A Combination of Conventional Transconjunctival Lower Blepharoplasty and Percutaneous Nanofat Grafting in a Young Chinese Population With Eyelid Bags and Tear Trough Deformities

Chuanbo Liu, Zhiyuan Wu, Liang Tang, Zijing Zhang, Jinsheng Li, Xiaofang SunJournal of Cosmetic Dermatology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, minimally invasive surgical technique combining transconjunctival lower blepharoplasty with percutaneous nanofat grafting to address common lower eyelid aesthetic concerns like bags and tear troughs. The study demonstrates high patient satisfaction and significant aesthetic improvements, suggesting this combined approach is a safe and effective alternative for younger populations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lower eyelid bags and tear trough deformities are common aesthetic concerns that contribute to a tired and aged appearance. While traditional lower blepharoplasty techniques exist, they often focus on fat removal or repositioning, which may not fully address the volume loss in the tear trough area or can sometimes lead to uneven contours. The authors identified a need for a simpler, less invasive procedure that could simultaneously address both the excess fat contributing to bags and the hollowness of the tear trough, particularly in a younger demographic where these issues might be congenital or appear earlier due to genetics rather than significant aging. This study aims to evaluate a combined approach that utilizes the patient's own resected orbital fat, processed into "nanofat," to fill the tear trough, thereby creating a smoother, more youthful contour.

Methods

The study employed a retrospective design, analyzing data from 183 consecutive patients who underwent a combined surgical procedure between February 2020 and June 2024. The core of the technique involves two main steps:

  1. Transconjunctival Lower Blepharoplasty with Orbital Fat Removal: This part of the procedure is performed from the inside of the eyelid, leaving no external scars. The surgeon accesses and removes excess orbital fat pads that cause the "bags."
  2. Percutaneous Nanofat Grafting: The resected orbital fat is then processed into "nanofat" by mincing and mechanically transferring it between syringes. This creates a fine emulsion of fat cells and stem cells. This nanofat is then injected percutaneously (through the skin) into the tear trough area using a fine needle and blunt cannula. The injection is performed in multiple layers to ensure a natural contour.

The study meticulously documented operative time, fat volume injected, and patient follow-up for at least six months. Aesthetic outcomes were assessed both subjectively (patient satisfaction) and objectively, using a five-factor evaluation system (orbital fat prolapse, tear trough depression, dark circles, orbicularis prominence, and skin elasticity) by two independent observers comparing pre- and post-operative photographs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized patient data collected from the Affiliated Hangzhou First People's Hospital.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Approach: The key innovation is the combination of fat removal (for bags) and fat grafting (for tear troughs) in a single, minimally invasive procedure. This addresses multiple aesthetic concerns simultaneously.
  • Nanofat for Volume and Rejuvenation: Using nanofat, derived from the patient's own orbital fat, offers the dual benefit of filling the tear trough depression and potentially improving skin texture due to the presence of adipose-derived stem cells (ASCs).
  • Minimally Invasive and Efficient: The transconjunctival approach for fat removal and the percutaneous injection for grafting contribute to a procedure with minimal scarring and a relatively short operative time (average 36.1 minutes).
  • Targeted Application for Young Adults: The study specifically focuses on a younger Chinese population, suggesting that these aesthetic concerns can be prevalent even without significant aging, and this technique is well-suited for them.
  • High Patient Satisfaction: The overwhelming majority of patients reported high satisfaction, indicating the procedure effectively meets their aesthetic goals.

Key Results

  • Patient Demographics: 183 patients (mean age 26.9 years, 95% female, 98% Han nationality) were included.
  • Procedure Efficiency: Average surgery time was 36.1 minutes.
  • Fat Grafting Volume: Mean nanofat injected per patient was 1.1 mL.
  • Subjective Outcomes: 96.6% of patients reported satisfaction with the surgical results.
  • Objective Outcomes: Significant improvements were observed in orbital fat prolapse, tear trough depression, and dark circles (all p<0.01). Orbicularis prominence also became more evident (p<0.01). Skin elasticity showed no significant difference (p>0.05).
  • Complications: The study reported a low incidence of minor complications, such as transient bloodshot eyes, chemosis, dry eye symptoms, and increased fine wrinkles. No severe complications like infection, hematoma, or fat embolism were noted.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective Design: This inherently carries flaws, and the study protocol was confirmed post-operatively.
  • Lack of Dynamic Photos: Photos were not taken during facial expressions (e.g., smiling), which could provide a more comprehensive assessment of outcomes.
  • Inconsistent Photography: Some photos were taken with an iPhone under varying lighting conditions and backgrounds, potentially affecting objective assessment.
  • Dark Circle Classification: Dark circles were not classified by type (hyperpigmented, vascular, or mixed), limiting detailed analysis.
  • Non-Controlled Study: The study did not directly compare this combined technique against traditional blepharoplasty or fat repositioning.
  • Unquantified Fat Retention: The exact retention rate of the grafted nanofat was not quantified, although patient satisfaction was high.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Prospective Studies: To provide more persuasive evidence and potentially include dynamic facial expression photos.
  • Case-Control Studies: To directly compare the efficacy of this combined approach with other established techniques.
  • Three-Dimensional Assessment: To precisely measure infraorbital volume changes and objectively evaluate fat retention.
  • Further Research on Nanofat: To clarify the complex factors influencing nanofat retention and its long-term effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our study provided a simple, effective, and safe combination of transconjunctival lower blepharoplasty and percutaneous nanofat grafting for the treatment of lower eyelid bags with high patient satisfaction, quick recovery and low complication rate. Thus, this combined application may be a promising alternative choice for the young Chinese with lower eyelid bags.
BibTeX
@article{liu2025combination,
  author = {Chuanbo Liu and Zhiyuan Wu and Liang Tang and Zijing Zhang and Jinsheng Li and Xiaofang Sun},
  title = {{A Combination of Conventional Transconjunctival Lower Blepharoplasty and Percutaneous Nanofat Grafting in a Young Chinese Population With Eyelid Bags and Tear Trough Deformities}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1111/jocd.70009},
}
Figure