Abstract
To provide a context for the potential threat of unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) sightings on airport operations, this paper compares the characteristics of UAS sightings with two common airport threats: wildlife strikes and runway incursions. This study analyzed over 60,000 events in a three-year period (September 2016 to August 2019), including 6,551 UAS sightings from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) UAS Sightings Report database, 47,574 wildlife strikes from the FAA Wildlife Strike database, and 6,041 runway incursions from the FAA Runway Safety database. The results suggest both similarities and differences among the airport threats. Both UAS sightings and wildlife strikes vary by time of year and time of day. UAS sightings and wildlife strikes farther from the airport occur at higher altitudes than sightings and strikes occurring close to the airport. However, UAS sightings are reported at higher altitudes than wildlife strikes, and the distance of UAS sightings from the airport is farther than that of wildlife strikes, in general. The severities of UAS sightings and runway incursions are similar. Pilots take evasive actions in three percent of UAS sightings, and runway incursions of severity A and B are also rare. Pilots of general aviation (GA) aircraft reported the most UAS sightings, and GA operations are also involved in more runway incursions. Considering the kind of airport affected, UAS sightings and wildlife strikes are more common at primary airports, notably large and medium hub airports, whereas runway incursions are more common at reliever airports. Generally, UAS have had a minimal impact on airport operations despite their growing prevalence, which reflects the overall success of integrating this new airspace user into the national airspace system.
Introduction
As Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS), or drones, become increasingly ubiquitous, reports of "UAS sightings" by pilots have surged, frequently sparking media alarm regarding aviation safety. However, the aviation industry has lacked a rigorous framework to determine if these sightings represent a unique, catastrophic threat or a manageable risk comparable to existing hazards.
This study addresses this gap by benchmarking UAS sightings against two established "known quantities" in aviation safety: wildlife strikes (a common environmental hazard) and runway incursions (a critical operational hazard). By comparing the frequency, location, and severity of these events, this research provides a data-driven perspective on how drones are currently affecting the National Airspace System (NAS).
Methodology
The researchers conducted a retrospective statistical analysis of over 60,000 safety events recorded between September 2016 and August 2019. The analysis integrated four primary FAA data sources: the UAS Sightings Report Database (6,551 reports), the Wildlife Strike Database (47,574 reports), the Runway Safety (RWS) Database (6,041 incursions), and the Air Traffic Activity Data System for normalization. A comparative framework was utilized to analyze four primary dimensions: temporal distribution, spatial distribution (altitude and distance), event severity, and operational context (aircraft and airport types).
Results and Analysis
The study revealed several key insights regarding the nature of UAS risks compared to traditional hazards.
Spatial and Temporal Patterns
Both UAS sightings and wildlife strikes exhibit strong seasonality, peaking in the summer months (May–July for UAS; July–October for wildlife). This correlates with increased drone hobbyist activity and migratory patterns. Spatially, UAS sightings occur significantly further from airports (average 6.94 miles) and at higher altitudes than wildlife strikes. While 70% of bird strikes occur below 500 feet, the average UAS sighting within 10 miles of an airport is at 2,692 feet—well above the standard 1,000-foot traffic pattern.
Severity and Operational Impact
A critical finding is the "3% Severity Benchmark": only 3.3% of UAS sightings required pilots to take evasive action. This closely mirrors the rarity of "Category A and B" runway incursions (the most severe), suggesting that while sightings are frequent, high-risk "near-misses" are relatively rare. Despite the high volume of reports, UAS have had a minimal impact on actual airport operations (delays/closures) compared to the massive disruption caused by wildlife or runway safety issues.
The General Aviation (GA) Connection
GA pilots are the primary reporters of UAS sightings and are also the most frequently involved in runway incursions. This suggests that the interface between recreational drones and GA traffic is the most active risk zone, likely because both operate at lower altitudes and often in less controlled environments. Furthermore, UAS sightings and wildlife strikes are primarily "Primary Airport" problems, peaking at large and medium hubs, whereas runway incursions are more prevalent at "Reliever" airports.
Discussion and Conclusion
The study concludes that the current integration of UAS into the NAS has been largely successful, with minimal operational impact despite growing prevalence. However, several limitations exist. UAS sightings are currently based on pilot visual acquisition, which lacks sensor verification (radar or telemetry). There is also a potential reporting bias, as GA pilots may have more "eyes-out-the-cockpit" time than commercial crews.
Future improvements should include the implementation of Remote ID to move from subjective pilot reports to objective, data-linked tracking. Additionally, developing a standardized UAS reporting system modeled after the FAA’s Wildlife Strike Database would significantly improve data granularity and risk assessment capabilities.
Summary updated