A Closed-Loop Optimization System for Evaluating the Development Effect and Potential of Producers with Water Alternating Gas Flooding

Han Zhang, Chenji Wei, Guangya Zhu, Meng Gao, Jian Yang, Liang Sun, Jiaheng Chen, Zhichao WangProcesses 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel closed-loop optimization system to evaluate the development effectiveness of producers in Water Alternating Gas (WAG) flooding operations, a crucial enhanced oil recovery technique. By coupling the Entropy Weight Method (EWM) with an improved Analytic Hierarchy Process (IAHP), the system objectively quantifies producer contributions and provides tailored adjustment strategies, addressing a significant gap in current evaluation methodologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Water Alternating Gas (WAG) flooding is a well-established enhanced oil recovery (EOR) method that leverages the benefits of both water and gas injection to improve oil extraction. However, evaluating its effectiveness, particularly at the producer level, is complex due to the intricate interplay of geological, engineering, and operational factors. Existing evaluation methods often lack adaptability and objectivity, failing to provide a comprehensive understanding of individual producer contributions and hindering timely, effective development adjustments. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a robust, quantitative system for evaluating producer performance and potential in WAG flooding scenarios.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the development of a coupled evaluation model. The authors first employ the Entropy Weight Method (EWM) to objectively determine the weights of various evaluation indexes based on their data dispersion. This method helps to minimize subjective bias by relying on the inherent information within the data. To incorporate expert knowledge and account for the intrinsic attributes of factors, they then utilize an Improved Analytic Hierarchy Process (IAHP). This IAHP method is enhanced by using data-driven comparisons rather than solely relying on expert opinions, aiming to improve objectivity and reliability.

Finally, these two methods are coupled using a weighted average approach (with a 50/50 weighting) to create a more comprehensive and accurate assessment of producer contribution. This coupled model aims to balance the strengths of both objective data analysis (EWM) and structured expert judgment (IAHP), leading to a more holistic evaluation. The system then classifies producers into different efficiency levels and proposes specific adjustment measures based on these classifications.

Datasets

The study utilizes static and dynamic data from a WAG pilot test area in a low-permeability carbonate reservoir located in the Middle East. The dataset includes information from four horizontal producers, covering parameters such as:

  • Porosity (φ)
  • Permeability (K)
  • Horizontal producer length (L)
  • Average monthly oil production (AMOP)
  • Gas-oil ratio (GOR)
  • Water cut (WCT)
  • Injection-production ratio (VRR)

Data was collected both before and after the implementation of the WAG pilot test, with a focus on data collected six months after the test to mitigate the residual effects of prior gas injection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Producer performance is multi-faceted: The study strongly emphasizes that a producer's development effect is not dictated by a single factor but is a complex interplay of geological, engineering, and development parameters.
  • Objective and subjective methods complement each other: Combining the data-driven EWM with the structured IAHP provides a more balanced and reliable evaluation than either method used in isolation.
  • High GOR is a critical constraint: The research highlights high gas-oil ratio (GOR) as a primary constraint in the studied reservoir, likely due to gas channeling from previous injection practices. This insight is crucial for guiding targeted interventions.
  • Tailored adjustments are key: The system's ability to classify producers into distinct efficiency levels (e.g., High-Efficiency Well, Low-Efficiency Well) allows for the development of specific, economically viable adjustment measures, moving beyond generic solutions.

Key Results

The developed closed-loop optimization system was applied to the pilot test area, yielding the following key results:

  • EWM Analysis: GOR was identified as the most influential index (28.9%), followed by porosity (16.1%), with VRR having the least influence (2.7%).
  • IAHP Analysis: The P-120 producer showed the highest contribution weight (54.3%), indicating the best production effect, while P-119 had the lowest (5.3%).
  • Coupled Model Analysis: The final coupled model assigned the highest contribution weight to P-120 (40.7%) and the lowest to P-119 (11.3%), reinforcing the findings from individual methods and providing a more refined assessment.
  • Classification and Recommendations: Producers were classified into five levels, and specific adjustment measures were proposed. For instance, high-efficiency wells like P-120 are recommended for stable production and real-time monitoring, while low-efficiency wells like P-89 might require targeted plugging or differential gas injection.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Data: The collected field data was partially limited, particularly regarding reservoir pressure and bottom hole flowing pressure, which could introduce errors.
  • Complexity of WAG: The periodicity of WAG is uncertain due to the controlling of gas and stabilizing of oil, and some characteristic indexes for WAG development were not fully incorporated.
  • Pilot Scale: The study was conducted on a pilot test area, limiting the sample size and diversity.

Future work will focus on:

  • Dynamic Database: Continuously updating the dynamic database with real-time data and incorporating more development indexes, potentially using missing value interpolation for gaps.
  • Intelligent Agent Model: Embedding an intelligent agent model to improve the efficiency and speed of the evaluation process.
  • Scale-Up: Expanding the system to a larger scale with more producers and parameters to enrich the data system and facilitate rapid scale development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Water alternating gas (WAG) flooding is a relatively mature technology for enhanced oil recovery (EOR). It combines the advantages of water flooding and gas flooding to maintain reservoir pressure and effectively mitigate the issues of high mobility ratio and fingering, demonstrating preferable application prospects. However, the evaluation of its development effect faces the challenges of complexity and lack of adaptability attributed to the multiple interactions of various factors involved in WAG flooding. Moreover, there are few studies evaluating the development effect of producers. Therefore, the traditional hierarchical analysis process (AHP) is improved in this study to fill the gap in this technological field. This process is combined with the entropy weight method (EWM) to establish a coupled evaluation model. Subsequently, this study classifies the contribution weights of producers and proposes adjustment suggestions for the primary development contradictions. This study finds that the contribution weight of producers to the well group indicates that the development effect of producers is no longer influenced by a single factor, but is determined by the coupling effect of geological, engineering, and development factors. By constructing a coupled model and fully utilizing on-site data to objectively characterize the underground production situation, the development effect of producers can be more accurately reflected. Finally, a closed-loop optimization system for evaluating the development effect and potential of producers with WAG flooding is established, laying a theoretical foundation for dynamic analysis and development adjustment of on-site engineers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025closed,
  author = {Han Zhang and Chenji Wei and Guangya Zhu and Meng Gao and Jian Yang and Liang Sun and Jiaheng Chen and Zhichao Wang},
  title = {{A Closed-Loop Optimization System for Evaluating the Development Effect and Potential of Producers with Water Alternating Gas Flooding}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/pr13092798},
}
Figure