A clinical survey investigating the dental disorders of jennies in China

Wuyan Jiang, Bo Liu, Yipeng Jin, Liang Deng, Qingchao Liao, Jing LiThe Thai Journal of Veterinary Medicine 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Recent clinical studies have documented a high prevalence of dental disorders in donkeys. However, there are few studies about the same topic in China. A cross-sectional study was performed to investigate the prevalence of clinically diagnosed dental disorders of donkeys in China. A total of 101 jennies which had never received any dental care were examined for the presence of dental disorders under small-holder farm conditions. The prevalence of dental disorders was analyzed by Chi‐square test or Fisher's exact correlation test. The strength of association was evaluated using Cramer's V test. Jennies between 2 and 15 years of age were categorized into four age groups. The most common dental disorders were sharp enamel points (100%), incisor diastemata (90.1%) and focal overgrowths (72.3%). Age was moderately related to the presence of ventral convex curvatures, focal overgrowths, wave mouth and canine calculus accumulation (P < 0.05, 0.3 < V < 0.5). Shear mouth (V > 0.5) was significantly associated with age group. Common dental disorders were found in all groups and the prevalence was higher in aged groups. This study indicated that donkeys should receive proper dental care to improve their welfare.

Introduction

China is home to approximately 2.68 million donkeys, a population currently transitioning from traditional draft labor to production roles for meat and milk. Despite their economic importance, donkey welfare is frequently neglected, particularly regarding dental health. Dental disorders in equids are not merely cosmetic; they cause chronic oral pain, reduce feed efficiency, and can lead to life-threatening systemic issues like colic. While dental health has been studied in donkey populations in Europe and Mexico, there has been a significant lack of data regarding the dental status of donkeys in China’s small-holder farming systems. This paper fills that gap by documenting the prevalence of dental disorders and investigating their correlation with age.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study in Liaoning Province, China, examining 101 "Liaoxi" jennies from 10 different villages. The methodology followed standard veterinary dental protocols:

  • Clinical Examination: Animals were restrained in stocks and, in some cases, sedated. A Hausmann speculum was used to keep the mouth open, and the oral cavity was flushed for better visibility.
  • Diagnostic Tools: Veterinarians used dental mirrors, explorers, and periodontal probes to identify pathologies.
  • Standardized Charting: Disorders were recorded using the modified Triadan system.
  • Statistical Analysis: The team used Chi-square and Fisher’s exact tests to analyze prevalence, employing the Cramer’s V test to determine the strength of the association between age and specific dental disorders (where V > 0.5 indicates a high association).

Results

The study found a universal prevalence of dental pathology, with 100% of the subjects exhibiting sharp enamel points (SEPs). Other common findings included incisor diastemata (90.1%) and focal overgrowths (72.3%).

Common dental disorders observed in the study population: (A) Lingual ulcers (blue arrows) and sharp enamel points (black arrows); (B) Food impaction (yellow arrows) within diastemata; (C) Shear mouth, characterized by extreme angulation of the occlusal surface.

Soft tissue damage was a frequent secondary finding, with over half of the donkeys (54.5%) suffering from buccal ulcers directly related to dental overgrowths. Age served as a significant marker for progression; for instance, "shear mouth" (an extreme angulation of the chewing surface) was strongly associated with older donkeys ($P < 0.01$, Cramer’s V $> 0.5$), occurring in 66.7% of the oldest age group (11–15 years) compared to 0% in the youngest.

Discussion

The 100% prevalence of SEPs suggests that without human intervention, the natural wear of a donkey's hypsodont teeth inevitably leads to painful pathology. The authors hypothesize that the high prevalence of incisor diastemata and SEPs may be exacerbated by a local diet of coarse crop residues like corn and millet stalks, which require more intense lateral chewing movements than softer grasses.

A notable "welfare paradox" was observed: many donkeys suffered from significant oral ulcers yet continued to be used for reproduction and production. This points to a lack of awareness among owners regarding sub-clinical pain in livestock. Furthermore, the strong correlation between age and shear mouth indicates that dental misalignments worsen over time, leading to a cumulative degradation of oral health.

Conclusion

This clinical survey highlights a critical welfare gap for donkeys in China. Regular dental care should be integrated into standard production protocols to mitigate chronic pain and improve productivity. Further research is needed to quantify the economic benefits of dental care, such as improvements in milk yield and overall longevity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent clinical studies have documented a high prevalence of dental disorders in donkeys. However, there are few studies about the same topic in China. A cross-sectional study was performed to investigate the prevalence of clinically diagnosed dental disorders of donkeys in China. A total of 101 jennies which had never received any dental care were examined for the presence of dental disorders under small-holder farm conditions. The prevalence of dental disorders was analyzed by Chi‐square test or Fisher's exact correlation test. The strength of association was evaluated using Cramer's V test. Jennies between 2 and 15 years of age were categorized into four age groups. The most common dental disorders were sharp enamel points (100%), incisor diastemata (90.1%) and focal overgrowths (72.3%). Age was moderately related to the presence of ventral convex curvatures, focal overgrowths, wave mouth and canine calculus accumulation (P <0.05, 0.3 0.5) was significantly associated with age group. Common dental disorders were found in all groups and the prevalence was higher in aged groups. This study indicated that donkeys should receive proper dental care to improve their welfare.
BibTeX
@article{jiang2021clinical,
  author = {Wuyan Jiang and Bo Liu and Yipeng Jin and Liang Deng and Qingchao Liao and Jing Li},
  title = {{A clinical survey investigating the dental disorders of jennies in China}},
  journal = {The Thai Journal of Veterinary Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.56808/2985-1130.3097},
}
Figure