A comprehensive structural, biochemical and biological profiling of the human NUDIX hydrolase family

Jordi Carreras‐Puigvert, Marinka Žitnik, Ann‐Sofie Jemth, Megan Carter, Judith E. Unterlass, Björn M. Hallström, Olga Loseva, Zhir Karem, José Manuel Calderón‐Montaño, Cecilia Lindskog, Per-Henrik Edqvist, Damian J. Matuszewski, Hammou Ait Blal, Ronnie P.‐a. Berntsson, Maria Häggblad, Ulf Märtens, Matthew Studham, Bo Lundgren, Carolina Wählby, Erik L. L. Sonnhammer, Emma Lundberg, Pål Stenmark, Blaž Zupan, Thomas HelledayNature Communications 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The NUDIX enzymes are involved in cellular metabolism and homeostasis, as well as mRNA processing. Although highly conserved throughout all organisms, their biological roles and biochemical redundancies remain largely unclear. To address this, we globally resolve their individual properties and inter-relationships. We purify 18 of the human NUDIX proteins and screen 52 substrates, providing a substrate redundancy map. Using crystal structures, we generate sequence alignment analyses revealing four major structural classes. To a certain extent, their substrate preference redundancies correlate with structural classes, thus linking structure and activity relationships. To elucidate interdependence among the NUDIX hydrolases, we pairwise deplete them generating an epistatic interaction map, evaluate cell cycle perturbations upon knockdown in normal and cancer cells, and analyse their protein and mRNA expression in normal and cancer tissues. Using a novel FUSION algorithm, we integrate all data creating a comprehensive NUDIX enzyme profile map, which will prove fundamental to understanding their biological functionality.

Introduction

The NUDIX (Nucleoside Diphosphates linked to moiety-X) hydrolases are a family of enzymes found in almost all organisms, acting as cellular "housekeepers" by hydrolyzing a wide range of potentially toxic metabolites, such as oxidized nucleotides. Despite their conservation, the specific biological roles and functional redundancies of human NUDIX enzymes have remained largely uncharacterized. This "dark matter" of the genome complicates efforts to understand their roles in health and disease, particularly in cancer where metabolic adaptation is key.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary systems approach to create a comprehensive functional map:

  • Biochemical Profiling: 18 of the 22 human NUDIX proteins were purified and screened against 52 substrates using a high-throughput Malachite Green assay.
  • Structural Biology: Crystal structures and sequence alignments were used to categorize the family into four major structural classes.
  • Genetic Interaction Mapping: siRNA-mediated single and pairwise depletions (276 combinations) were performed across three cancer cell lines and one normal cell line to identify epistatic interactions.
  • Data Integration: The novel FUSION algorithm (collective matrix factorization) was used to integrate 27 distinct datasets, including biochemical data, genetic interactions, and public mRNA/protein expression data from TCGA and the Human Protein Atlas.
Structural and phylogenetic analysis of the human NUDIX hydrolase family, showing domain architectures and structural classes.

Results

Biochemical Specificity and Redundancy

The biochemical screen revealed a complex landscape of substrate preferences. While some enzymes are highly specific, others show significant overlap. For instance, NUDT5 and NUDT14 exhibit high structural similarity and overlapping substrate activity, explaining why the cell can often tolerate the loss of one but not both. The study also identified novel enzyme-substrate pairs, such as MTH1 (NUDT1) acting on N2-me-dGTP.

Biochemical substrate profiling and functional redundancy map of human NUDIX enzymes.

Structural Basis of Function

Analysis showed that while the catalytic "NUDIX box" is conserved, substrate specificity is largely determined by residues outside this fold. Interestingly, enzymes within the same structural class often share substrate preferences, and sequence similarity was found to be a strong predictor of functional redundancy and negative genetic interactions.

Cancer Vulnerabilities

The integration of genetic and expression data identified a subset of NUDIX enzymes—specifically NUDT1 (MTH1), NUDT2, NUDT10, and NUDT11—as essential for survival in cancer cells (e.g., A549 lung and MCF7 breast cancer) while being less critical in normal cells. Furthermore, while NUDT1 is broadly overexpressed in cancers, others like NUDT4 are frequently downregulated, pointing to diverse roles in tumor progression or metabolic adaptation.

Discussion

This study provides the first comprehensive "atlas" of the human NUDIX hydrolase family. By untangling the redundancies of these enzymes, the researchers have identified specific members that are critical for cancer cell survival. The limitations of this work include the inability to express four family members in E. coli and the potential for local cellular environments to alter enzyme activity in ways not captured by in vitro assays.

Future efforts will leverage this map to develop highly specific inhibitors and combination therapies that bypass cellular redundancy to more effectively target cancer metabolism.

Summary updated

Abstract

The NUDIX enzymes are involved in cellular metabolism and homeostasis, as well as mRNA processing. Although highly conserved throughout all organisms, their biological roles and biochemical redundancies remain largely unclear. To address this, we globally resolve their individual properties and inter-relationships. We purify 18 of the human NUDIX proteins and screen 52 substrates, providing a substrate redundancy map. Using crystal structures, we generate sequence alignment analyses revealing four major structural classes. To a certain extent, their substrate preference redundancies correlate with structural classes, thus linking structure and activity relationships. To elucidate interdependence among the NUDIX hydrolases, we pairwise deplete them generating an epistatic interaction map, evaluate cell cycle perturbations upon knockdown in normal and cancer cells, and analyse their protein and mRNA expression in normal and cancer tissues. Using a novel FUSION algorithm, we integrate all data creating a comprehensive NUDIX enzyme profile map, which will prove fundamental to understanding their biological functionality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{carreraspuigvert2017comprehensive,
  author = {Jordi Carreras‐Puigvert and Marinka Žitnik and Ann‐Sofie Jemth and Megan Carter and Judith E. Unterlass and Björn M. Hallström and Olga Loseva and Zhir Karem and José Manuel Calderón‐Montaño and Cecilia Lindskog and Per-Henrik Edqvist and Damian J. Matuszewski and Hammou Ait Blal and Ronnie P.‐A. Berntsson and Maria Häggblad and Ulf Märtens and Matthew Studham and Bo Lundgren and Carolina Wählby and Erik L. L. Sonnhammer and Emma Lundberg and Pål Stenmark and Blaž Zupan and Thomas Helleday},
  title = {{A comprehensive structural, biochemical and biological profiling of the human NUDIX hydrolase family}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-017-01642-w},
}
Figure