TL;DR
This study compares extreme heat events (EHEs) in two major Chinese urban areas, the Yangtze River Delta (YRD) and the Pearl River Delta (PRD). It reveals distinct synoptic drivers for heatwaves in each region, with the YRD dominated by a strong subtropical high and the PRD influenced by a combination of high-pressure systems and tropical cyclones, highlighting the critical role of local geography and weather patterns in shaping urban heat extremes.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Extreme heat events (EHEs) are a growing global concern, posing significant threats to human health, economies, and ecosystems. As urbanization accelerates, particularly in densely populated regions like Southeast China, understanding the specific characteristics and underlying causes of EHEs in these urban areas becomes crucial for effective mitigation and adaptation strategies. While general factors contributing to heatwaves are known (e.g., climate variability, synoptic systems, land surface properties), there's a need for detailed comparative analyses of distinct urban agglomerations to pinpoint regional differences in EHE drivers and their interplay with local conditions. This paper addresses this by comparing EHEs in the Yangtze River Delta (YRD) and the Pearl River Delta (PRD), two major economic hubs in Southeast China, to elucidate their unique spatial-temporal distributions and synoptic backgrounds.
Methods
The study employs a multi-faceted approach to analyze extreme heat events (EHEs). Heatwaves are defined as periods of over three consecutive days with maximum temperatures exceeding 35°C, a standard metric used in China. Warm nights are identified when minimum temperatures exceed 27°C, based on the 90th percentile of nighttime temperatures. The researchers calculated the occurrence frequency and average cumulative intensity of heatwaves and warm nights at individual weather stations. Regional heatwaves were defined as occurring when at least half of the stations in a region experienced a heatwave simultaneously. To understand the synoptic drivers, the study utilized the ERA5 reanalysis dataset to composite atmospheric fields (geopotential height, wind vectors, vertical velocity, cloud cover, net solar radiation) for different types of heatwave events (YRD-only, PRD-only, and simultaneous). Anomalies were calculated to highlight deviations from the mid-summer average.
Datasets
- Surface Weather Station Data: Daily maximum and minimum 2m air temperature data from 93 stations in the YRD and 46 stations in the PRD (including Hong Kong Observatory) were used to identify EHEs. This data was quality-controlled by the National Meteorological Information Center (NMIC) of China.
- ERA5 Reanalysis Data: Hourly data on a 0.25°×0.25° grid and 37 vertical levels were used for analyzing synoptic backgrounds.
- Tropical Cyclone (TC) Best Track Dataset: Provided by the China Meteorological Administration (CMA), this dataset was used to identify TCs associated with heatwaves.
- Nighttime Lights Data: The fourth version of composite satellite-based nighttime lights data (2013) from the Defense Meteorological Satellite Program's Operational Linescan System (DMSP/OLS) was used to distinguish urban and rural areas, with a digital number (DN) value of 57 serving as the urban threshold.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Local Geography Matters: The study strongly emphasizes how local geographical features, like land-sea contrast and terrain, significantly modulate the occurrence and intensity of heatwaves in both regions.
- Urban Heat Island (UHI) Amplifies Warm Nights: The UHI effect is a major contributor to more frequent and intense warm nights in urban areas compared to rural surroundings, exacerbating the impact of heatwaves.
- Distinct Synoptic Drivers: The YRD heatwaves are primarily driven by a persistent, strong subtropical high, leading to descending motion and clear skies. In contrast, PRD heatwaves are more complex, often involving tropical cyclones in conjunction with high-pressure systems.
- Tropical Cyclones' Dual Role: While TCs are often associated with cooling, in the PRD context, their outer circulation can drive northerly winds that transport warm inland air, which is then heated by foehn effects and surface fluxes, leading to extreme temperatures.
- Timing is Crucial: The YRD experiences heatwaves more concentrated in mid-summer (July-August), while the PRD has a broader heatwave season extending into June and August. This timing difference contributes to the YRD's generally more intense heatwaves.
Key Results
- Heatwave Frequency: Heatwave frequency generally decreases from inland mountains towards the coast in both regions, likely due to sea breeze effects.
- Warm Night Intensity: Urban stations in both YRD and PRD experience significantly higher proportions (YRD: ~73%, PRD: ~66%) and intensities of warm nights during heatwaves compared to rural stations (YRD: ~53%, PRD: ~31%).
- Intensity Discrepancy: The warm-season average cumulative intensity of heatwaves in the YRD is approximately 2-3 times higher than in the PRD.
- YRD Heatwave Drivers: ~80% of YRD regional heatwaves are linked to a dominant subtropical high, causing descending motion and reduced cloud cover, leading to enhanced solar radiation and adiabatic heating.
- PRD Heatwave Drivers: ~53% of PRD heatwaves occur in mid-summer and are influenced by both TCs and subtropical high-pressure systems. Notably, ~72% of PRD heatwave days involve a TC to the east. The foehn effect from inland mountains, driven by TC-associated northerly winds, plays a key role in PRD heatwaves. When TCs are absent, a local high-pressure system becomes the primary driver.
- Simultaneous Heatwaves: When heatwaves occur in both regions simultaneously, they are driven by either an extremely intense subtropical high covering both areas or a combination of an enhanced WNPSH over the YRD and TCs influencing the PRD.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Heatwave Duration Analysis: The study focuses on the occurrence and intensity of heatwaves but suggests further investigation into the duration of heatwaves under different circulation patterns.
- Speculative Foehn Effect Role: The role of upstream surface sensible heat flux in PRD heatwaves is speculated based on previous studies, and quantitative analysis for the current cases is needed.
- TC Track Uncertainty: The projection of TC tracks, which significantly influences PRD heatwaves, is associated with large uncertainties, making future EHE predictions challenging.
- Extended Analysis Period: The authors suggest extending the analysis period to improve the statistical significance and robustness of the conclusions.
- Thermal Comfort Indices: Incorporating thermal biometeorological indices like PET and UTCI would provide a more comprehensive understanding of EHE impacts beyond just temperature.
- Predictability and Variability: Further research on the predictability of circulation patterns and their linkage with atmospheric variability modes and sea surface temperature is recommended for improved EHE prediction.
Summary updated