A Comprehensive Review of Multifunctional Nanozymes for Degradation and Detection of Organophosphorus Pesticides in the Environment

Jijia Liang, Zhongtian Dong, Ning Xu, Tao Chen, Jie Liang, Mingzhu Xia, Fenghe WangToxics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Organophosphorus pesticides (OPPs) pose significant environmental and health risks due to their widespread use and toxicity. This review highlights the burgeoning field of nanozymes – artificial enzyme mimics – as a promising solution for both degrading and detecting OPPs. By leveraging the unique properties of nanomaterials, nanozymes offer enhanced stability, tunability, and catalytic efficiency compared to natural enzymes, paving the way for innovative environmental remediation and monitoring technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organophosphorus pesticides are indispensable in modern agriculture for crop protection and yield enhancement. However, their extensive use leads to persistent residues in the environment (water, soil, air) and poses serious threats to ecosystems and human health, including neurological disorders and potential long-term organ damage. Current methods for detecting and degrading these pesticides face challenges related to sensitivity, specificity, cost, and the stability of traditional biocatalysts (natural enzymes). The paper addresses the urgent need for more effective, stable, and versatile tools to combat the pervasive issue of OPP contamination.

Methods

This paper is a comprehensive review, not an experimental study. It synthesizes and analyzes existing research on nanozymes for OPP degradation and detection. The authors categorize nanozymes based on their composition and structure, including:

  • Metal-based nanozymes: Nanoparticles composed of single or multiple metals (e.g., Cu NPs, Au-Pt, Pt-Ni NPs).
  • Metal oxide nanozymes: Nanomaterials based on metal oxides (e.g., CuO NPs, CeO2, MnO2).
  • Metal-organic framework (MOF)-based nanozymes: Hybrid materials combining metal ions and organic linkers, offering tunable structures and catalytic sites.
  • Single-atom nanozymes (SAzymes): Nanomaterials featuring isolated metal atoms dispersed on a support, maximizing atomic utilization and catalytic efficiency.
  • Carbon-based nanozymes: Materials like carbon nanosheets, graphene, and carbon dots, known for their excellent electron transfer properties.
  • Covalent organic framework (COF)-based nanozymes: Porous crystalline materials with tunable structures and catalytic capabilities.

The review focuses on the enzymatic-like activities (e.g., peroxidase-like, oxidase-like, phosphatase-like) of these nanozymes and their application in developing sensors and degradation systems for various OPPs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a review article that synthesizes existing literature rather than presenting new experimental data or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nanozymes as Superior Enzyme Mimics: Nanozymes offer a compelling alternative to natural enzymes due to their enhanced stability under harsh environmental conditions (temperature, pH, organic solvents), cost-effectiveness, ease of synthesis, and tunable catalytic properties.
  • Multifunctionality is Key: The most promising nanozymes exhibit dual functionality, capable of both degrading OPPs and acting as sensitive detection probes. This integration streamlines environmental monitoring and remediation efforts.
  • Structural Diversity Drives Performance: The performance of nanozymes is highly dependent on their composition and structure. For instance, single-atom nanozymes maximize active site exposure, while MOFs and COFs offer tunable pore structures and synergistic effects between metal nodes and organic ligands.
  • Synergistic Effects Enhance Catalysis: Combining different nanomaterials or incorporating specific dopants (e.g., Bi in Pd@Pt, Fe in MOFs) can significantly boost catalytic activity and selectivity.
  • Colorimetric and Electrochemical Sensing Dominate: Many nanozyme-based detection strategies rely on colorimetric changes or electrochemical signals, offering rapid, sensitive, and often visually detectable results.

Key Results

The review details numerous examples of nanozymes demonstrating high efficacy in detecting and degrading various OPPs. For instance:

  • Detection Limits: Many nanozyme-based sensors achieve detection limits in the ng mL⁻¹ or even pg mL⁻¹ range for specific OPPs, surpassing the sensitivity of some traditional methods. Examples include detection limits of 0.083 ng mL⁻¹ for dichlorvos using PtPdNPs@g-C3N4, and 0.039 ng mL⁻¹ for chlorpyrifos using Au@MnO2-x.
  • Degradation Efficiency: Certain nanozymes show rapid hydrolysis of OPPs. For example, CeO2@NC nanozymes achieved rapid hydrolysis of parathion within 10 minutes at low temperatures.
  • Broad Spectrum Detection: Some nanozyme-based sensor arrays can simultaneously detect multiple OPPs, offering a more comprehensive monitoring solution.
  • Growing Research Landscape: Bibliometric analysis shows a significant and increasing trend in research publications on OPP degradation and detection using nanozymes, with China leading in output.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for future development:

  • Dual-Functionality Integration: Further research is needed to develop nanozymes that seamlessly integrate both degradation and detection functionalities for real-time monitoring and integrated removal.
  • Environmental and Health Impact Assessment: A critical aspect for future work is evaluating the long-term environmental and health impacts of nanozymes themselves to ensure their safety and sustainability.
  • Scalable Manufacturing: Developing cost-effective and industrially scalable manufacturing processes for nanozymes is crucial for their widespread adoption in practical applications like agriculture and environmental management.
  • Understanding Mechanisms: While significant progress has been made, a deeper understanding of the precise catalytic mechanisms and structure-activity relationships of various nanozymes could lead to even more efficient and targeted designs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Organophosphorus pesticides are the most extensively utilized agrichemicals in the world. They play a crucial role in regulating crop growth, immunizing against pests, and improving yields, while their unregulated residues exert serious detrimental effects on both the environment and human health. Many efforts have been made in the world to monitor organophosphorus pesticides and solve the issues caused by them. Nanozymes, as one kind of enzyme mimic that is artificially designed to simulate the function of natural enzymes, have aroused a lot of attention due to their unparalleled advantages. Nanozymes inherit both the unique properties of nanomaterials and catalytic functions, which could overcome the limitations inherent in natural enzymes and have great versatile and adaptable application prospects. This review presents a recent advancement in synthesizing multifunctional nanozymes with enzymatic-like activities by using various nanomaterials to degrade and detect organophosphorus pesticides. It mainly encompasses metal-based nanozymes, carbon-based nanozymes, metal-organic-framework-based nanozymes, and single-atom-based nanozymes. Additionally, this paper discusses the potential of nanozymes as novel functional environmental materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liang2024comprehensive,
  author = {Jijia Liang and Zhongtian Dong and Ning Xu and Tao Chen and Jie Liang and Mingzhu Xia and Fenghe Wang},
  title = {{A Comprehensive Review of Multifunctional Nanozymes for Degradation and Detection of Organophosphorus Pesticides in the Environment}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics12120926},
}
Figure