A Component-Based Software Reliability Growth Model Considering Differences in Components

QiShun Xie -, Jun Bai, Ce Zhang, Fanchao Meng, Gang Cui, Hongwei LiuAdvances 2013 · DOI

Abstract: In the light of the problems in reliability modeling and analyzing for CBS (Component-Based Software), occurring time-invariant, less attention to debugging process, absence of considering differences in the components, a CBS SRGM (Software Reliability Growth Model) is presented. In terms of characters of different components, components are divided into critical and non-critical component sets. An imperfect debugging model considering fault correction probability and introducing new fault is used to describe critical component, and G-O model is applied to non-critical component. The formulation of the cumulative number of faults detected in CBS is derived. The proposed CBS SRGM can appropriately describe real testing process. Numerical examples verify the effectiveness of the proposed model and it outperforms other models.

Introduction

Most software reliability models treat every component the same, but in the real world, some modules are significantly more complex than others. Traditional Software Reliability Growth Models (SRGMs) often suffer from three major limitations: they struggle with time-invariance, they assume "perfect fixes" where every bug found is perfectly resolved, and they treat all components as homogeneous. This paper introduces CBSDC-RGM, a reliability growth model that categorizes components into critical and non-critical sets, accounting for the messy reality of "imperfect debugging"—where fixing one bug might accidentally introduce another.

Methodology: The "Divide and Conquer" Approach

The core innovation of the CBSDC-RGM (Component-Based Software with Differences in Components-RGM) is its nuanced approach to modeling based on component characteristics:

  • Component Classification: Components are divided into Critical (CC) and Non-Critical (NCC) sets based on their complexity and execution frequency (transition probabilities).
  • Modeling Critical Components: For complex modules, an imperfect debugging model is used. This incorporates two vital parameters: $p$ (the probability that a fault is actually removed) and $\beta$ (the probability that a new fault is introduced during the fix).
  • Modeling Non-Critical Components: For simpler modules, the model employs the classic Goel-Okumoto (G-O) model, which assumes simpler failure patterns and perfect debugging.
  • System Integration: Using a Non-Homogeneous Poisson Process (NHPP) framework, the authors aggregate expected failures across all components to predict total system reliability.

Simulation and Datasets

Because real-world failure data for component-based systems is difficult to obtain, the authors utilized a simulation-based approach using a well-known CBS architecture consisting of 10 components.

Architecture of the 10-component CBS used for simulation.

In this setup, components $C_1$ and $C_5$ were identified as "critical" due to their high execution probabilities. This simulated "real" data served as the benchmark to compare CBSDC-RGM against three established models: Pham, Ohba, and the standard G-O model.

Key Results and Performance

The authors evaluated the models using Mean Square Error (MSE), R-square (goodness of fit), and Variance. The CBSDC-RGM outperformed the competition across all metrics:

Model MSE R-square Variance
Pham 18.8562 0.9716 4.5707
Ohba 24.3110 1.0300 5.1725
G-O 24.3110 1.0300 5.1725
CBSDC-RGM 16.8149 1.0243 4.3025

Note: In this context, an R-square value closest to 1 indicates the best fit. The proposed model's value of 1.0243 is the closest to the ideal target.

Visually, the proposed model's curve tracks the "real" failure data much more tightly than the simpler models, as shown in the comparison below.

Comparison of fitted results for G-O, Ohba, Pham, and the proposed CBSDC-RGM models.

Conclusion

The CBSDC-RGM model demonstrates that architecture dictates reliability. By applying imperfect debugging math only to critical components, the model captures the reality that complex code is harder to fix and more prone to regression bugs. While currently validated on simulated data, the model provides a robust mathematical framework for aggregating individual component reliability into a coherent system-level growth curve. Future work will focus on testing against large-scale industrial data and adapting the model for incremental integration testing.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the light of the problems in reliability modeling and analyzing for CBS (Component-Based Software), occurring time-invariant, less attention to debugging process, absence of considering differences in the components, a CBS SRGM (Software Reliability Growth Model) is presented. In terms of characters of different components, components are divided into critical and non-critical component sets. An imperfect debugging model considering fault correction probability and introducing new fault is used to describe critical component, and G-O model is applied to non-critical component. The formulation of the cumulative number of faults detected in CBS is derived. The proposed CBS SRGM can appropriately describe real testing process. Numerical examples verify the effectiveness of the proposed model and it outperforms other models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{2013component,
  author = {QiShun Xie - and Jun Bai and Ce Zhang and Fanchao Meng and Gang Cui and Hongwei Liu},
  title = {{A Component-Based Software Reliability Growth Model Considering Differences in Components}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.2991/icsecs-13.2013.8},
}

Loading related content...

Figure