A COVID-19 Model for Local Authorities of the United Kingdom

Swapnil Mishra, James A. Scott, Daniel J. Laydon, Harrison Zhu, Neil M. Ferguson, Samir Bhatt, Seth Flaxman, Axel GandyJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A (Statistics in Society) 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Bayesian modeling framework to track and project COVID-19 at the local authority level in the UK. By incorporating diverse data sources and a flexible random walk for the reproduction number, it provides daily, granular insights crucial for public health interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the critical need for localized epidemic tracking and forecasting. While national and regional data were available, understanding and responding to the epidemic at the sub-national level (local authorities) presented a significant challenge. This gap made it difficult to tailor interventions effectively, as transmission dynamics can vary considerably even within relatively small geographic areas. The authors aimed to bridge this gap by developing a model that could provide daily, localized estimates of infections and the reproduction number ($R_t$).

Methods

The core of the model is a semi-mechanistic Bayesian framework built upon renewal equations, a standard approach in epidemic modeling. However, the authors introduce several key innovations:

  • Incorporation of Reported Cases and Deaths: Unlike some earlier models that focused solely on deaths, this framework integrates both reported cases and deaths, providing a more comprehensive view of the epidemic.
  • Calibration with Survey Data: To estimate the unobserved number of true infections, the model leverages survey data (from the Office for National Statistics and the REACT study). This is crucial because reported cases and deaths only represent a fraction of actual infections.
  • Time-Varying Infection Fatality Ratio (IFR) and Infection Ascertainment Rate (IAR): The model accounts for the fact that the probability of an infection leading to death (IFR) and the probability of an infection being detected as a case (IAR) can change over time.
  • Latent Infection Modeling: Infections are treated as latent random variables, allowing for more accurate modeling of variability, especially in areas with low infection numbers.
  • Random Walk for Reproduction Number ($R_t$): A key innovation is the use of a random walk to model the time-varying reproduction number ($R_t$). This allows the model to adapt to changes in transmission intensity, including those driven by interventions or behavioral shifts, without explicitly modeling those interventions. This approach also helps to smooth out potentially sharp transitions in $R_t$.
  • Three-Stage Fitting Approach: The model is fitted in three stages:
  • National Calibration: IFR and IAR are first estimated at the national level for England using serosurveys.
  • Regional Fitting: Individual models are then fitted to regions of England and nations of the UK using aggregated data and the national IFR/IAR estimates as priors.
  • Local Authority Fitting: Finally, individual models are fitted for each local authority, using regional $R_t$ as a covariate and incorporating weekly random walks.

Datasets

The model utilizes a variety of publicly available datasets:

  • Reported Cases: Data from the UK Coronavirus dashboard (Public Health England), Public Health Wales, Department of Health (Northern Ireland), and Scottish Health and Social Care Open Data. The date of specimen collection is used for cases.
  • Reported Deaths: Data from the Office for National Statistics (England and Wales), Department of Health (Northern Ireland), and Scottish Health and Social Care Open Data.
  • Survey Data:
    • Office for National Statistics (ONS) Coronavirus (COVID-19) infection survey.
  • Real-time Assessment of Community Transmission (REACT) study.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather integrates existing, regularly updated data sources.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Granularity is Key: The paper strongly advocates for the importance of local-level data and modeling. National or even regional trends can mask significant variations at the local authority level, necessitating a more granular approach for effective public health response.
  • The Power of Latent Variables and Flexible $R_t$: Treating infections as latent and modeling $R_t$ with a random walk are crucial for capturing the complex dynamics of an epidemic. This allows the model to adapt to changing conditions and provides a more realistic representation of transmission.
  • Combining Data Sources is Essential: The success of the model hinges on its ability to integrate diverse data streams, from reported cases and deaths to survey data. This multi-faceted approach provides a more robust estimate of the true epidemic state.
  • Projections as Actionable Indicators: The paper emphasizes that projections of future cases, particularly "hotspot" predictions (areas likely to exceed a certain case threshold), are more actionable for policymakers than just current incidence or $R_t$ alone. This combines both the current state and the rate of change.

Key Results

  • The model provides daily updated results for local authorities across the UK.
  • It estimates time-varying infection fatality ratios (IFR) and infection ascertainment rates (IAR) for England, showing temporal trends in these crucial parameters.
  • The model's projections show a "reasonable correspondence" with reported case numbers, though exceptions are noted due to factors like new variants (e.g., Alpha) and interventions.
  • The model's output is actively used by the Scottish government to inform their epidemic response.
  • The paper presents visualizations of the probability of epidemic growth (based on $R_t$) and "hotspot" probabilities for local areas, demonstrating the model's ability to identify areas of concern.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Homogeneous Mixing Assumption: The model assumes homogeneous mixing within local authorities and age groups, which is a simplification of real-world population dynamics.
  • Constant Delay Distributions: Distributions for delays between infection and symptom onset, and symptom onset and death, are assumed to be constant, which may not always hold true.
  • Lag in Intervention Effects: Interventions are not explicitly modeled, meaning their effects may not be apparent in the $R_t$ estimates for 1-2 weeks after implementation due to the random walk smoothing. This also means sharp transitions due to measures can be smoothed.
  • No Joint Modeling of Regions: The authors deliberately avoided a joint model of all regions to manage computational demand and to ensure local decisions are primarily driven by local information. This means there's no explicit modeling of spatial correlation between neighboring areas.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future work could explore alternative formulations, such as making $R_t$ and ascertainment rates dependent on the time of infection rather than the current time. The authors also note that the model does not attempt to estimate the effect of policy changes or the emergence of new variants, which could be areas for future development.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a new framework to model the COVID-19 epidemic of the United Kingdom at the local authority level. The model fits within a general framework for semi-mechanistic Bayesian models of the epidemic based on renewal equations, with some important innovations, including a random walk modelling the reproduction number, incorporating information from different sources, including surveys to estimate the time-varying proportion of infections that lead to reported cases or deaths, and modelling the underlying infections as latent random variables. The model is designed to be updated daily using publicly available data. We envisage the model to be useful for now-casting and short-term projections of the epidemic as well as estimating historical trends. The model fits are available on a public website: https://imperialcollegelondon.github.io/covid19local. The model is currently being used by the Scottish government to inform their interventions.
BibTeX
@article{mishra2022covid,
  author = {Swapnil Mishra and James A. Scott and Daniel J. Laydon and Harrison Zhu and Neil M. Ferguson and Samir Bhatt and Seth Flaxman and Axel Gandy},
  title = {{A COVID-19 Model for Local Authorities of the United Kingdom}},
  journal = {Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A (Statistics in Society)},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1111/rssa.12988},
}
Figure