions showing statistically significant increases in reporter gene expression).
  • The cross-organism model trained on Drosophila data performed as well as or better than models trained directly on mouse data for predicting mouse enhancers.
  • A secondary model based on TF binding patterns could distinguish enhancers from promoters with high accuracy (AUROC = 0.87, AUPR = 0.90).
  • The framework outperformed other computational methods like ChromHMM in mouse enhancer prediction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Episomal Nature of STARR-seq: The authors acknowledge that STARR-seq, being episomal, might not fully capture the nuances of enhancer activity in the native chromatin environment.
  • Potential Biases in Training Data: While efforts were made to mitigate bias, the selection of STARR-seq peaks based on H3K27ac and DHS signals could introduce subtle biases.
  • Cell Specificity: While the model is designed for cell-type specificity, the validation in human cell lines showed that some predicted enhancers were cell-specific, meaning their activity might not be universal.
  • Future Work: The authors envision re-training the model with more extensive, whole-genome STARR-seq datasets as they become available for mammalian systems. They also suggest that their framework can be extended to generate more comprehensive regulatory element annotations across eukaryotic species. Further exploration of TF binding patterns could lead to identifying key TFs associated with active regulatory regions in specific cell types.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Enhancers are important noncoding elements, but they have been traditionally hard to characterize experimentally. Only a few mammalian enhancers have been validated, making it difficult to train statistical models for their identification properly. Instead, postulated patterns of genomic features have been used heuristically for identification. The development of massively parallel assays allows for the characterization of large numbers of enhancers for the first time. Here, we developed a framework that uses Drosophila STARR-seq data to create shape-matching filters based on enhancer-associated meta-profiles of epigenetic features. We combined these features with supervised machine learning algorithms (e.g., support vector machines) to predict enhancers. We demonstrated that our model could be applied to predict enhancers in mammalian species (i.e., mouse and human). We comprehensively validated the predictions using a combination of in vivo and in vitro approaches, involving transgenic assays in mouse and transduction-based reporter assays in human cell lines. Overall, the validations involved 153 enhancers in 6 mouse tissues and 4 human cell lines. The results confirmed that our model can accurately predict enhancers in different species without re-parameterization. Finally, we examined the transcription-factor binding patterns at predicted enhancers and promoters in human cell lines. We demonstrated that these patterns enable the construction of a secondary model effectively discriminating between enhancers and promoters.
BibTeX
@misc{sethi2018cross,
  author = {Anurag Sethi and Mengting Gu and Emrah Gümüşgöz and Landon L. Chan and Koon‐Kiu Yan and Joel Rozowsky and Iros Barozzi and Veena Afzal and Jennifer A. Akiyama and Ingrid Plajzer-Frick and Chengfei Yan and Catherine S. Pickle and Momoe Kato and Tyler H. Garvin and Quan Pham and Anne I. Harrington and Brandon J. Mannion and Elizabeth Lee and Yoko Fukuda-Yuzawa and Axel Visel and Diane E. Dickel and Kevin Yip and Richard E. Sutton and L Pennacchio and Mark Gerstein},
  title = {{A cross-organism framework for supervised enhancer prediction with epigenetic pattern recognition and targeted validation}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/385237},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure