A common pattern of influenza A virus single cell gene expression heterogeneity governs the innate antiviral response to infection

J. Cristobal Vera, Jiayi Sun, Yen Ting Lin, Jenny Drnevich, Ruian Ke, Christopher B. BrookebioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that influenza A virus infection leads to a surprisingly diverse range of host cell responses at the single-cell level, driven by both viral and host heterogeneity. A key finding is that the expression of the viral NS gene segment often diverges from the rest of the viral genome, and this divergence significantly influences the host's antiviral response, particularly in H3N2 infections.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how viruses interact with host cells is crucial for controlling infections. While we know that both virus populations and host cells are diverse, how this heterogeneity impacts the infection process and the host's defense mechanisms is not well understood. Specifically, for influenza A virus (IAV), it's unclear how the variability in viral gene expression within individual infected cells influences the host's innate antiviral response. Previous studies have been limited by the number of cells analyzed and experimental design, making it difficult to dissect these complex interactions.

Methods

The researchers employed single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) to analyze the transcriptomes of thousands of individual cells infected with influenza A virus. They infected A549 cells with the H1N1 strain A/California/07/2009 (Cal07) at a very low multiplicity of infection (MOI) to ensure most infected cells received only a single virion. To enrich for infected cells and block secondary spread, they used antibody staining for viral surface proteins (HA and M2) and NH4Cl treatment, respectively. The sorted infected, bystander, and mock-infected cells were then subjected to scRNA-seq using the 10x Genomics Chromium platform. They used a customized hybrid reference for mapping viral and human sequences and employed advanced bioinformatics tools (MAST, NBID, scran, Seurat) for data processing, normalization, clustering, and differential gene expression analysis.

Datasets

The study utilized A549 cells infected with the influenza A virus strains A/California/07/2009 (Cal07, H1N1) and A/Perth/16/2009 (Perth09, H3N2). The scRNA-seq data generated from these experiments, along with associated documentation, will be made available from NCBI GEO.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Viral gene expression is highly variable: Even under controlled conditions (single virion input, uniform infection timing), individual infected cells show enormous variation in the fraction of viral RNA.
  • Host response is not uniform: Instead of a single, standard antiviral response, infected cells mount a diverse array of transcriptional responses.
  • NS segment expression is unique: The NS gene segment's expression often diverges from the rest of the viral genome in a subset of infected cells, suggesting a distinct regulatory role.
  • NS divergence is a key driver of antiviral response: This unique NS expression pattern appears to be a major determinant of how strongly the host activates its antiviral defenses, especially for H3N2.
  • H1N1 and H3N2 differ in host interaction: The two strains exhibit distinct patterns of host antiviral gene heterogeneity at the single-cell level.

Key Results

  • The study generated high-quality transcriptomic data from thousands of single virion-infected cells, bystander cells, and mock-infected controls.
  • They identified multiple distinct host transcriptional response groups to IAV infection, indicating significant heterogeneity.
  • Viral gene expression distributions were highly over-dispersed, with viral gene expression being substantially noisier than host gene expression.
  • The expression of the NS viral gene segment showed a unique pattern of divergence from other viral genes in a subset of infected cells.
  • This NS segment expression heterogeneity was found to be a major determinant of antiviral gene activation, particularly for the H3N2 strain.
  • H1N1 (Cal07) and H3N2 (Perth09) strains showed significant differences in their single-cell antiviral gene transcription patterns, with Perth09 exhibiting a stronger link between NS expression and IFN/ISG activation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental artifact potential: The researchers acknowledge that enriching for infected cells by sorting based on surface protein expression might have biased the results, potentially underrepresenting cells that couldn't synthesize these proteins.
  • Timing of analysis: The analysis was performed at 16 hours post-infection (hpi), which might have missed transient early expression of viral genes.
  • In vivo relevance: The study was conducted in vitro using A549 cells. The authors suggest that in vivo heterogeneity might be even greater due to factors like defective interfering particles (DIPs) and variable cellular MOI, which were controlled for in this study.
  • Mechanism of NS divergence: The study identifies the unique expression pattern of the NS segment but does not fully elucidate the underlying mechanism. Future work will aim to understand this.
  • Broader implications: The findings raise questions about how selection acts on viral heterogeneity and how these patterns are controlled by viral genetics, which are important areas for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Viral infection outcomes are governed by the complex and dynamic interplay between the infecting virus population and the host response. It is increasingly clear that both viral and host cell populations are highly heterogeneous, but little is known about how this heterogeneity influences infection dynamics or viral pathogenicity. To dissect the interactions between influenza A virus (IAV) and host cell heterogeneity, we examined the combined host and viral transcriptomes of thousands of individual, single virion-infected cells. We observed complex patterns of viral gene expression and the existence of multiple distinct host transcriptional responses to infection at the single cell level. Our analyses reveal that viral NS segment gene expression diverges from that of the rest of the viral genome within a subset of infected cells, and that this unique pattern of NS segment expression can play a dominant role in shaping the host cell response to infection. Finally, we show that seasonal human H1N1 and H3N2 strains differ significantly in patterns of host anti-viral gene transcriptional heterogeneity at the single cell level. Altogether, these data reveal a common pattern of viral gene expression heterogeneity across human IAV subtypes that can serve as a major determinant of antiviral gene activation.
BibTeX
@misc{vera2019common,
  author = {J. Cristobal Vera and Jiayi Sun and Yen Ting Lin and Jenny Drnevich and Ruian Ke and Christopher B. Brooke},
  title = {{A common pattern of influenza A virus single cell gene expression heterogeneity governs the innate antiviral response to infection}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/858373},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure