A comprehensive map of human glucokinase variant activity

Sarah Gersing, Matteo Cagiada, Marinella Gebbia, Anette P. Gjesing, Atina G. Coté, Gireesh Seesankar, Roujia Li, Daniel Tabet, Amelie Stein, Anna L. Gloyn, Torben Hansen, Frederick P. Roth, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen, Rasmus Hartmann‐PetersenbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive "variant effect map" for human glucokinase (GCK), a key protein in glucose regulation. By using a high-throughput yeast-based assay, they've characterized the functional impact of nearly all possible GCK variants, providing a crucial tool for diagnosing and understanding GCK-related diabetes and hypoglycemia.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Glucokinase (GCK) is a critical enzyme in how our bodies sense and respond to blood glucose levels, playing a vital role in insulin secretion. Variations in the GCK gene can lead to serious conditions like hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia (too much insulin, leading to low blood sugar) or GCK-maturity-onset diabetes of the young (GCK-MODY, leading to high blood sugar). These conditions affect millions worldwide, and misdiagnosis can lead to unnecessary and ineffective treatments. The main challenge is that while some GCK variants are well-understood, many novel missense variants (changes in a single amino acid) have an "uncertain significance," making it hard to determine their clinical impact. This paper aims to bridge that gap by providing a systematic, large-scale functional assessment of GCK variants.

Methods

The core of this study is a multiplexed yeast complementation assay. Here's how it works:

  1. Yeast Strain Engineering: They created a yeast strain that lacks its own glucose-sensing enzymes (hexokinases). This strain cannot grow on glucose.
  2. Human GCK Expression: They then engineered this yeast strain to express human GCK. When functional human GCK is present, the yeast can grow on glucose.
  3. Variant Library: They generated a library containing almost every possible single amino acid substitution (missense variants) and stop codon (nonsense variants) in the GCK gene.
  4. Complementation Assay: This library of GCK variants was introduced into the engineered yeast. The yeast were then grown on glucose-containing media. The rate at which the yeast grew served as a proxy for the activity of the GCK variant. Faster growth indicates higher GCK activity (hyperactive variant), while slower growth indicates lower GCK activity (hypoactive variant).
  5. Deep Sequencing (TileSeq): After the yeast grew under selective conditions (0.2% glucose), the plasmids encoding the GCK variants were extracted and sequenced using a technique called TileSeq. By comparing the frequency of each variant before and after selection, they could quantify its relative activity.
  6. Activity Scoring: Variants were assigned an "activity score," normalized so that wild-type-like variants scored 1, and complete loss-of-function variants scored 0.
  7. Structural Mapping & Mechanistic Analysis: The activity scores were mapped onto the 3D structure of GCK to identify regions critical for function. They also used computational methods (Rosetta) to predict how variants might affect protein stability and conformational dynamics.

Datasets

  • GCK Variant Library: A library of 9003 out of 9280 (97%) possible single amino acid and nonsense variants of human GCK.
  • gnomAD: Used for comparison of variant allele frequencies and to identify common, likely benign variants.
  • ClinVar: Used to identify previously characterized pathogenic variants for validation.
  • Published Kinetic Data: Data from 38 GCK variants with previously measured in vitro kinetic parameters (catalytic efficiency).
  • Clinical Data: Fasting glucose levels from 33 patients with known GCK variants from four different Danish cohorts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GCK Variants Have Diverse Functional Impacts: The assay revealed a wide spectrum of GCK activity, from complete loss-of-function to significantly enhanced activity, highlighting the complex role of GCK in glucose homeostasis.
  • Location Matters: Hypoactive variants were often found in buried positions or near the active site, suggesting critical structural or catalytic roles. Hyperactive variants, interestingly, often clustered at an allosteric activator site, hinting at regulatory mechanisms.
  • Conformational Dynamics are Key: The study suggests that some hyperactive variants might work by shifting the conformational equilibrium of GCK towards its active state, possibly by destabilizing the inactive conformation.
  • Yeast Complementation is a Powerful Tool: This work validates the use of yeast complementation as a high-throughput, cost-effective method for assessing the functional impact of thousands of protein variants.

Key Results

  • Comprehensive Variant Map: The study generated activity scores for 9003 (97%) of possible GCK missense and nonsense variants.
  • Correlation with Existing Data: The yeast assay scores strongly correlated with:
  • In vitro catalytic efficiency (Spearman's ρ = 0.76).
  • Fasting glucose levels in patients carrying GCK variants (Spearman's ρ = -0.58).
  • Evolutionary conservation scores.
  • Classification of Variants:
    • 4442 variants (51.8%) showed decreased activity.
  • 1198 variants (14%) showed increased activity.
  • 2930 variants (34.2%) showed wild-type-like activity.
  • Clinical Relevance: The assay correctly classified 76.7% of known GCK-MODY variants and 87.5% of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia (HH) variants, providing a valuable tool for variant interpretation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited to Missense and Nonsense Variants: The study did not include other types of pathogenic variations like insertions, deletions, or promoter/splice site variants, which can also affect GCK function.
  • Potential for Secondary Mutations: While efforts were made to minimize this, the mutagenesis strategy could introduce multiple mutations within a single region, potentially confounding results.
  • Assay Sensitivity: Some pathogenic variants with complex mechanisms (e.g., modest instability) might not be detected if their intrinsic catalytic efficiency remains wild-type-like. The authors suggest that increasing replicates or varying assay conditions could improve sensitivity.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose that this variant effect map can be used to:
  • Facilitate variant interpretation and diagnosis of GCK-related diseases.
  • Expand mechanistic understanding of GCK variants.
  • Inform the development of therapeutics targeting GCK, particularly glucokinase activators (GKAs).
  • Further investigate the mechanisms of variants that were not detected by conservation analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Glucokinase (GCK) regulates insulin secretion to maintain appropriate blood glucose levels. Sequence variants can alter GCK activity to cause hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia (HH) or hyperglycemia associated with GCK-maturity-onset diabetes of the young (GCK-MODY), collectively affecting up to 10 million people worldwide. Patients with GCK-MODY are frequently misdiagnosed and treated unnecessarily. Genetic testing can prevent this but is hampered by the challenge of interpreting novel missense variants. Here we exploited a multiplexed yeast complementation assay to measure both hyper- and hypoactive GCK variation, capturing 97% of all possible missense and nonsense variants. Activity scores correlated with in vitro catalytic efficiency, fasting glucose levels in carriers of GCK variants and with evolutionary conservation. Hypoactive variants were concentrated at buried positions, near the active site, and at a region of known importance for GCK conformational dynamics. Some hyperactive variants shifted the conformational equilibrium towards the active state through a relative destabilization of the inactive conformation. Our comprehensive assessment of GCK variant activity promises to facilitate variant interpretation and diagnosis, expand our mechanistic understanding of hyperactive variants, and inform development of therapeutics targeting GCK.
BibTeX
@misc{gersing2022comprehensive,
  author = {Sarah Gersing and Matteo Cagiada and Marinella Gebbia and Anette P. Gjesing and Atina G. Coté and Gireesh Seesankar and Roujia Li and Daniel Tabet and Amelie Stein and Anna L. Gloyn and Torben Hansen and Frederick P. Roth and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen and Rasmus Hartmann‐Petersen},
  title = {{A comprehensive map of human glucokinase variant activity}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.05.04.490571},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure