A Comparative Analysis of ODA and Growth in East Asia Pacific and Sub-Saharan Africa

Sim Yee Lau, Pui Mun Yin, Hongxu ChenInternational Journal of Business and Society 2022 · DOI

Abstract This paper reports a comparative empirical analysis on the role of official development assistance (ODA) in influencing growth in East Asia Pacific (EAP) and Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) regions. The distinct difference in growth patterns between these two regions in the past five decades motivates our research to examine what factors contributed to the difference in growth. This study examines, from the financial gap perspective, the role of foreign aid in promoting growth in the two regions. On this basis, our study constructs a theoretical framework by specifying a behavioral equation to examine the relationship between foreign aid and growth supported by capital formation and human resource development. The analytical results induce two conclusions: ODA impacts positively on economic growth in the EAP region but with time lagged effects, and ODA influences economic growth differently by region. The results from the dynamic GMM approach have shown that ODA contributed positively to economic growth in the EAP region but not in the SSA region. Hence, donors, recipients, and aid practitioners must reexamine aid effectiveness especially in the SSA region.

Introduction

Since the 1960s, the economic trajectories of East Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa have diverged spectacularly. While the "Asian Tigers" and their neighbors achieved rapid industrialization, many African nations remained trapped in poverty. Economists have long debated the role of Official Development Assistance (ODA) in this divergence. Does aid provide the "Big Push" needed to break the poverty trap, or is it a "White Man’s Burden" that fosters dependency? This paper tackles this "aid-growth nexus" by testing the financial gap model—the idea that aid promotes growth by filling gaps in domestic savings, foreign exchange, and fiscal revenue, thereby enabling capital formation and human resource development.

Methodology

The study employs a comparative empirical analysis using two primary econometric approaches to handle the complexities of cross-country data:

  1. Two-Stage Least Square (2SLS) Instrumental Variable Estimator: This addresses endogeneity—the "chicken and egg" problem where it is unclear if aid causes growth or if low growth attracts more aid. Social indicators such as life expectancy, school enrollment, and water access are used as instruments for aid.
  2. Dynamic GMM (Generalized Method of Moments): Specifically, Difference GMM and System GMM are used to account for the fact that current GDP is heavily influenced by past GDP, while also controlling for unique country characteristics (fixed effects) and heteroscedasticity.

Data and Variables

The study utilizes unbalanced panel data spanning from 1980 to 2013, sourced from the World Bank’s World Development Indicators (WDI). The sample includes 11 developing countries in the EAP group (e.g., China, Indonesia, Vietnam) and 15 in the SSA group (e.g., Ethiopia, Kenya, Botswana).

Descriptive statistics for the East Asia Pacific (EAP) region variables.
Descriptive statistics for the Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) region variables.

Empirical Results and Key Insights

The "Slow Brew" Effect in East Asia

In the EAP region, ODA does not yield immediate results. The analysis reveals a significant positive impact only after a three-to-four-year lag. This suggests that ODA-funded infrastructure, such as ports and power plants, requires time to mature and integrate into the economy. A 1% increase in ODA (lagged 3-4 years) is associated with a GDP per capita increase of approximately 0.0056% to 0.0067%.

The Regional Efficacy Gap

The most striking finding is that the financial gap logic holding in East Asia fails in Sub-Saharan Africa. In SSA, the impact of ODA was either statistically insignificant or, in some lagged models, slightly negative. While individual aid projects might succeed at a micro-level, they often fail to move national GDP in Africa, likely due to poor "absorptive capacity" or institutional bottlenecks.

Capital Formation and Openness

In East Asia, Gross Fixed Capital Formation (GFCF) was a massive driver of growth, with ODA effectively "crowding in" private investment and Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). Conversely, economic openness and FDI were largely insignificant for the SSA countries in this dataset, suggesting these nations have not yet benefited from global trade integration to the same degree.

Conclusion

The study concludes that ODA impacts economic growth differently by region. While it has been a successful component of the East Asian miracle, it has failed to stimulate growth in Sub-Saharan Africa within the studied framework. Policy recommendations suggest that SSA nations should move away from a "transformative" aid framework toward a "marginal" (piecemeal) approach with improved feedback loops to ensure aid reaches productive sectors effectively.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper reports a comparative empirical analysis on the role of official development assistance (ODA) in influencing growth in East Asia Pacific (EAP) and Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) regions. The distinct difference in growth patterns between these two regions in the past five decades motivates our research to examine what factors contributed to the difference in growth. This study examines, from the financial gap perspective, the role of foreign aid in promoting growth in the two regions. On this basis, our study constructs a theoretical framework by specifying a behavioral equation to examine the relationship between foreign aid and growth supported by capital formation and human resource development. The empirical inquiry uses: two-stage least square instrumental variable estimator; and the generalized method of moments (GMM) estimation of dynamic panel data model. The analytical results induce two conclusions: ODA impacts positively on economic growth in the EAP region but with time lagged effects, and ODA influences economic growth differently by region. The results from the dynamic GMM approach have shown that ODA contributed positively to economic growth in the EAP region but not in the SSA region. Hence, donors, recipients, and aid practitioners must reexamine aid effectiveness especially in the SSA region.
BibTeX
@article{lau2022comparative,
  author = {Sim Yee Lau and Pui Mun Yin and Hongxu Chen},
  title = {{A Comparative Analysis of ODA and Growth in East Asia Pacific and Sub-Saharan Africa}},
  journal = {International Journal of Business and Society},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.33736/ijbs.5216.2022},
}
Figure