TL;DR
This study analyzes how sports science graduate students use "reporting verbs" (like argue, find, or suggest) to navigate the complex world of academic citation. By examining a corpus of American master’s theses, the researchers found that while students are proficient at reporting procedures and asserting facts, they often struggle with expressing critical stances, frequently falling back on a limited and repetitive vocabulary to avoid challenging established authorities.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Writing a literature review isn't just about listing what others have done; it’s a delicate rhetorical dance. Authors must use "reporting verbs" (RVs) to attribute information to sources while simultaneously signaling their own stance—whether they agree, doubt, or are staying neutral.
For graduate students, this is a major hurdle. They face an "authority imbalance" where they must cite world-class experts while trying to establish their own scholarly voice. This challenge is amplified in sports science, an interdisciplinary field that blends the rhetorical traditions of the natural and social sciences. Despite its importance, sports science has been largely neglected in "corpus linguistics" (the study of language through large datasets), leaving students and educators without discipline-specific guidance on how to use these critical linguistic tools.
Methods
The researchers adopted a corpus-based functional analysis. They collected 16 literature reviews from American sports science master’s theses published between 2020 and 2023.
To analyze the text, they used:
- AntConc 4.2.4: A professional corpus analysis software used to locate and extract citations.
- Hyland’s Taxonomy: A standard framework in applied linguistics that categorizes RVs into three "acts":
- Research Acts: Real-world experimental activities (e.g., observe, discover).
- Cognition Acts: The researcher's mental processes (e.g., believe, view).
- Discourse Acts: Verbal expressions of research (e.g., state, hypothesize).
The study combined quantitative data (how often verbs appeared) with qualitative analysis (how the verbs functioned in context).
Datasets
The study utilized a specialized, small-scale corpus:
- Source: 16 master's theses sourced from the ProQuest database.
- Size: 58,796 words.
- Scope: Specifically focused on the literature review sections of American sports science theses.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Safety of Discourse: Students heavily favor "Discourse Acts" (52.4% of all RVs). They prefer to talk about the act of reporting (e.g., "the author stated") rather than the mental state of the researcher or the physical experiment itself.
- The "Authority Imbalance": There was a near-total absence of "counter-verbs" or critical reporting. Students almost never used verbs like deny, attack, or challenge. The authors suggest this is because students are intimidated by the "gatekeepers" of the field and fear that explicit criticism might lead to "retaliation" or disapproval from thesis committees.
- Vocabulary "Poverty": Many students suffer from a restricted range of RVs. In some cases, just two phrases—call for and use—accounted for nearly 75% of all reporting verbs in a single review. This leads to monotonous, less convincing writing.
- Stance through "Assurance": When students do take a stand, they prefer "Assurance" verbs (like show or demonstrate). This allows them to present cited work as empirically validated and authoritative, effectively "borrowing" the credibility of the original author to support their own arguments.
Key Results
The quantitative breakdown of the 488 identified reporting verbs revealed a clear hierarchy:
- Discourse Acts (52.4%): The most frequent, dominated by "Assurance" verbs (43.8%) that present information as factive.
- Research Acts (36.7%): Used primarily to describe "Procedures" (19.5%) and "Findings" (17.2%).
- Cognition Acts (10.9%): The least frequent, suggesting students are less comfortable speculating on the mental processes or theories of other researchers.
- The "Critical Gap": Critical verbs in both cognition and discourse categories were nearly non-existent (0% to 0.2%), highlighting a significant lack of critical engagement with the literature.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the sample size is small (16 theses), which may limit the generalizability of the findings to the entire field of sports science. Additionally, the study focused exclusively on American theses, leaving a gap in how non-native English speakers or students in other regions handle these rhetorical challenges.
Future Work could involve:
- Expanding the corpus to include doctoral dissertations and published journal articles for a cross-genre comparison.
- Developing specific pedagogical tools and "scaffolding activities" to help sports science students move beyond repetitive verbs and gain the confidence to use more evaluative, critical language.
Summary updated