A comparison of the biomechanical properties of three different lumbar internal fixation methods in the treatment of lumbosacral spinal tuberculosis: finite element analysis

Jiantao Liu, Xi Gong, Kao Wang, Xingyuan Li, X N Zhang, Jiajun Sun, Yihan Zhu, Yixiang Ai, Jing Ren, Jintao Xiu, Wenchen JiScientific 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses finite element analysis to compare the biomechanical stability and stress distribution of three common internal fixation methods for treating lumbosacral spinal tuberculosis. The findings suggest that a titanium cage with posterior double screw-rod fixation offers the best balance of spinal stability and reduced stress on implants and surrounding tissues, potentially leading to better patient outcomes and fewer complications like screw loosening.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Spinal tuberculosis, particularly in the lumbar region, can lead to vertebral destruction, instability, and neurological deficits. While surgical intervention is often necessary to remove diseased tissue and restore stability, there's a lack of clear consensus on which internal fixation method provides the optimal biomechanical performance. Current surgical strategies involve different combinations of bone grafts (autologous bone) or implants (titanium cages) with various screw-rod configurations (anterior/lateral vs. posterior). These methods can lead to complications such as implant subsidence, screw loosening, and rod fracture. This paper aims to address this gap by quantitatively comparing the biomechanical properties of three prevalent fixation techniques to guide clinical decision-making.

Methods

The researchers employed a finite element (FE) analysis approach. They constructed a validated 3D FE model of the intact L3-S1 lumbar spine based on CT scan data from a healthy adult male. This model was then modified to simulate three different surgical scenarios for treating spinal tuberculosis:

  1. Group 1: Titanium cage with lateral double screw-rod fixation.
  2. Group 2: Autologous bone with posterior double screw-rod fixation.
  3. Group 3: Titanium cage with posterior double screw-rod fixation.

A fourth group (Group 4) represented the intact spine for baseline comparison. After simulating the removal of the affected vertebral body and surrounding ligaments, the internal fixation constructs were applied. Standardized loads (a preload and a pure bending moment of 8 Nm) were applied to the superior surface of L3, while the inferior surface of S1 was fixed. The analysis focused on two key biomechanical parameters:

  • Ranges of Motion (ROMs): Quantifying the degree of movement at the surgical segment (L4-S1) across six directions (flexion, extension, left/right lateral bending, left/right rotation).
  • Von Mises Stresses: Measuring the stress distribution within the implants (screw-rod system), surrounding bone (cortical endplates, cortical bone around screws), and intervertebral discs/facet joints.

Datasets

The study utilized CT scan data from a single healthy adult male volunteer (31 years old, 175 cm, 68 kg) to create the FE model of the L3-S1 lumbar spine. This data was processed using Mimics and 3-matic software. Material properties for bone, ligaments, and implants were derived from existing literature and previous studies. No new experimental datasets were generated or used for training/evaluation in this FE analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stability is Achieved by All Methods: All three internal fixation methods significantly reduced the range of motion in the surgical segment compared to the intact spine, indicating their effectiveness in restoring stability.
  • Posterior Fixation Superior for Stability: Group 3 (titanium cage with posterior double screw-rod fixation) consistently demonstrated the lowest ranges of motion across most directions, suggesting superior stability compared to Group 2 (autologous bone with posterior fixation) and especially Group 1 (lateral fixation).
  • Stress Distribution Varies Significantly: While all methods restore stability, the distribution of stress on implants and surrounding tissues differs dramatically, which is crucial for predicting long-term outcomes and complications.
  • Autologous Bone Buffers Stress: Group 2 (autologous bone) showed the lowest peak stresses in the cortical endplates, potentially indicating a lower risk of implant subsidence. This is attributed to the bone's ability to disperse stress and its lower elastic modulus acting as a buffer.
  • Posterior Cage Fixation Minimizes Screw Stress: Group 3 exhibited the lowest Von Mises stresses in the screw-rod internal fixation system, suggesting a reduced risk of screw loosening and implant failure.
  • Lateral Fixation's Trade-offs: Group 1 (lateral fixation) showed higher stresses in the screw-rod system during flexion and extension compared to posterior fixation methods, though it performed comparably in lateral bending and rotation.

Key Results

  • Reduced ROMs: The ROMs of the L4-S1 surgical segment were substantially lower in all three fixation groups (0.53°–1.54°) compared to the intact spine (4.48°–10.12°).
  • Group 3 Dominates Stability: Group 3 (titanium cage with posterior fixation) had the lowest ROMs overall, particularly in flexion and extension.
  • Screw-Rod System Stress:
    • Group 2 had the highest stress in the screw-rod system during flexion, lateral bending, and rotation.
  • Group 1 had the highest stress in the screw-rod system during extension.
  • Group 3 consistently had the lowest stress in the screw-rod system across most directions.
  • Cortical Endplate Stress: Group 2 (autologous bone) had the lowest peak stresses in the cortical endplates in all directions. Group 1 generally had higher endplate stresses than Group 3, except in the lateral bending direction.
  • Cortical Bone Stress Around Screws: Group 3 showed the lowest peak stresses in the cortical bone around the screws in all directions, indicating a lower risk of screw loosening. Group 1 and Group 2 had higher stresses in this region than Group 3.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Single Subject Model: The FE model was based on CT data from a single healthy male, which may not fully represent the biomechanical variability across the population or account for pathologies.
  • Simplified Geometry: The study used an identical geometry for all surgical models, potentially overlooking how different surgical approaches might alter spinal lordosis and profile.
  • Simplified Loading Conditions: The mechanical environment was simulated using simplified loads, which may not perfectly replicate the complex in vivo conditions. Further validation with in vivo studies is suggested.
  • Limited Tuberculosis Model: The FE analysis focused on a model with L5 vertebral body resection, not encompassing other vertebral body involvements or multiple levels of disease.

Future work could involve creating more diverse FE models, incorporating more complex loading scenarios, and conducting in vivo studies to validate these findings. The authors suggest that further research is needed to analyze specific situations involving different vertebral body resections or multiple affected levels.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract There are various internal fixation methods in treating lumbosacral spinal tuberculosis. The study compared the stability and stress distribution in surrounding tissues/implants, such as discs, endplates and screw-rod internal fixation system, etc. when applying three different lumbar internal fixation methods to treat lumbosacral spinal tuberculosis. A finite element model was constructed and validated. The spinal stability was restored using three methods: a titanium cage with lateral double screw-rod fixation (group 1), autologous bone with posterior double screw-rod fixation (group 2), and a titanium cage with posterior double screw-rod fixation (group 3). For comparison, group 4 represented the intact L3-S1 spine. Finally, a load was applied, and the ranges of motion and Von Mises stresses in the cortical endplates, screw-rod internal fixation system and cortical bone around the screws in the different groups were recorded and analyzed. All six ranges of motion (flexion, extension, left/right lateral bending, left/right rotation) of the surgical segment were substantially lower in groups 1 (0.53° ~ 1.41°), 2 (0.68° ~ 1.54°) and 3 (0.55° ~ 0.64°) than in group 4 (4.48° ~ 10.12°). The maximum stress in the screw-rod internal fixation system was clearly higher in group 2 than in groups 1 and 3 under flexion, left/right lateral bending, and left/right rotation. However, in extension, group 1 had the highest maximum stress in the screw-rod internal fixation system. Group 2 had the lowest peak stresses in the cortical endplates in all directions. The peak stresses in the cortical bone around the screws were higher in group 1 and group 2 than in group 3 in all directions. Thus, titanium cage with posterior double screw-rod fixation has more advantages in immediate reconstruction of lumbosacral spinal stability and prevention of screw loosening.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023comparison,
  author = {Jiantao Liu and Xi Gong and Kao Wang and Xingyuan Li and X N Zhang and Jiajun Sun and Yihan Zhu and Yixiang Ai and Jing Ren and Jintao Xiu and Wenchen Ji},
  title = {{A comparison of the biomechanical properties of three different lumbar internal fixation methods in the treatment of lumbosacral spinal tuberculosis: finite element analysis}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-32624-2},
}
Figure