A Conserved Developmental Patterning Network Produces Quantitatively Different Output in Multiple Species of Drosophila

Charless C. Fowlkes, Kelly B. Eckenrode, Meghan D. J. Bragdon, Miriah Meyer, Zeba Wunderlich, Lisa Simirenko, Cris L. Luengo Hendriks, Soile V.e. Keränen, Clara Henriquez, David Knowles, Mark D. Biggin, Michael B. Eisen, Angela H. DePacePLoS 2011 · DOI

Introduction

A fundamental question in evolutionary biology is how conserved genetic networks can produce diverse organismal forms. While it is well-established that changes in the timing, location, and level of gene expression drive phenotypic evolution, comparing these patterns across species is challenging. Embryos of even closely related species often differ in size, shape, and nuclear density, making direct spatial comparisons difficult. This study addresses these challenges by examining the segmentation network in Drosophila embryos to determine how much gene regulatory networks vary over short evolutionary timescales.

Methodology

The researchers developed a high-resolution comparative framework using three Drosophila species: D. melanogaster, D. yakuba, and D. pseudoobscura.

Data Acquisition and Processing

Using two-photon microscopy and fluorescent in situ hybridization, the team captured the 3D spatial expression of 13 core anterior/posterior (AP) patterning genes at cellular resolution. The dataset included 616 D. yakuba embryos and 933 D. pseudoobscura embryos, which were integrated with a reference dataset of 2,772 D. melanogaster embryos.

Cellular Resolution Atlases

The raw images were segmented to identify individual nuclei, creating "pointclouds" where each nucleus serves as a data point with 3D coordinates and associated gene expression levels. Rather than using a single standard embryo, the authors constructed species-specific morphological frameworks.

Comparative Analysis

To compare cells across species while accounting for morphological variation, the authors developed an "expression distance score" based on the squared Euclidean distance between expression vectors. A local search algorithm was employed to find the "best match" for a cell in a target species within a neighborhood of its 30 nearest neighbors. This approach allowed for the quantification of positional shifts independently of absolute expression levels.

Results

The study revealed that while the core developmental network is conserved, its output varies significantly in both space and time.

Morphological and Positional Divergence

Embryo morphology does not scale linearly between species. For instance, D. pseudoobscura embryos are smaller but possess distinct internal nuclear density patterns rather than being simple miniatures of D. melanogaster. Every gene examined showed quantitative differences in spatial positioning, with expression patterns often shifting by 3 to 4 cell widths between species.

Conservation of Cellular Identity

Despite these positional shifts, the "transcriptional identity" of cells—defined by the combination of genes they express—is remarkably stable. Over 99.5% of cells in one species have a near-identical transcriptional counterpart in the others. This suggests that the fundamental "cell types" defined by the segmentation network are conserved across these species.

Evolution of Proportions

The most significant evolutionary change observed was in the allocation of cells to specific transcriptional states. The relative proportion of cells assigned to a particular "expression neighborhood" varied by as much as 5-fold between species. For example, D. melanogaster allocates significantly more cells to the posterior trunk region than its relatives.

Discussion

These findings demonstrate that transcriptional networks can diverge rapidly, leading to distinct outputs in terms of cell placement and number, even when the underlying cell types remain conserved. The study highlights that evolution often operates by altering the "dosage" and "spatial arrangement" of equivalent developmental units.

Future research is needed to pinpoint the specific cis-regulatory changes (enhancers) responsible for these shifts. Additionally, expanding this high-resolution analysis to a broader set of genes and later developmental stages will clarify whether the principle of conserved cellular identity holds as organismal complexity increases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Differences in the level, timing, or location of gene expression can contribute to alternative phenotypes at the molecular and organismal level. Understanding the origins of expression differences is complicated by the fact that organismal morphology and gene regulatory networks could potentially vary even between closely related species. To assess the scope of such changes, we used high-resolution imaging methods to measure mRNA expression in blastoderm embryos of Drosophila yakuba and Drosophila pseudoobscura and assembled these data into cellular resolution atlases, where expression levels for 13 genes in the segmentation network are averaged into species-specific, cellular resolution morphological frameworks. We demonstrate that the blastoderm embryos of these species differ in their morphology in terms of size, shape, and number of nuclei. We present an approach to compare cellular gene expression patterns between species, while accounting for varying embryo morphology, and apply it to our data and an equivalent dataset for Drosophila melanogaster. Our analysis reveals that all individual genes differ quantitatively in their spatio-temporal expression patterns between these species, primarily in terms of their relative position and dynamics. Despite many small quantitative differences, cellular gene expression profiles for the whole set of genes examined are largely similar. This suggests that cell types at this stage of development are conserved, though they can differ in their relative position by up to 3-4 cell widths and in their relative proportion between species by as much as 5-fold. Quantitative differences in the dynamics and relative level of a subset of genes between corresponding cell types may reflect altered regulatory functions between species. Our results emphasize that transcriptional networks can diverge over short evolutionary timescales and that even small changes can lead to distinct output in terms of the placement and number of equivalent cells.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fowlkes2011conserved,
  author = {Charless C. Fowlkes and Kelly B. Eckenrode and Meghan D. J. Bragdon and Miriah Meyer and Zeba Wunderlich and Lisa Simirenko and Cris L. Luengo Hendriks and Soile V.E. Keränen and Clara Henriquez and David Knowles and Mark D. Biggin and Michael B. Eisen and Angela H. DePace},
  title = {{A Conserved Developmental Patterning Network Produces Quantitatively Different Output in Multiple Species of Drosophila}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pgen.1002346},
}
Figure