A Comprehensive Dataset of Grains for Granular Jamming in Soft Robotics: Grip Strength and Shock Absorption

David Howard, David Howard 0001, Jack O'Connor, Jordan Letchford, Therese Joseph, Sophia Lin, Sarah Baldwin, Gary W. DelaneyRobosoft 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the largest dataset to date of granular materials for soft robotics applications, evaluating their performance in both gripping and shock absorption. They found that soft grains excel at gripping by conforming to objects, while larger, rigid grains are better for shock absorption, offering valuable insights for designing more effective granular jamming systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Granular jamming is a powerful technique in soft robotics, enabling variable stiffness and adaptable gripping. However, the performance of granular jamming systems is highly dependent on the properties of the granular material itself – its shape, size, and material composition. Despite this, most research has only explored a limited selection of grains, making it difficult for researchers to choose the optimal material for their specific application. This paper addresses this gap by creating and testing a comprehensive dataset of 35 different granular materials, covering a wide range of properties, to systematically understand their impact on two key soft robotics applications: gripping and shock absorption.

Methods

The researchers conducted two main experiments:

  • Grip Strength: A latex balloon gripper was filled with each granular material and used to pick up various test objects. The "retention force" (how strongly the gripper held the object) was measured using a load cell. This setup allowed for a standardized evaluation of how well each grain type could conform to and grip different shapes.
  • Shock Absorption: An Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU) was encased in a silicone membrane filled with the granular material. This assembly was then dropped from a set height, and the IMU recorded the shock experienced. The goal was to quantify how effectively each granular material could dissipate impact forces.

The dataset includes both commercially available grains and custom 3D-printed grains, allowing for fine-grained control over shape, size, and material properties. The 3D printed grains were parameterized using superquadrics to create precise shapes like cubes, ellipsoids, spheres, and superellipsoids.

Datasets

The paper introduces a new, comprehensive dataset of 35 granular materials for soft robotics applications. This dataset includes:

  • Purchased Grains: A variety of natural (e.g., rice, coffee) and manufactured (e.g., glass, plastic, rubber) grains.
  • 3D Printed Grains: Custom-designed grains with controlled shapes (cubes, ellipsoids, spheres, superellipsoids) and sizes (3mm to 7mm Sphere Volume Equivalent), fabricated from rigid (Vero) and soft (Agilus) materials.

This dataset is publicly available, serving as a benchmark for future research in granular jamming.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Softness is Key for Gripping: Soft granular materials significantly outperform rigid ones in gripping applications. This is attributed to their ability to conform to the shape of the object being grasped, creating a more intimate contact and thus a stronger grip.
  • Size Matters for Shock Absorption: For shock absorption, larger grain sizes, particularly in rigid materials, lead to better performance. This suggests that larger grains can better spread and dissipate impact forces.
  • No "One-Size-Fits-All" Grain: The optimal grain choice is highly application-dependent. What works best for gripping might be detrimental for shock absorption, and vice-versa.
  • Shape Complexity Can Be Beneficial (for Gripping): Unconventional shapes like super-ellipsoids showed surprisingly high gripping forces, suggesting that custom-designed grain geometries can unlock enhanced performance.
  • Material Properties are Crucial: Beyond shape and size, the inherent material properties (softness, elasticity, tendency to bounce) play a critical role in determining performance for both gripping and shock absorption.

Key Results

  • Gripping: Soft grains, like Agilus70 and polystyrene, generally provided the highest retention forces across various test objects. The Agilus70 4mm cube was particularly effective for gripping cube and star-shaped objects.
  • Shock Absorption: Larger, rigid grains, such as the 8mm glass sphere (S8G) and 7mm hollow plastic cube (C7HP), demonstrated the lowest shock absorption values (meaning they absorbed impact better). Rigid Vero grains generally performed better than soft grains in shock absorption tests.
  • Variability: While soft grains excelled at gripping, they also exhibited higher variability in performance compared to rigid grains.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Soft Grains: The study notes that only five out of the 35 grains were soft, suggesting a need for a broader exploration of soft materials.
  • Long-Term Effects: The paper mentions that long-term effects of compressing soft grains are open to further investigation.
  • Printer Settings: For 3D printed grains, the influence of printer settings on material properties and performance warrants further study.
  • Application-Specific Optimization: The authors emphasize that while their dataset provides guidance, further research is needed to optimize grain selection for highly specific robotic tasks and object geometries. They also plan to release additional grain sets and explore the impact of printer settings on printed grain properties.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{howard2023comprehensive,
  author = {David Howard and David Howard and Jack O'Connor and Jordan Letchford and Therese Joseph and Sophia Lin and Sarah Baldwin and Gary W. Delaney},
  title = {{A Comprehensive Dataset of Grains for Granular Jamming in Soft Robotics: Grip Strength and Shock Absorption}},
  booktitle = {Robosoft},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/robosoft55895.2023.10122060},
}
Figure