A CRISPR toolbox for generating intersectional genetic mice for functional, molecular, and anatomical circuit mapping

Savannah Lusk, Andrew McKinney, Patrick J. Hunt, Paul G. Fahey, Jay Patel, Andersen Chang, Jenny J. Sun, Vena K. Martinez, Ping Zhu, Jeremy R. Egbert, Genevera I. Allen, Xiaolong Jiang, Benjamin R. Arenkiel, Andreas S. Tolias, Mauro Costa‐Mattioli, Russell RaybioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a simplified CRISPR-based toolkit for rapidly and affordably generating "intersectional" genetic mouse lines. This technology allows researchers to precisely control gene expression in specific cell populations, enabling more detailed studies of neural circuits and other biological systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding complex biological systems, especially neural circuits, requires studying individual cell types and their interactions. Traditional methods often lack the precision to isolate and manipulate specific cell populations, especially in developing or hard-to-access tissues. While recombinase-based systems (like Cre-Lox) offer some control, achieving highly specific targeting often involves expensive and time-consuming generation of custom mouse lines. This limits widespread application, particularly for common genetic manipulations. The authors aim to overcome these limitations by providing a more accessible and efficient method for creating these specialized mouse lines.

Methods

The core of this work is a simplified CRISPR/Cas9 toolkit designed for rapid and cost-effective generation of intersectional alleles. Key aspects include:

  • Modular Vector Design: They developed a set of versatile targeting vectors for the Rosa26 locus, which is known for its ubiquitous expression. These vectors are designed for easy cloning of desired effector genes.
  • CRISPR/Cas9 for Homologous Recombination: They utilized CRISPR/Cas9 to enhance the efficiency of inserting these targeting vectors into the Rosa26 locus in mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells. This approach allows for precise gene editing.
  • Optimized Homology Arms: The homology arms used for recombination were significantly shortened (to 1-1.2 kb) compared to previous methods. This simplification improved vector stability and ease of construction without sacrificing targeting efficiency.
  • Multiplexed Electroporation: They demonstrated the ability to co-electroporate multiple targeting vectors simultaneously into ES cells, significantly increasing throughput and reducing costs.
  • Simplified Selection Cassettes: They streamlined the selection process by removing unnecessary components like the DTA negative selection cassette, making vector validation easier.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CRISPR as a Game-Changer for Genetic Tools: The paper highlights how CRISPR/Cas9 technology can be leveraged not just for gene editing, but also to dramatically improve the efficiency and accessibility of generating complex genetic tools like intersectional mouse lines.
  • Shortening Homology Arms is Effective: Contrary to potential expectations, shortening homology arms in the targeting vectors did not negatively impact targeting efficiency in ES cells, simplifying vector construction and improving stability.
  • Multiplexing for Efficiency: The ability to deliver and integrate multiple targeting vectors in a single electroporation step is a significant advancement for high-throughput generation of diverse genetic alleles.
  • Broad Applicability Beyond Neuroscience: While the paper focuses heavily on neural circuit mapping, the developed toolkit is presented as broadly applicable to studying various cell types and systems throughout the body.

Key Results

  • Efficient Targeting: They achieved targeting efficiencies of up to 58% in ES cells using their optimized CRISPR/Cas9 approach with shortened homology arms and a 10:1 Cas9/targeting vector ratio.
  • Multiplexed Targeting Success: They successfully co-electroporated five different targeting vectors into ES cells, achieving an overall targeting efficiency of 52% and demonstrating the ability to generate complex alleles in a single step.
  • Generation of Diverse Lines: They produced 11 intersectional or Dre-responsive alleles, including 8 mouse lines and 3 ES cell lines, with various effector molecules (fluorescent reporters, DREADDs, calcium sensors).
  • Functional Validation: They demonstrated the utility of their lines in vivo by mapping neural circuits involved in respiratory control and studying hormone effects on calcium release in ovarian follicles.
  • Open Access: All generated tools, vectors, and mouse/ES cell lines are made publicly available for non-commercial use.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Oocyte Targeting Inefficiency: Direct oocyte injection for targeting was found to be inefficient (<1% success rate) with the current parameters, suggesting a need for further optimization or development of new technologies for this application.
  • Off-Target Effects: While they performed off-target analysis and found no mutations in the top 5 predicted sites, they acknowledge that off-target effects in other loci cannot be entirely ruled out.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize that their toolkit enables the generation of a wide range of effector molecules in various cell types, facilitating developmental, anatomical, molecular, and functional characterization of cellular organization. They envision this technology being used to investigate most, if not all, neural circuits and other systems for research into development, disease, and complex biological processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Background A full understanding of circuits and cellular mechanisms governing health and disease requires the dissection and multi-faceted study of discrete cell subtypes in developing and adult animal models. Recombinase-driven expression of transgenic response alleles represents a significant and powerful approach to delineate cell populations for functional, molecular, and anatomical study. In addition to single recombinase systems, the expression of two recombinases in distinct, but partially overlapping, populations allow for more defined target expression. Although the application of this method is becoming increasingly popular, the expense and difficulty associated with production of customized intersectional mouse lines have limited widespread application to more common allele manipulations that are often commercially produced at great expense. Results We present a simplified CRISPR toolkit for rapid, inexpensive, and facile intersectional allele production. Briefly, we produced 7 intersectional mouse lines using a dual recombinase system, one mouse line with a single recombinase system, and three embryonic stem (ES) cell lines that are designed to study how functional, molecular, and anatomical features relate to each other in building circuits that underlie physiology and behavior. As a proof-of-principle, we applied three of these lines to different neuronal populations for anatomical mapping and functional in vivo investigation of respiratory control. We also generated a mouse line with a single recombinase-responsive allele that controls the expression of the calcium sensor Twitch-2B. This mouse line was applied globally to study the effects of follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing hormone (LH) on calcium release in the ovarian follicle. Conclusions Lines presented here are representative examples of outcomes possible with the successful application of our genetic toolkit for the facile development of diverse, modifiable animal models. This toolkit will allow labs to create single or dual recombinase effector lines easily for any cell population or subpopulation of interest when paired with the appropriate Cre and FLP recombinase mouse lines or viral vectors. We have made our tools and derivative intersectional mouse and ES cell lines openly available for non-commercial use through publicly curated repositories for plasmid DNA, ES cells, and transgenic mouse lines.
BibTeX
@misc{lusk2021crispr,
  author = {Savannah Lusk and Andrew McKinney and Patrick J. Hunt and Paul G. Fahey and Jay Patel and Andersen Chang and Jenny J. Sun and Vena K. Martinez and Ping Zhu and Jeremy R. Egbert and Genevera I. Allen and Xiaolong Jiang and Benjamin R. Arenkiel and Andreas S. Tolias and Mauro Costa‐Mattioli and Russell Ray},
  title = {{A CRISPR toolbox for generating intersectional genetic mice for functional, molecular, and anatomical circuit mapping}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.06.10.447908},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure