TL;DR
This paper provides a comparative empirical analysis of how China, the United States, and Japan utilized tax and fee reduction policies to mitigate the economic shock of COVID-19. It reveals distinct national strategies—ranging from the US focus on direct subsidies to China’s supply-side VAT relief—and evaluates their effectiveness in stabilizing GDP and employment.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic triggered a global economic contraction, leading to plummeting employment rates and stalled production. While most nations turned to fiscal policy to prevent a total collapse, there is a lack of granular, comparative research on which specific tax instruments (e.g., income tax vs. consumption tax vs. social security contributions) were most effective.
The authors aim to fill this gap by analyzing the "three major engines" of the global economy. They explore how different fiscal architectures—China’s reliance on turnover taxes versus the US and Japan’s focus on income taxes—influenced their respective recovery paths and policy choices.
Methods
The authors employ a comparative empirical analysis framework, examining data from 2020 to 2021. The study is structured into two main dimensions:
- Horizontal Comparison: Comparing the overall economic impact (GDP and employment) across the three nations.
- Vertical Comparison: Analyzing the growth rates of specific tax categories (VAT, income tax, excise tax, social security, etc.) within each country to see which levers were pulled most aggressively.
The approach is primarily descriptive and analytical, using year-on-year growth rates to correlate policy implementation with economic recovery markers.
Datasets
The study synthesizes data from several high-authority international and national sources:
- International: IMF Fiscal Policies Database, World Bank Data.
- China: National Bureau of Statistics, Ministry of Finance, and State Administration of Taxation.
- United States: Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and CEIC database.
- Japan: National Tax Service of Japan and CEIC database.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Divergent Strategies: The three economies targeted different parts of the economic cycle.
- The US focused on the demand side, using direct tax rebates and massive subsidies to boost household disposable income and stimulate consumption.
- Japan took a mixed approach, providing relief for income, consumption, and business taxes to stabilize employment and reduce the cost of living.
- China leaned into supply-side relief, focusing heavily on Value-Added Tax (VAT) and social security fund exemptions to lower the operating costs for enterprises and keep production lines running.
- The "Turnover Tax" Factor: Because China relies heavily on VAT and turnover taxes, its policy of reducing these rates had a more immediate "indirect" effect on lowering product prices and curbing inflation compared to the income-tax-heavy systems of the US and Japan.
- Social Security as a Lever: China used the suspension or reduction of social security premiums as a primary tool to help small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) survive, a tactic less emphasized in the US and Japanese tax-reduction packages.
Key Results
- GDP Recovery: China was the only one of the three to maintain positive GDP growth in 2020 (+2.24%), while the US (-3.49%) and Japan (-4.53%) saw significant contractions.
- Tax Revenue Volatility:
- In China, VAT revenue plummeted by 65.5% in Q2 2020, reflecting aggressive tax-cutting measures.
- In the US, subsidies saw a staggering growth rate of 1811.6% in Q2 2020, highlighting the shift from tax collection to direct fiscal injection.
- In Japan, business tax revenue dropped by 85.53% in Q2 2020, the most significant decline among its tax categories.
- Employment Stability: Japan’s employment rate remained remarkably stable (above 60%) despite the GDP drop, likely due to specific business tax reliefs aimed at preventing layoffs. China’s urban unemployment rate peaked at 4.2% in 2020 but stabilized as production resumed.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several constraints:
- Scope: The study is limited to only three countries; including emerging economies or the EU could provide a broader perspective.
- Depth of Modeling: The analysis relies on descriptive statistics and growth rates. The authors suggest that future research should employ "more rigorous empirical tests" (such as econometric modeling or CGE models) to isolate the impact of tax policies from other variables like monetary policy or lockdowns.
- Fiscal Sustainability: The paper notes that prolonged tax cuts increase the fiscal deficit. Future work is needed to determine the "sweet spot" where tax relief supports growth without compromising long-term fiscal health.
Summary updated