A comprehensive evaluation of regional carbon emission based on the composite model in China: a case study of Huaibei city (China)

Wen Zheng, Ziwei Yang, Qinfeng XingScientific 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive evaluation of carbon emission reduction strategies in Huaibei City, China, using a novel composite model. It identifies the secondary industry as the most significant factor influencing carbon emissions, while population, though having a smaller weight, poses a significant obstacle. The study predicts that achieving the "dual carbon" strategy is feasible by 2030 with targeted improvements, particularly in population-related indicators.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving China's "dual carbon" strategy (carbon peaking and carbon neutrality) requires effective regional-level carbon emission reduction. However, understanding the complex interplay of various factors influencing regional emissions and developing targeted strategies remains a challenge. Existing research often focuses on specific influencing factors or employs single evaluation methods, lacking a holistic approach. This paper addresses this gap by developing and applying a composite model to comprehensively evaluate and predict carbon emission trends in Huaibei City, a representative coal-dependent region, to inform policy and strategy.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Composite Weighting Method: This method combines objective weights from the entropy weight method with subjective weights from the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) to derive optimal combination weights for various indicators. This aims to reduce error and provide a more robust assessment of indicator importance.
  • Matter-Element Model: This model is used for comprehensive evaluation of carbon emission safety levels. It constructs a matter-element system representing the indicators and their relationships, then calculates correlation degrees to assess the safety status of each indicator and the overall system.
  • Gray Prediction Model (GM(1,1)): This model is utilized for predicting future trends of carbon emission. It's known for its ability to handle data with limited observations and provide accurate predictions for gray systems.

These methods are integrated to provide a holistic evaluation and prediction of carbon emission dynamics.

Datasets

The study utilizes historical data for Huaibei City from 2012 to 2021. The specific indicators analyzed are:

  • Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
  • Energy Intensity
  • Urbanization Rate
  • Proportion of Secondary Industry
  • Population

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relies on publicly available data for these indicators in Huaibei City.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Secondary Industry Dominance: The secondary industry is identified as the most impactful factor on carbon emissions in Huaibei City, highlighting its critical role in reduction efforts.
  • Population's Dual Role: While having the lowest weight, population growth presents a significant obstacle to carbon emission reduction, indicating a need for specific policy interventions.
  • Feasibility of "Dual Carbon" Goal: The study suggests that with focused improvements, particularly in population-related indicators, Huaibei City can achieve the "dual carbon" strategy by 2030.
  • Indicator Synchronization is Key: The safety levels of different indicators are not synchronized, and achieving the overall goal requires coordinated improvements across all factors.
  • Urbanization as a Driver: Urbanization shows a positive trend and is closely linked to improvements in carbon emission safety, suggesting its role in driving low-carbon development.

Key Results

  • Indicator Weights: The secondary industry (C4) has the highest weight (0.32), followed by energy intensity (C2, 0.24), GDP (C1, 0.16), urbanization (C3, 0.15), and population (C5, 0.13).
  • Historical Trends (2012-2021):
    • Carbon emission safety levels for energy intensity, secondary industry, GDP, and urbanization generally improved.
  • GDP safety level showed the largest improvement.
  • Population safety level fluctuated but remained largely at a "less secure" level.
  • Overall carbon emission safety in Huaibei City experienced a decline from 2012-2016, with a slight improvement in 2019, but a subsequent decline in 2020-2021.
  • Future Predictions (2022-2030):
    • GDP and urbanization are predicted to remain at a "safe" level.
  • Energy intensity and the proportion of the secondary industry are expected to improve from "relatively safe" to "safe."
    • Population is predicted to decline to "insecure" and then "less secure" levels, becoming the primary limiting factor.
  • The overall carbon emission safety level is projected to improve and stabilize at a "safe" level by 2028-2030.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: The study focuses on regional-level data for Huaibei City. Future work could explore finer-grained data within the city for more localized policy recommendations.
  • Model Complexity: While the composite model offers a comprehensive view, the interaction and feedback loops between indicators could be further explored.
  • Population Factor: The persistent "less secure" status of the population indicator warrants deeper investigation into the specific socio-economic drivers and the development of more effective interventions.
  • Technological Innovation: The paper highlights the importance of technological innovation, particularly in energy efficiency and clean energy, suggesting future research could quantify the impact of specific technological advancements.
  • Policy Implementation: While the study provides insights, translating these findings into actionable and effective regional policies remains a crucial next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Formulating carbon emission reduction at the regional level is key to achieving the "dual carbon" strategy. A composite model is used to analyze the carbon emission reduction in Huaibei City based on the data from 2012 to 2021 and predict its change trend of carbon emission from 2022 to 2030. The study finds that: (1) the effects of observed factors on carbon emission in Huaibei City are complicated. Among them, the secondary industry has the greatest impact on carbon emission (weight is 0.32), and it is the key constraint factor of carbon emission. Population has the smallest impact on carbon emission (weight is 0.13), but its obstacle effect is significant. (2) The observed factors have a significant positive effect on the "dual carbon" strategy, but the improvement pressure is high. Among them, the conditions of all indicators have been improved except population, and it is found that each indicator can reach the level I before 2030, the "dual carbon" strategy can be achieved. This study deepens the understanding of regional carbon emission in China and the following conclusions are formed: (1) Grasping the carbon reduction effect of urbanization on the population to consolidate the new model of low-carbon development. (2) Identifying the key areas of carbon emission reduction to build a low-carbon emission oriented industrial system. (3) Strengthening the technological innovation of carbon emission reduction to achieve the strategic goal of "dual-carbon".
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2023comprehensive,
  author = {Wen Zheng and Ziwei Yang and Qinfeng Xing},
  title = {{A comprehensive evaluation of regional carbon emission based on the composite model in China: a case study of Huaibei city (China)}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-42667-0},
}
Figure