A Comparative Study on the Effect of Surface and Bulk Sulfates on the High-Temperature Selective Catalytic Reduction of NO with NH3 over CeO2

Chong Tan, Zhiwen Gu, Songil Sin, Jiawei Ji, Yan Wang, Baiyun Zhu, Lijun Cheng, Chunkai Huang, Lulu Li, Hongliang Zhang, Changjin TangCatalysts 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different forms of sulfate modification on cerium oxide (CeO2) impact its performance in high-temperature selective catalytic reduction (SCR) of nitrogen oxides (NOx) with ammonia (NH3). The researchers found that surface sulfates significantly boost NOx removal efficiency by creating more strong acid sites and suppressing unwanted ammonia oxidation, outperforming bulk sulfates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nitrogen oxides (NOx) are major air pollutants, and selective catalytic reduction (SCR) with ammonia is a key technology for their removal. While traditional SCR catalysts are effective at medium temperatures, there's a growing need for catalysts that can operate efficiently at high temperatures (above 400°C), such as those found in diesel engines, gas turbines, and waste incinerators. Existing high-temperature SCR catalysts often face challenges like ammonia oxidation and limited thermal stability.

Sulfur dioxide (SO2), a common component in flue gases, can interact with catalysts like cerium oxide (CeO2) to form sulfate species. Previous research suggests sulfates can enhance SCR performance by increasing acidity. However, it's been unclear whether the location of these sulfates – on the surface or within the bulk of the material – makes a difference. This paper aims to disentangle the distinct roles of surface versus bulk sulfates on CeO2 for high-temperature NH3-SCR.

Methods

The researchers developed two distinct CeO2 catalysts with comparable sulfate content but different sulfate distributions:

  • S-CeS (Surface Sulfates): Prepared using a vapor sulfation method where pure CeO2 was exposed to SO2 and O2 for a short duration. This method aims to deposit sulfates primarily on the catalyst's surface.
  • B-CeS (Bulk Sulfates): Synthesized using a novel top-down approach by directly calcining cerium sulfate precursor (Ce2(SO4)3·xH2O) at a high temperature (900°C). This method is designed to incorporate sulfates into the bulk of the CeO2 structure.

To differentiate between surface and bulk sulfates, a water leaching experiment was crucial. Surface sulfates are generally more soluble in water than bulk sulfates, allowing researchers to selectively remove them.

A suite of characterization techniques was employed to understand the catalysts' properties:

  • Thermogravimetric Analysis (TG): To study the thermal decomposition behavior of the sulfated precursor and confirm the presence of sulfates.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To observe the surface morphology of the catalysts.
  • Energy-Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS): To determine the elemental composition and sulfur content.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: To probe the vibrational modes and identify sulfate species, particularly their behavior after water leaching.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To analyze the crystalline structure of the CeO2.
  • X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS): To investigate the surface chemical states of elements (S 2p, Ce 3d, O 1s) and quantify surface sulfur and Ce3+/Ce4+ ratios.
  • H2 Temperature-Programmed Reduction (H2-TPR): To assess the redox properties and oxygen mobility of the catalysts.
  • Ammonia Temperature-Programmed Desorption (NH3-TPD): To quantify the acidity (weak and strong acid sites) of the catalysts.

Finally, NH3-SCR performance tests were conducted in a fixed-bed reactor across a temperature range of 200-500°C to evaluate NOx conversion and N2 selectivity. Additional tests for NO oxidation and NH3 oxidation were performed to understand the catalysts' redox behavior.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on synthesizing and characterizing novel catalysts and evaluating their performance in a controlled experimental setup.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Location Matters: The most significant finding is that the location of sulfate species (surface vs. bulk) profoundly impacts catalytic performance. Surface sulfates are demonstrably more beneficial for high-temperature NH3-SCR.
  • Surface Sulfates Enhance Acidity: S-CeS, with surface sulfates, developed a significantly higher concentration of strong acid sites compared to B-CeS. This is crucial for NH3 adsorption, the first step in the SCR reaction.
  • Surface Sulfates Suppress NH3 Oxidation: The S-CeS catalyst showed suppressed NH3 oxidation, which is a common issue at high temperatures that reduces the availability of NH3 for NOx reduction. This suppression is attributed to the strong coverage of sulfate species on the CeO2 surface, limiting the availability of active surface oxygen.
  • Water Leaching as a Discriminator: The innovative use of water leaching to distinguish between surface and bulk sulfates, confirmed by Raman spectroscopy, is a key methodological contribution. The significant decrease in sulfate signal in B-CeS-W (water-leached B-CeS) versus the negligible change in S-CeS-W (water-leached S-CeS) clearly illustrates this difference.
  • Bulk Sulfates Offer Limited Benefit: While B-CeS also showed improved performance over bare CeO2, its contribution to high-temperature SCR was significantly less than S-CeS. The water-leaching experiment further confirmed that removing bulk sulfates had a minimal impact on the high-temperature performance of B-CeS.

Key Results

  • NOx Conversion: S-CeS achieved over 90% NOx conversion in the high-temperature range of 350-450°C, significantly outperforming B-CeS and bare CeO2. B-CeS showed moderate improvement over CeO2.
  • NH3 Oxidation: S-CeS exhibited a lower NH3 oxidation capacity compared to B-CeS, which is beneficial for high-temperature SCR.
  • Acidity: NH3-TPD results showed that S-CeS possessed more strong acid sites (peak at ~263°C) compared to B-CeS, which was dominated by weak acid sites (peak at ~150°C).
  • Redox Properties: H2-TPR indicated that S-CeS had altered redox behavior, with a disappearance of the low-temperature oxygen reduction peak (attributed to surface oxygen) and a shift of another peak to higher temperatures, suggesting a less facile reduction of surface oxygen.
  • Stability: Both sulfated catalysts demonstrated good reaction stability at 450°C over 240 minutes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Temperature Range for Oxidation Tests: The NO and NH3 oxidation experiments were conducted at a limited temperature range (200-500°C). Further investigation across a broader range might provide more comprehensive insights.
  • Focus on CeO2: While the study focuses on CeO2, future work could explore the synergistic effects of surface sulfates on other SCR catalyst supports or active components.
  • Long-Term Stability Under Realistic Conditions: While short-term stability was good, long-term performance under realistic flue gas conditions (including potential poisons like water vapor and SO3) would be valuable.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: While the study provides strong evidence for the roles of acidity and NH3 oxidation, a deeper mechanistic understanding of how surface sulfates specifically interact with NOx and NH3 at the molecular level could be explored through advanced in-situ/operando spectroscopy.

The authors suggest that the enhanced performance of S-CeS is due to the combined effects of increased strong acidity and reduced NH3 oxidation capacity, making surface sulfates a promising strategy for developing efficient high-temperature NH3-SCR catalysts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Herein, two CeO2 samples dominantly decorated with surface and bulk sulfates were constructed and their distinct effects on high-temperature NH3-SCR were investigated by strictly controlling the sulfate content at a comparable level. The obtainment of surface and bulk sulfates was revealed using a designed leaching experiment, and further evidenced by the characterization results from XPS and H2-TPR. In comparison with CeO2 modified with bulk sulfates (B-CeS), sufficient acid sites with strong intensity were generated on CeO2 modified with surface sulfates (S-CeS). In addition, due to electron-withdrawing effect from S=O in sulfate species, NH3 oxidation over S-CeS was greatly suppressed, providing an additional contribution to enhanced performance in high-temperature NH3-SCR.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2023comparative,
  author = {Chong Tan and Zhiwen Gu and Songil Sin and Jiawei Ji and Yan Wang and Baiyun Zhu and Lijun Cheng and Chunkai Huang and Lulu Li and Hongliang Zhang and Changjin Tang},
  title = {{A Comparative Study on the Effect of Surface and Bulk Sulfates on the High-Temperature Selective Catalytic Reduction of NO with NH3 over CeO2}},
  booktitle = {Catalysts},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/catal13081162},
}
Figure