A comparison of electronic health records at two major Peking University Hospitals in China to United States meaningful use objectives

Jianbo Lei, Paulina S. Sockolow, Pengcheng Guan, Qun Meng, Jiajie ZhangBMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper compares the electronic health record (EHR) functionalities of two leading hospitals in China against the US "Meaningful Use" (MU) objectives. It reveals that while Chinese EHRs are advancing rapidly, they currently meet approximately half of the US MU criteria, highlighting cultural and operational differences that influence EHR design and adoption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Chinese government's 2009 National Health Reform Plan emphasizes the critical role of health information technology (HIT) in modernizing its healthcare system. To guide this, China has begun developing its own HIT standards. However, the US has already established a comprehensive set of criteria for EHRs, known as Meaningful Use (MU) objectives, designed to improve clinical quality and safety. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how early adopters of EHRs in China align with these established US standards. By comparing Chinese EHRs to US MU objectives, the authors aim to inform future EHR development and policy in China, as well as contribute to informatics research in both countries by assessing the generalizability of US MU criteria.

Methods

The study employed a qualitative and descriptive approach, involving direct observation of physicians using EHR systems in two major Beijing hospitals. The researchers meticulously noted which MU functionalities were present and which were not. To capture a complete picture, they also interviewed IT departments about the availability of functionalities that were neither observed nor known to the physicians. This method is similar to previous studies assessing MU functionality in home care EHRs. A key methodological consideration was the translation of MU objectives from English to Chinese to ensure accurate understanding and observation.

Datasets

This paper does not use datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, it evaluates the functionality of existing EHR systems against a defined set of criteria (US Meaningful Use objectives). The "data" collected consists of observations of EHR usage and interviews with hospital staff.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cultural Nuances Impact EHR Design: Concepts like "preferred language" and "race" are not as relevant in China due to perceived homogeneity, leading to their absence in EHRs, whereas they are core MU requirements. Similarly, the US concept of "advanced directives" is handled differently, with specific consent forms for each procedure rather than a general directive.
  • Operational Differences Drive Functionality Gaps: The study identified that Chinese EHRs often lack functionalities like medication reconciliation due to less frequent care transitions between different healthcare providers. The emphasis on identifying the cause of a disease rather than just documenting abnormal signs and symptoms also influences how problem lists are maintained.
  • EHRs Meet About Half of US MU Objectives: Despite rapid adoption, the EHRs in the studied Chinese hospitals only met approximately half of the US Meaningful Use objectives, indicating a significant gap.
  • Need for National Standards in China: The observed lack of uniformity in EHR functionality even between two leading hospitals in China suggests a strong need for a national EHR standard, similar to the US MU framework, to ensure consistent quality and interoperability.
  • Different Adoption Drivers: While the US incentivizes EHR adoption through financial means, China's rapid adoption appears to be driven by strong government policy support as part of its broader health reform.

Key Results

  • Approximately half of the US Meaningful Use objectives were found to be available in the EHR systems of the two studied Peking University hospitals.
  • Specific functionalities that were generally not available or not fully implemented included: drug-allergy interaction checks (though drug-drug checks were present), maintaining an up-to-date problem list of current and active diagnoses (focus was on diagnoses, not symptoms), recording preferred language and race, charting changes in vital signs (though data was recorded), implementing clinical decision support (CDSS) rules, providing patients with electronic copies of their health information and discharge instructions, and exchanging key clinical information electronically.
  • Notable functionalities present in Chinese EHRs included the use of ICD-10 codes for diagnoses and the recording of patient occupation, which are areas of ongoing development in the US.
  • The study highlighted differences in how patients receive information, with Chinese hospitals providing oral patient education resources, unlike US hospitals that often provide printed materials.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the two hospitals studied were top-tier tertiary hospitals and early adopters, and thus may not be representative of all hospitals or EHR systems in China. It is possible that other hospitals may have more advanced EHR systems. Future work could involve a broader assessment of EHRs across different types of hospitals and regions in China. The study also suggests that China should implement an EMR certification program and a US MU-like standards and certification program to ensure the quality of EMR adoption, moving beyond simply increasing adoption rates.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{lei2013comparison,
  author = {Jianbo Lei and Paulina S. Sockolow and Pengcheng Guan and Qun Meng and Jiajie Zhang},
  title = {{A comparison of electronic health records at two major Peking University Hospitals in China to United States meaningful use objectives}},
  journal = {BMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak.},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1186/1472-6947-13-96},
}
Figure