A Computational Theory of the Function of Clue Words in Argument Understanding

Robin CohenACL 1984

TL;DR

This paper proposes a computational model for understanding arguments in dialogues, focusing on the role of "clue words" (like "therefore," "in addition," "as a result") that signal argument structure. The authors argue that these clues are essential for both simplifying processing in coherent arguments and enabling understanding of complex, non-standard argument structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding natural language arguments, especially in a dialogue setting, is challenging. Listeners need to not only grasp the content of what's being said but also how individual statements relate to each other to form a coherent argument. This involves identifying claims and the evidence supporting them. The paper addresses how "clue words" – special linguistic markers – facilitate this process by explicitly indicating the structural relationships between propositions in an argument. Without these clues, understanding complex or unconventional argument structures would be computationally prohibitive.

Methods

The authors develop a computational model for argument analysis that represents arguments as trees of claim and evidence relations. Their core contribution is a theory of "clue words" and interpretation rules for processing them. They categorize clue words based on their semantic function (e.g., parallel, inference, summary, contrast) and propose a "clue interpretation module" to handle these signals. The model uses a "hybrid reception" algorithm that can recognize arguments presented in either "pre-order" (claim first) or "post-order" (evidence first) structures. The paper emphasizes that clue words reduce processing complexity by guiding the hearer's search for relevant propositions and enabling the recognition of "exceptional" transmission strategies that deviate from standard coherent structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and uses example dialogues (EX1-EX11) to illustrate its concepts rather than large-scale datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Clue words are not just stylistic; they are functional: They actively reduce the computational burden on the listener by explicitly signaling argument structure.
  • Clues enable understanding of complexity: While coherent arguments can be understood without clues, complex or "exceptional" argument structures (those deviating from standard pre- or post-order) require clue words for the listener to reconstruct the intended meaning.
  • A taxonomy of clue functions is crucial: Grouping clue words by their semantic function (e.g., indicating addition, causality, summary) allows for the development of specific interpretation rules, making the analysis more systematic.
  • Computational complexity as a guide: The authors propose using computational effort as a metric to determine preferred interpretations and to identify when a transmission strategy is "exceptional" and thus requires explicit clueing.
  • Distinction from reference resolution: While related to tasks like anaphora resolution in terms of identifying relationships between discourse elements, clue interpretation is distinct because it relies on semantic function and structural rules rather than solely on surface form or referential links.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results from large-scale experiments. Instead, its key results are theoretical:

  • A framework for classifying clue words based on their function in argument structure.
  • Interpretation rules for processing these clue words within a computational model.
  • The demonstration that clue words are necessary for understanding complex argument structures that would otherwise be computationally intractable.
  • A proposed "clue interpretation module" to be integrated into existing argument analysis models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exact specification of clues: The authors acknowledge that the precise definition and exhaustive specification of what constitutes a "clue" is an area for further research.
  • Indirect indications: While they discuss mechanisms like lexical equivalence and substitution, they are hesitant to classify all such devices as "clues," suggesting more research is needed.
  • Attitudinal and emphasis clues: Clues related to speaker belief or emphasis are noted but not deeply examined, as the model focuses on structural connections.
  • Memory limitations: The paper speculates that memory limitations might necessitate clues even in basic transmissions, suggesting this as a direction for future investigation.
  • Delineating sub-arguments: The use of clues to signal topic shifts and delineate sub-arguments is mentioned as an area where memory limitations might play a role.
  • Extending the model: The authors propose developing a "clue interpretation module" and further exploring "extended" transmission strategies like mixed-mode sub-arguments and multiple relations.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cohen1984computational,
  author = {Robin Cohen},
  title = {{A Computational Theory of the Function of Clue Words in Argument Understanding}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {1984},
}
Figure