A Comparative Analysis on Volatility and Scalability Properties of Blockchain Compression Protocols

Gerui Zhang, Xiongfei Zhao, Yain-Whar SiarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction: The Scalability-Security Trade-off

Blockchain networks like Bitcoin and Ethereum face a persistent scalability bottleneck, processing only a fraction of the transaction volume seen in centralized systems like VISA. While many "Layer 1" solutions focus on increasing block capacity through compression protocols, these changes can have unintended consequences for network security. Specifically, as block subsidies (newly minted coins) decrease over time, miners must rely almost exclusively on transaction fees. This transition to a Transaction Fee Regime introduces significant reward volatility.

If a network is scaled poorly, the rewards for mining a block can become highly unpredictable. This volatility leads to "Mining Gaps"—periods where it is temporarily unprofitable to mine—or encourages "Selfish Mining" strategies. The following figure illustrates how block incentives must exceed mining costs to maintain continuous activity.

Figure 1: Relationship between block incentives, mining costs, and mining activity duration.

Methodology: Simulating Compression and Network Dynamics

The researchers evaluated six state-of-the-art compression protocols: Compact, XThin, Graphene, XThinner, IPFS Model, and Dino. Their evaluation combined two distinct experimental phases:

  1. Monte Carlo Simulation: Protocols like Graphene and XThinner have variable compression rates based on the state of the mempool. The authors used Monte Carlo methods to estimate average block sizes and capacities across a range of 1,000 to 1,000,000 transactions per block.
  2. Network Simulation (SimBlock): Using an event-driven simulator, they modeled the Bitcoin network's behavior under various scaling scenarios, measuring the Historical Volatility (HV) of miner rewards as Transactions Per Second (TPS) increased.

The study utilized six months of historical Bitcoin transaction data (May–November 2021), analyzing approximately 40 million transactions to model fee distributions accurately.

The Volatility U-Curve and the "Critical Point"

A key finding of the paper is that the relationship between scalability and reward volatility is non-linear, following a U-shaped curve.

  • Underscaling: At very low TPS, volatility is high because of intense competition for limited block space.
  • The Sweet Spot: As TPS increases, volatility drops to a minimum. In the simulated environment, this "critical point" occurred at approximately 295 TPS.
  • Overscaling: If throughput is pushed too far, volatility begins to climb again. This happens because high-value transactions are either spread too thin across many blocks or become clumped together, making some blocks significantly more valuable than others.

Protocol Performance and Security Implications

The paper argues that compression protocols should not be judged solely on their compression ratios. If a protocol allows for a block size that pushes the network into "overscaling," it inadvertently increases the risk of forks and malicious mining strategies.

Figure 5: High and low bandwidth relaying mechanisms in the Compact block protocol.

Among the tested protocols, Compact demonstrated the lowest reward volatility. In contrast, while Graphene and XThinner offer superior compression, they exhibited higher reward volatility when pushed to their limits. The researchers identified a general scaling limit of roughly 1350 TPS to avoid the most severe effects of overscaling.

To maintain volatility within historical norms, the authors proposed maximum block sizes for specific protocols:

  • Graphene: ~1.81 MB
  • XThinner: ~1.89 MB
  • Compact/XThin/IPFS: Capped at 4 MB (limited by network propagation constraints rather than volatility).

Conclusion and Future Directions

Scaling blockchain throughput is a delicate balancing act with miner incentives. The study highlights that over-optimizing for compression can destabilize the network by increasing reward volatility. Future research will explore how dynamic block times might interact with compression to stabilize rewards and investigate more sophisticated incentivization models to mitigate the risks associated with overscaling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasing popularity of trading digital assets can lead to significant delays in Blockchain networks when processing transactions. When transaction fees become miners' primary revenue, an imbalance in reward may lead to miners adopting deviant mining strategies. Scaling the block capacity is one of the potential approaches to alleviate the problem. To address this issue, this paper reviews and evaluates six state-of-the-art compression protocols for Blockchains. Specifically, we designed a Monte Carlo simulation to simulate two of the six protocols to observe their compression performance under larger block capacities. Furthermore, extensive simulation experiments were conducted to observe the mining behaviour when the block capacity is increased. Experimental results reveal an interesting trade-off between volatility and scalability. When the throughput is higher than a critical point, it worsens the volatility and threatens Blockchain security. In the experiments, we further analyzed the relationship between volatility and scalability properties with respect to the distribution of transaction values. Based on the analysis results, we proposed the recommended maximum block size for each protocol. At last, we discuss the further improvement of the compression protocols.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023comparative,
  author = {Gerui Zhang and Xiongfei Zhao and Yain-Whar Si},
  title = {{A Comparative Analysis on Volatility and Scalability Properties of Blockchain Compression Protocols}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2303.17643},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17643},
}
Figure