Abstract: We investigate the effect of the surface electronic structure and composition of $LiMn_2O_4$ nanoparticles on the electrocatalytic oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) studies combined with density functional theory (DFT) based simulations of the EEL spectra reveal in pristine nanoparticles a 4 nm thick surface layer with reduced average Mn oxidation state and increased Mn concentration. This is attributed to $Mn^{2+}$ partially replacing $Li^+$ at the tetrahedral sites of the spinel lattice accompanied by Mn 3d-state filling of octahedrally coordinated Mn. During electrocatalytic OER cycling, this near-surface tetrahedral Mn is leached out, thereby increasing the oxidation state of octahedrally coordinated Mn. Using rotating ring-disc electrode (RRDE) based detection of O and Mn during the OER, we show that the oxygen evolution remains constant while the $Mn^{2+}$ is removed, revealing that near-surface tetrahedrally coordinated Mn has no effect on the OER activity of $LiMn_2O_4$. This is surprising since the $e_g$ occupancy of Mn in octahedral sites, which is widely used as a descriptor of OER activity, changes significantly in the surface layer during cycling. The fact that $e_g$ emptying fails to correlate with OER activity here indicates that octahedral cation valence is not a fundamental measure of activity, either because the active surface state is not affected by tetrahedral Mn or because other details of the band structure or metal-oxygen bonding character, more strongly regulate the rate-limiting steps for OER.
Introduction
The search for universal descriptors to predict the catalytic performance of transition metal oxides in the Oxygen Evolution Reaction (OER) is a central theme in electrocatalysis. Among these, the $e_g$ occupancy of surface metal cations has emerged as a prominent metric, particularly for perovskite and spinel oxides. The prevailing theory suggests that an $e_g$ occupancy near unity optimizes the adsorption strength of oxygen intermediates, thereby maximizing catalytic activity. However, most experimental validations of this descriptor rely on bulk characterization, which may not accurately reflect the dynamic and often distinct electronic state of the catalyst surface during operation.
Methodology
This study employs a multi-modal approach to probe the surface of $LiMn_2O_4$ nanoparticles (size < 0.5 µm). Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) coupled with Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (EELS) provided nanometer-scale resolution of the Mn oxidation state. These experimental spectra were compared against a library of Density Functional Theory (DFT) simulated EEL fingerprints to identify specific atomic site occupancies. Furthermore, Rotating Ring-Disc Electrode (RRDE) measurements were utilized to simultaneously monitor the OER current (at the disc) and the leaching of Mn species (at the ring) in real-time.
The Core-Shell Structure of Pristine Nanoparticles
A key finding of this work is the inherent non-uniformity of pristine $LiMn_2O_4$ nanoparticles. STEM-EELS mapping revealed a 4 nm thick surface "shell" characterized by a significantly reduced Mn oxidation state compared to the bulk "core."
DFT simulations suggest this surface reduction is driven by the presence of $Mn^{2+}$ ions occupying tetrahedral sites, effectively replacing $Li^+$. This defect structure, modeled as $[Li_{0.5}Mn_{0.5}]_T Mn_2O_4$, results in an average Mn valence of approximately 2.9+ at the surface, compared to the expected 3.5+ in the stoichiometric bulk.
Surface Dynamics and the Descriptor Disconnect
Upon electrochemical cycling in the OER region, the surface of the $LiMn_2O_4$ nanoparticles undergoes significant transformation. The near-surface tetrahedral $Mn^{2+}$ ions are leached into the electrolyte, a process captured by the ring current in RRDE measurements. As these ions leave, the remaining octahedral Mn ions at the surface oxidize to maintain charge neutrality, shifting the average valence from ~2.9+ toward 3.5+ or higher.
Crucially, despite this substantial change in surface Mn valence—and consequently a significant shift in $e_g$ occupancy—the OER current density remains remarkably stable across the cycles. This observation directly challenges the role of $e_g$ occupancy as a fundamental regulator of OER activity in this system. If $e_g$ occupancy were the primary driver, the activity should have changed drastically as the surface oxidized.
Conclusion
The decoupling of surface oxidation state from catalytic activity in $LiMn_2O_4$ suggests that $e_g$ occupancy may be a correlative rather than a causative descriptor for OER in manganese spinels. The results indicate that the rate-limiting steps of the OER might be governed by other electronic factors, such as metal-oxygen bond covalency or specific features of the band structure, which remain relatively unaffected by the leaching of tetrahedral Mn. This work highlights the necessity of surface-sensitive, operando characterization to truly understand and predict the behavior of electrocatalytic interfaces.
Summary updated