Abstract
How do standards of poetic beauty change as a function of time and expertise? This study uses computational methods to compare the stylistic features of 359 English poems written by 19th-century professional poets, Imagist poets, contemporary professional poets, and contemporary amateur poets. Building upon techniques designed to analyze style and sentiment in texts, we examine elements of poetic craft such as imagery, sound devices, emotive language, and diction. We find that contemporary professional poets use significantly more concrete words than 19th-century poets, fewer emotional words, and more complex sound devices. These changes are consistent with the tenets of Imagism, an early 20th-century literary movement. Further analyses show that contemporary amateur poems resemble 19th-century professional poems more than contemporary professional poems on several dimensions. The stylistic similarities between contemporary amateur poems and 19th-century professional poems suggest that elite standards of poetic beauty in the past “trickled down” to influence amateur works in the present. Our results highlight the influence of Imagism on the modern aesthetic and reveal the dynamics between “high” and “low” art.
Introduction
Literary history has traditionally relied on qualitative analysis—the intuition and close reading of scholars to identify shifts in style and sentiment. However, the rise of natural language processing (NLP) and psycholinguistic databases allows for a quantitative bridge between computational linguistics and literary criticism. This paper, authored by Justine T. Kao and Dan Jurafsky, seeks to quantify the stylistic "fingerprints" of poetry across two centuries. Specifically, it investigates how the Imagist movement (c. 1912–1917) redefined professional poetry and created a lasting divide between professional and amateur aesthetics.
Methodology and Data
To analyze poetic style objectively, the researchers operationalized the core tenets of the Imagist manifesto—which emphasized "exact" words and "concrete" images—into 16 computational features across four primary categories:
- Concrete Imagery: Utilizing the Harvard General Inquirer and the MRC Psycholinguistic Database, the authors calculated scores for "Object" vs. "Abstract" words, alongside average "Concreteness" and "Imageability" ratings.
- Emotional Language: Affective lexicons were used to measure "Arousal" (the intensity of emotion) and "Valence" (the positivity or negativity of the sentiment).
- Sound Devices: Using the PoetryAnalyzer (Kaplan, 2006) and the CMU Pronouncing Dictionary, the study detected phonetic patterns including perfect rhyme, slant rhyme, alliteration, and assonance.
- Diction: Features included word length, word frequency (via the COCA corpus), and Type-Token Ratio to measure vocabulary diversity.
The study utilized a curated dataset of 359 English poems categorized into four distinct groups: 19th-Century Professional (e.g., Emily Dickinson, Robert Frost), Imagist (e.g., poems from the Des Imagistes anthology), Contemporary Professional (from a 2006 "best of" anthology), and Contemporary Amateur (randomly sampled from a public amateur writing website).
Key Findings
The Imagist Shift toward Concreteness
The analysis confirms that the Imagist movement successfully moved poetry away from "vague generalities." Imagist and contemporary professional poems cluster together in stylistic space, characterized by significantly higher concreteness scores ($p < 0.001$) and a higher density of "Object" words compared to 19th-century works. This validates the "Show, Don't Tell" mantra of modern professional poetry through quantitative evidence.
The Evolution of Sound and Emotion
One of the most striking findings involves the collapse of traditional rhyme. In the 19th century, professional poets utilized "perfect" end rhymes frequently (score of 0.111). For contemporary professionals, this plummeted to 0.014, as the aesthetic shifted toward more subtle devices like slant rhyme and assonance. Furthermore, contemporary professional poetry is significantly less "arousing" or emotionally intense than 19th-century work ($p < 0.0005$), favoring a more subdued, "cool" tone over overt sentimentality.
The "Trickle-Down" Aesthetic
Perhaps the most significant insight is the relationship between contemporary amateur poetry and the professional standards of the past. The data reveals that modern amateur poems resemble 19th-century professional poems more closely than they do contemporary professional work. Amateurs continue to favor abstract, highly emotional language and traditional, perfect rhyme schemes—styles that the professional elite abandoned over a century ago. This suggests an aesthetic "trickle-down" effect, where the high art of the past becomes the amateur standard of the present.
Conclusion
By applying computational linguistics to literary history, this study demonstrates that Imagism was not merely a short-lived trend but a fundamental disruption that permanently altered the professional poetic aesthetic. While professional poetry evolved toward complexity and concreteness, amateur poetry remained anchored in the emotional and formal structures of the 19th century. These findings highlight the power of quantitative methods to reveal the underlying forces and trends that shape artistic evolution and the enduring dynamics between "high" and "low" art.
Summary updated