A Credit Risk Contagion Intensity Model of Supply Chain Enterprises under Different Credit Modes

Yuhao Wang, Jiaxian Shen, Jinnan Pan, Tingqiang ChenSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a model to quantify how credit default risk spreads through supply chains, considering different financing methods like trade credit and bank loans. It reveals that factors like supplier production costs and retailer repayment priorities significantly influence this contagion, offering insights for managing financial stability in supply chains.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Supply chain finance, while crucial for business operations, introduces complex interdependencies that can amplify financial risks. When one company defaults on its debts, this "contagion" can spread rapidly through the network, potentially destabilizing the entire supply chain and hindering sustainable development. Existing research has often focused on individual financing strategies, but this paper aims to systematically model and analyze the intensity of credit default risk contagion across different supply chain financing structures, specifically comparing single-channel (e.g., only trade credit) and dual-channel (e.g., trade credit and bank credit) models for retailers. Understanding these contagion mechanisms is vital for effective financial risk management.

Methods

The authors employ a theoretical modeling approach based on Stackelberg game theory to analyze the decision-making processes of suppliers, retailers, and commercial banks within a supply chain. They construct mathematical models to represent two primary credit financing scenarios for retailers: a single-channel model where retailers rely solely on trade credit from suppliers, and a dual-channel model where retailers can access both trade credit and bank credit. The core of their methodology involves defining and calculating a "credit default risk contagion intensity" metric (denoted by β). This metric is then analyzed through computational simulations using MATLAB to explore the impact of various parameters on contagion intensity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and simulation rather than empirical data from real-world supply chains.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Supplier Production Costs Fuel Contagion: Higher supplier production costs directly increase the intensity of credit default risk contagion. This is because suppliers pass these costs on as higher wholesale prices, squeezing retailer profit margins and increasing their risk of defaulting on trade credit.
  • Retailer Repayment Priority is Key: How retailers choose to prioritize their debt repayments (bank credit vs. trade credit) is a critical determinant of contagion. Prioritizing trade credit repayment to suppliers reduces contagion intensity, as it stabilizes the supplier's financial position.
  • Market Price Matters: A higher market retail price for products acts as a buffer against contagion. It increases retailer profit margins, making them less likely to default on trade credit, thus dampening the ripple effect of risk.
  • Bank Risk-Free Rates Amplify Risk: Higher risk-free rates for commercial banks increase the cost of credit for suppliers, which in turn raises trade credit costs for retailers, escalating contagion risk.
  • Dual-Channel Financing Offers Nuance: In dual-channel models, retailer repayment priority significantly influences supplier wholesale prices and retailer order quantities. Prioritizing suppliers can lead to lower wholesale prices and increased order volumes, fostering collaboration.

Key Results

  • Positive Correlations: Supplier production cost, commercial bank risk-free rate, and retailer trade credit interest rate all positively correlate with credit default risk contagion intensity.
  • Negative Correlations: Market retail price and retailer repayment priority (especially prioritizing trade credit) negatively correlate with contagion intensity.
  • Simulation Findings: Figures illustrate these relationships, showing, for instance, how increasing supplier production costs (c) leads to higher contagion intensity (β), and how increasing retailer repayment priority (θ) decreases contagion intensity. The study also quantifies the impact of retailer bank credit ratios (α) on these dynamics.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study is based on a simplified supply chain model (one supplier, multiple retailers) and assumes rational actors. Future work could explore more complex network structures, imperfect rationality, and the impact of external shocks. The paper's findings provide a theoretical foundation for risk management, but empirical validation would be a valuable next step. The authors suggest that their work offers insights for policymakers to strengthen supply chain financial risk management and maintain national financial security.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rapid development of theoretical and practical innovations in corporate finance driven by supply chain finance has exacerbated the complexity of credit default risk contagion among supply chain enterprises. Financial risks in the supply chain greatly hinder its sustainable development; thus, strengthening financial risk management is necessary to ensure the sustainability of the supply chain. Based on the single-channel and dual-channel credit financing models of retailers in the supply chain, the purpose of this paper was to construct a model of the intensity of credit default risk contagion among supply chain enterprises under different credit financing models, and investigate the influencing factors of credit risk contagion among supply chain enterprises and its mechanism of action through a computational simulation system. The results were as follows: (1) there was a positive relationship between the production cost of suppliers and the contagion intensity of the supply chain credit default risk, and the contagion effect of the supply chain credit default risk increased significantly when both retailers defaulted on trade credit to suppliers; (2) the market retail price of the product was negatively related to the contagion intensity of the supply chain credit default risk, and the contagion intensity of the supply chain credit default risk increased significantly when both retailers defaulted on trade credit to the supplier; (3) the intensity of credit default risk contagion in the supply chain was positively correlated with both the commercial bank risk-free rate and the trade credit rate, and retailers’ repayment priority on trade credit debt was negatively correlated with suppliers’ wholesale prices and positively correlated with retailers’ order volumes, with retailers’ repayment priority positively affecting retailers’ bank credit rates and negatively affecting suppliers’ bank credit rates; and (4) retailers’ repayment priority on trade credit debt was negatively correlated with the intensity of supply chain credit default risk contagion, and the lower the retailer’s bank credit limit, the higher the trade credit limit, and the stronger the credit default contagion effect in the supply chain.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022credit,
  author = {Yuhao Wang and Jiaxian Shen and Jinnan Pan and Tingqiang Chen},
  title = {{A Credit Risk Contagion Intensity Model of Supply Chain Enterprises under Different Credit Modes}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142013518},
}
Figure