A comprehensive mechanism for 5-carboxylcytosine-induced transcriptional pausing revealed by Markov state models

Kirill A. Konovalov, Wei Wang, Guo Wang, Eshani C. Goonetilleke, Xin Gao, Dong Wang, Xuhui HuangJournal of Biological Chemistry 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a multi-faceted mechanism by which the epigenetic modification 5-carboxycytosine (5caC) induces transcriptional pausing in RNA polymerase II (Pol II). Using advanced computational modeling, the researchers identified novel interactions and a surprising effect on the enzyme's structural flexibility, explaining how 5caC significantly slows down transcription.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Epigenetic modifications of DNA play crucial roles in regulating gene expression. One such modification, 5-carboxycytosine (5caC), is known to cause RNA polymerase II (Pol II) to pause during transcription. While a previous study suggested a single hydrogen bond between 5caC and a residue in fork loop 3 (FL3) of Pol II was responsible for this pausing, it was unclear how other potential interactions of the 5caC modification with Pol II might contribute. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the molecular mechanisms by which 5caC induces transcriptional pausing, going beyond the previously identified interaction.

Methods

The core of this study relies on Markov State Models (MSMs) built from extensive molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. MD simulations generate atomic-level trajectories of molecular motion, while MSMs are statistical models that can effectively capture the slow conformational changes of biomolecules by discretizing the simulation data into "states" and modeling the transitions between them. This approach allows researchers to overcome the timescale limitations of direct MD simulations and explore rare events like transcriptional pausing. The authors specifically focused on the translocation of the template nucleotide within the Pol II elongation complex. They also employed time-lagged independent component analysis (tICA) for dimensionality reduction of the MD data, a common technique in MSM construction. Furthermore, they performed in silico mutations of key Pol II residues (R512A and Q531A) to experimentally probe the role of specific interactions in pausing.

Datasets

The study utilized existing crystal structures of the Pol II elongation complex (PDB IDs: 4Y52 and 2E2H) as starting points for their MD simulations. The simulations themselves generated the primary datasets used for MSM construction. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond a Single Interaction: The study moves beyond the previously identified hydrogen bond between 5caC and Q531 (FL3) to reveal a more complex picture of 5caC-induced pausing.
  • A Novel Interaction: A key finding is the discovery of a new interaction involving residue R512 (in fork loop 2) forming a stable ion pair with the 5caC modification, which directly hinders its movement into the active site.
  • Bridge Helix Kinking is Crucial: Surprisingly, 5caC was found to suppress the kinking of the bridge helix, a flexible a-helix critical for Pol II translocation. This reduced kinking stabilizes a straighter conformation, impeding the movement of the template base.
  • Multiple Pausing States: The presence of 5caC leads to the formation of distinct translocation intermediates, with at least two of these states showing the template base shifted away from the active site, directly contributing to pausing.
  • Synergistic Effects: The pausing mechanism is not due to a single factor but a combination of direct hydrogen bonding interactions with key Pol II residues and indirect effects on the bridge helix's structural dynamics.

Key Results

  • Two Translocation Intermediates: The study identified two distinct translocation intermediates induced by 5caC that prevent the template base from entering the Pol II active site.
  • R512 Interaction: A novel hydrogen bond between 5caC and R512 was identified, contributing to pausing.
  • Bridge Helix Stabilization: 5caC was found to reduce bridge helix kinking, with approximately 25% of conformations showing a straighter bridge helix compared to unmodified cytosine (C). This effect was observed even in regions of the bridge helix not directly interacting with 5caC.
  • Mutant Analysis:
    • The R512A mutation partially restored translocation by favoring the transition between intermediate states and restoring bridge helix kinking.
  • The Q531A mutation reduced the energy barrier between later translocation states, also promoting movement.
  • Flanking Nucleotides Have Minimal Impact: The study found that the immediate upstream and downstream DNA bases flanking 5caC had a negligible effect on transcription slowdown.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Silico Nature: The study relies on computational simulations. While powerful, these models are approximations of reality and may not capture all nuances of the biological system. Experimental validation of the predicted interactions and mechanisms is crucial.
  • Focus on Specific States: The simulations focused on the post-translocation basin. While this is where the pausing occurs, other stages of transcription might be influenced by 5caC.
  • Future Experimental Validation: The authors suggest that their predictions regarding transcription rates of WT and mutant Pol II on 5caC-containing templates can be tested experimentally. Further investigation into the impact of flanking nucleotides on other DNA sequences could also be valuable. The study also implies that understanding these mechanisms could lead to the development of therapeutic strategies targeting transcription.

Summary updated

Abstract

RNA polymerase II (Pol II) surveils the genome, pausing as it encounters DNA lesions and base modifications and initiating signals for DNA repair among other important regulatory events. Recent work suggests that Pol II pauses at 5-carboxycytosine (5caC), an epigenetic modification of cytosine, because of a specific hydrogen bond between the carboxyl group of 5caC and a specific residue in fork loop 3 of Pol II. This hydrogen bond compromises productive NTP binding and slows down elongation. Apart from this specific interaction, the carboxyl group of 5caC can potentially interact with numerous charged residues in the cleft of Pol II. However, it is not clear how other interactions between Pol II and 5caC contribute to pausing. In this study, we use Markov state models (a type of kinetic network models) built from extensive molecular dynamics simulations to comprehensively study the impact of 5caC on Pol II translocation. We describe two translocation intermediates with specific interactions that prevent the template base from loading into the Pol II active site. In addition to the previously observed state with 5caC constrained by fork loop 3, we discovered a new intermediate state with a hydrogen bond between 5caC and fork loop 2. Surprisingly, we find that 5caC may curb translocation by suppressing kinking of the helix bordering the active site (the bridge helix) because its high flexibility is critical to translocation. Our work provides new insights into how epigenetic modifications of genomic DNA can modulate Pol II translocation, inducing pauses in transcription.
BibTeX
@article{konovalov2021comprehensive,
  author = {Kirill A. Konovalov and Wei Wang and Guo Wang and Eshani C. Goonetilleke and Xin Gao and Dong Wang and Xuhui Huang},
  title = {{A comprehensive mechanism for 5-carboxylcytosine-induced transcriptional pausing revealed by Markov state models}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological Chemistry},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jbc.2021.100735},
}
Figure