A Comparative Reverse Docking Strategy to Identify Potential Antineoplastic Targets of Tea Functional Components and Binding Mode

Rong Zheng, Tuan-sheng Chen, Tun LuInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a comparative reverse docking strategy to pinpoint potential anti-cancer targets for green tea's active compounds. By employing two distinct docking software packages, Autodock and Tarfisdock, the researchers identified several promising protein targets for EGCG and other catechins, offering valuable insights into their anti-tumor mechanisms and guiding future drug development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Green tea is known for its broad anti-cancer properties, largely attributed to its functional components like epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG). However, the precise molecular mechanisms behind these effects, specifically identifying the proteins these compounds interact with (their targets), remain unclear. Traditional methods for target identification are laborious. While virtual screening and reverse docking have emerged as powerful computational tools, there's a need to compare different reverse docking approaches to ensure reliability and to explore the binding interactions in detail to understand how these compounds exert their effects. This paper addresses this by comparing two established reverse docking systems and then delving into the binding mode of EGCG with a key identified target.

Methods

The core of this study is a comparative reverse docking strategy. This involves using two different computational tools to predict potential protein targets for tea polyphenols:

  • Autodock: A widely used molecular docking software that employs a Lamarckian genetic algorithm and a comprehensive scoring function considering hydrogen bonding and solvation free energy.
  • Tarfisdock: A web server based on the DOCK program, which uses a fragment growth method and a scoring function focused on non-bond interaction energy terms.

Two separate in silico workflows were implemented. In each workflow, the tea polyphenols (EGCG, EGC, ECG, and EC) were "docked" against a large database of potential drug targets (PDTD database). The goal was to find proteins that bind strongly to these compounds. The results from both Autodock and Tarfisdock were then compared to identify common targets and assess the reliability of each method.

Beyond identifying targets, the researchers also performed a detailed analysis of the binding mode of EGCG with one of its most promising predicted targets, Leukotriene A4 hydrolase. This involved visualizing the interactions (hydrogen bonds, electrostatic forces) between EGCG and the active site of the enzyme to understand the molecular basis of their interaction.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary databases:

  • MMsINC database: Provided the 3D crystal structures for the four tea polyphenols (EGCG, EGC, ECG, EC).
  • PDTD (Potential Drug Target Database): This database served as the source of potential drug target proteins. It contains over 1100 3D protein structures across 15 therapeutic areas, including tumor therapy.

Additionally, for validating the docking results, experimental data and references were used to compare predicted targets with those already implicated experimentally. Three experimental targets of EGCG that were not present in the PDTD database were obtained from the PDB database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Comparative Reverse Docking is Powerful: Using multiple reverse docking tools (Autodock and Tarfisdock) and comparing their results significantly enhances the confidence in identifying potential drug targets. This approach helps overcome the limitations of any single method.
  • Green Tea Catechins Target Diverse Proteins: The study identified a range of potential protein targets for EGCG, ECG, EGC, and EC, many of which are implicated in cancer and other diseases. This suggests that the anti-cancer effects of green tea are likely multi-faceted, acting on various cellular pathways.
  • EGCG and Leukotriene A4 Hydrolase Interaction is Significant: The detailed analysis of EGCG binding to Leukotriene A4 hydrolase revealed that electrostatic interactions and hydrogen bonds are crucial for this binding. This interaction suggests EGCG might act as a competitive inhibitor of this enzyme, which is linked to myocardial infarction and inflammation.
  • Structural Similarities Lead to Overlapping Targets: Catechins with similar chemical structures (like ECG and EGCG) tend to bind to a similar set of protein targets, highlighting the importance of subtle structural differences in determining binding specificity.

Key Results

  • The comparative reverse docking strategy successfully identified several known experimental targets for EGCG, including 67 kD laminin receptor, HIV protease, glutathione reductase, catalase, and eEF1-a.
  • Eight out of nine protein receptors previously implicated experimentally for EGCG were identified by at least one of the docking procedures.
  • Leukotriene A4 hydrolase, Farnesyl protein transferase, and HIV protease were identified as common potential targets for EGCG by both Autodock and Tarfisdock.
  • For EGC, the highest match rate (27.30%) was observed, followed by EGCG (18.20%) and EC (4.50%), indicating differences in target identification efficiency between the catechins and the software.
  • The binding free energy for EGCG with Leukotriene A4 hydrolase was predicted to be -6.8 kcal/mol by Autodock, and -5.22 kcal/mol by Tarfisdock.
  • The docking simulation of EGCG with Leukotriene A4 hydrolase showed that EGCG forms multiple hydrogen bonds with key residues in the active site, suggesting a competitive inhibitory mechanism.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Protein Flexibility: The authors acknowledge that both Autodock and Tarfisdock do not fully account for protein conformational flexibility, which might explain why some experimentally verified targets were not identified in the top ranks. Future work could incorporate more advanced methods that consider protein dynamics.
  • Experimental Validation: While the study identified promising targets, it emphasizes that further experimental validation is crucial to confirm these predictions and fully elucidate the anti-tumor mechanisms of tea polyphenols.
  • Broader Catechin Analysis: While EGCG's binding mode was explored in detail, further in-depth analysis of the binding modes for other catechins (ECG, EGC, EC) with their respective top targets could provide more comprehensive insights.
  • Drug Design Guidance: The study provides a foundation for designing new targeted drugs with anti-neoplastic effects by identifying key binding mechanisms. Future research could leverage these findings to design novel drug candidates based on the tea polyphenol structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

The main functional components of green tea, such as epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), epigallocatechin (EGC), epicatechin gallate (ECG) and epicatechin (EC), are found to have a broad antineoplastic activity. The discovery of their targets plays an important role in revealing the antineoplastic mechanism. Therefore, to identify potential target proteins for tea polyphenols, we have taken a comparative virtual screening approach using two reverse docking systems, one based on Autodock software and the other on Tarfisdock. Two separate in silico workflows were implemented to derive a set of target proteins related to human diseases and ranked by the binding energy score. Several conventional clinically important proteins with anti-tumor effects are screened out from the PDTD protein database as the potential receptors by both procedures. To further analyze the validity of docking results, we study the binding mode of EGCG and the potential target protein Leukotriene A4 hydrolase in detail. We indicate that interactions mediated by electrostatic and hydrogen bond play a key role in ligand binding. EGCG binds to the enzyme with certain orientation and conformation that is suitable for nucleophilic attacks by several electrical residues inside the enzyme's activity cavity. This study provides useful information for studying the antitumor mechanism of tea's functional components. The comparative reverse docking strategy presented generates a tractable set of antineoplastic proteins for future experimental validation as drug targets against tumors.
BibTeX
@article{zheng2011comparative,
  author = {Rong Zheng and Tuan-sheng Chen and Tun Lu},
  title = {{A Comparative Reverse Docking Strategy to Identify Potential Antineoplastic Targets of Tea Functional Components and Binding Mode}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms12085200},
}
Figure