A Comparative Study of Two Contrasting Cosmic-Ray Events Caused by Solar Eruptions from NOAA AR 12673 in 2017 September

Xiaoxia Yu, Shuang‐Nan Zhang, H. Lu, Hong Hu, Ping Zhang, Wei GaoThe Astrophysical Journal 2023 · DOI

This study, published in The Astrophysical Journal, provides a detailed "forensic" analysis of two massive solar eruptions from September 2017. Despite originating from the same active region on the Sun and featuring similar X-class flares, these events had opposite effects on the cosmic-ray environment at Earth. By tracing the complete cause-and-effect chain from the Sun’s surface to ground-based detectors, the authors identify why one storm shielded Earth from radiation while the other showered it with high-energy particles.

TL;DR

Researchers compared two major solar eruptions from the same active region that produced contrasting cosmic-ray events: a Forbush decrease (reduction) and a ground-level enhancement (increase). The study concludes that while CME geometry determines shielding effects, the absolute speed of the CME-driven shock is the primary driver for accelerating particles to relativistic, ground-detectable energies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solar eruptions—specifically Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) and solar flares—impact the flux of cosmic rays reaching Earth in two primary ways:

  1. Forbush Decreases (FD): A temporary dip in the intensity of Galactic Cosmic Rays (GCRs), caused when the magnetic fields within a CME "sweep" away or deflect incoming deep-space radiation.
  2. Ground-Level Enhancements (GLE): A sudden spike in radiation caused by Solar Energetic Particles (SEPs) accelerated to such high energies (GeV range) that they penetrate Earth's atmosphere and create secondary particles detectable at the surface.

The central mystery of this paper is why two seemingly similar events from Active Region 12673 produced such different outcomes. The first eruption (Sept 6) was magnetically well-connected to Earth but only caused an FD. The second (Sept 10), occurring near the Sun's limb and poorly connected to Earth, triggered a significant GLE. Understanding these "dominant factors" is crucial for space weather forecasting and protecting satellite and aviation infrastructure.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-instrument "cause-effect chain" analysis:

  • Remote Sensing: Used SDO/AIA (Extreme Ultraviolet) and SOHO/LASCO (white-light coronagraphs) to observe the initiation and 3D structure of the CMEs.
  • 3D Modeling: Applied the Graduated Cylindrical Shell (GCS) model and a spheroid shock model to reconstruct the true 3D geometry, orientation, and "true" (not just projected) speeds of the eruptions.
  • In-situ Measurements: Data from DSCOVR and WIND spacecraft at the L1 point provided local solar wind plasma and magnetic field conditions.
  • Ground-Based Detection: Analyzed data from the International GLE Database, specifically focusing on Neutron Monitors (NMs) like DOMB and OULU to measure the final cosmic-ray impact.

Datasets

  • Solar Activity: GOES X-ray flux for flare classification; SDO/HMI for magnetic field maps of the source region.
  • CME Tracking: SOHO/LASCO and STEREO-A coronagraph images.
  • Particle Flux: ACE/SIS and GOES-15 for proton, iron, and oxygen flux measurements.
  • Ground Impact: Count rates from various polar and high-latitude Neutron Monitors (DOMB, FSMT, JBGO, SOPO, TERA, THUL, OULU).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometry vs. Intensity: The study highlights a "geometric effect" for FDs. The Sept 6 CME hit Earth head-on, allowing its magnetic "ejecta" to block GCRs. In contrast, the Sept 10 CME was directed away from Earth; only its "far flank" reached us, meaning the shielding ejecta missed the planet entirely.
  • The Speed Threshold: The Sept 10 eruption featured a peak shock speed of 3344 km/s, significantly faster than the Sept 6 event (2175 km/s). This extreme speed is identified as the "dominant factor" for the GLE, as it provided the energy necessary to accelerate particles to relativistic speeds.
  • Connectivity Paradox: Conventionally, better magnetic connectivity (the "Parker Spiral" path from Sun to Earth) is thought to favor GLEs. However, this paper shows that a sufficiently fast shock can overcome poor connectivity, producing a GLE even when Earth only intercepts the shock's edge.
  • Shock-Dominant Acceleration: The low Iron-to-Oxygen (Fe/O) ratio observed in the Sept 10 event suggests that the particles were accelerated by the CME-driven shock rather than the solar flare itself.

Key Results

  • Event 1 (Sept 6): X9.3 flare at W34° longitude. Produced a 15% Forbush decrease on Sept 8. The CME ejecta directly intercepted Earth.
  • Event 2 (Sept 10): X8.2 flare at W88° longitude. Produced a +8% Ground-Level Enhancement (GLE 72).
  • Quantitative Speed Gap: The second event's shock was ~1169 km/s faster than the first. The authors argue that GLE production is dominated by shocks exceeding a certain high-velocity threshold (often cited around 2000–2500 km/s in literature).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Sample: The study is limited to a comparative analysis of just two events. While they provide a "controlled" comparison (same AR, similar flares), broader statistical studies are needed to codify these speed thresholds.
  • Acceleration Ambiguity: While the data points toward shock acceleration for the GLE, the paper acknowledges the ongoing debate regarding the relative contributions of flares vs. shocks in particle acceleration.
  • 3D Modeling Constraints: Reconstructions rely on specific geometric assumptions (GCS model); more multi-viewpoint observations from different heliospheric angles would improve the accuracy of shock-front modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Two major solar eruptions on AR 12673 produced a Forbush decrease (FD) event (reduction of cosmic rays) on 2017 September 8 and ground-level enhancement (GLE; enhancement of cosmic rays) on 2017 September 10. The occurrence of two contrasting cosmic-ray events within 2 days that are associated with two similar X-class solar flares (X9.3 and X8.2) and share the same active region on the Sun provides us a rare opportunity to understand the dominant factors in determining the properties of transient cosmic-ray events. Using a suite of modern-day instruments continuously tracking solar eruptions from the Sun to the Earth with ground-based cosmic-ray detectors, we reveal the complete cause–effect chain of activities for these two events. We conclude that the different consequences on the ground arise from two effects of the eruptions near the Sun: (1) the geometric effect of CMEs and (2) the intensity effect of CME-driven shocks. The first eruption, which originated at the heliographic longitude of W34° on 2017 September 6, had its CME ejecta and CME-driven shock intercept the Earth, leading to the FD event. The second eruption, which occurred on September 10 at W88°, only had its far flank reach the Earth. The peak shock speed of 3344 km s −1 of the second eruption, much faster than the 2175 km s −1 of the first eruption, is the dominant factor producing the GLE event, even though the first eruption is better connected magnetically to the Earth and has a similar flare. The results indicate that the production of GLE particles can be dominated by fast-enough CME-driven shocks.
BibTeX
@article{yu2023comparative,
  author = {Xiaoxia Yu and Shuang‐Nan Zhang and H. Lu and Hong Hu and Ping Zhang and Wei Gao},
  title = {{A Comparative Study of Two Contrasting Cosmic-Ray Events Caused by Solar Eruptions from NOAA AR 12673 in 2017 September}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ad0550},
}
Figure