A Clinical Randomized Controlled Study of Low-Frequency rTMS Therapy on Lower Limb Motor Dysfunction after Stroke

Kaiqi Huang, Xizhen Jie, Xiaoyan Li, Zhaoming LiangJournal of Clinical and Nursing Research 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This clinical study demonstrates that low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) applied to the "healthy" side of the brain significantly improves lower limb motor function and balance in stroke survivors. By using 1Hz inhibitory stimulation to rebalance interhemispheric activity, researchers achieved measurable improvements in gait symmetry and muscle activation beyond what conventional rehabilitation offers alone.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stroke remains a leading cause of long-term disability, with over 80% of survivors experiencing impaired lower limb function. This leads to poor gait stability, increased energy expenditure during walking, and a higher risk of falls.

While rTMS—a non-invasive method of modulating cortical excitability—has been widely studied for upper limb recovery, its application to the lower limbs is less common. This is partly due to the anatomical challenge: the motor area for the lower limbs is located deep within the longitudinal fissure of the brain, making it harder to target than the upper limb areas. The authors sought to provide robust clinical evidence for the efficacy and safety of using low-frequency rTMS as an adjunctive therapy for post-stroke lower limb rehabilitation.

Methods

The researchers conducted a single-blind, randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 96 patients (divided equally into experimental and sham groups).

  • The Intervention: The experimental group received 1Hz rTMS (an inhibitory frequency) targeting the primary motor area (M1) of the unaffected (healthy) hemisphere. The logic here is based on the "interhemispheric inhibition" model: after a stroke, the healthy hemisphere often becomes overactive and further suppresses the damaged side. Inhibiting the healthy side can "release" the damaged side to facilitate recovery.
  • The Sham: The sham group used the same equipment, but the stimulation coil was placed perpendicular to the skull, preventing the magnetic field from effectively penetrating the brain.
  • Treatment Protocol: Both groups received conventional rehab. The rTMS was administered in 10 sessions (20 minutes each, 1000 pulses at 90% motor threshold) over four weeks.
  • Evaluation: The study went beyond simple clinical scales, employing three-dimensional gait analysis (using infrared motion capture) and surface electromyography (EMG) to measure the electrical activity of the tibialis anterior (TA) and rectus femoris (RF) muscles during walking.

Datasets

The "dataset" consists of clinical and kinematic data from 96 stroke patients treated at the Affiliated Hospital of Guangdong Medical University between 2019 and 2022.

  • Inclusion Criteria: Patients aged 18–80, 3 months to 1 year post-stroke, experiencing their first stroke with unilateral hemiparesis, and capable of walking (with or without aids).
  • Benchmarks: The study utilized standard clinical benchmarks including the Fugl-Meyer Assessment for Lower Extremities (FMA-LE) and the Berg Balance Scale (BBS).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rebalancing the Hemispheres: The study reinforces the "less is more" approach in neurorehabilitation. By inhibiting the healthy side of the brain, they successfully promoted functional recovery on the paretic side.
  • Objective Kinematic Gains: One of the most interesting findings was the improvement in gait symmetry. Post-stroke walking is often characterized by an asymmetrical "hitch." The rTMS group showed a significant reduction in the symmetrical ratio of step length and support time, moving closer to a natural, balanced gait.
  • Muscle-Specific Activation: EMG data revealed that rTMS specifically improved the activation of the tibialis anterior during the swing phase and the rectus femoris during the stance phase. This suggests that the brain stimulation is helping the motor cortex better coordinate the specific timing of muscle firing required for a fluid stride.

Key Results

The experimental group outperformed the sham group across all primary metrics ($P < 0.05$):

  • Motor Scores: FMA-LE scores in the rTMS group jumped from 18.27 to 25.8, compared to a much smaller increase in the sham group (20.67 to 22.67).
  • Balance: Berg Balance Scale (BBS) scores improved significantly more in the rTMS group (reaching 45.80 vs. 42.67 in the sham group).
  • Gait Parameters: Significant increases were seen in "pacemaker" (step length/speed), pace, and step frequency.
  • Safety: Zero adverse reactions (headaches, seizures, or skin irritation) were reported, confirming the 1Hz protocol's safety profile.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify several areas for improvement:

  • Coil Focus: The study used a circular coil, which produces a relatively broad magnetic field. Future studies might use "figure-eight" coils for more focal stimulation of the deep lower-limb motor areas.
  • Sample Size and Duration: While 96 patients is a solid cohort, larger multi-center trials and longer follow-up periods are needed to see if these gains persist over years.
  • Mechanistic Depth: The study relies on external observations (EMG and gait). The authors suggest that future research should incorporate functional imaging (like fMRI or PET) to visualize exactly how cortical excitability and connectivity change in response to the treatment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective: To investigate the efficacy and safety of low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) for the treatment of lower limb motor dysfunction after stroke. Methods: A total of 96 patients with stroke and lower limb motor dysfunction were enrolled in this study, and were randomly divided into the experimental group and the sham stimulation group using the method of calculator-generated random numbers. Both groups received conventional medication and rehabilitation therapy. The experimental group received 4 weeks of 1 Hz rTMS treatment in the primary cortical motor area (M1) of the healthy side, with the treatment coil tangent to the skull surface; the sham stimulation group underwent the same procedures as the experimental group, but the treatment coil was perpendicular to the skull surface instead. Lower-extremity subscale of the Fugl-Meyer Assessment (FMA-LE), Berg Balance Scale (BBS), gait analysis, and lower-extremity surface electromyography (LESEM) were performed in both groups before and after rTMS treatment. Results: All 96 patients completed the test with no shedding and no adverse reactions. After treatment, the FMA-LE score and BBS score of the 2 groups of patients were significantly improved as compared with the pre-treatment (P &lt; 0.05), and the TUG test time was reduced as compared with the pre-treatment (P &lt; 0.05). The true stimulation group had greater improvement in all assessment indexes than that of the sham stimulation group (P &lt; 0.05). After treatment, the electromyographic activity of the tibialis anterior and rectus femoris muscles in the true simulation group improved significantly. The step length, step speed, and step frequency were also significantly improved in both groups after treatment, and the symmetrical ratio of step length and support time was reduced (P &lt; 0.05). Comparison between the groups revealed that the true simulation group significantly improved after rTMS treatment as compared to the sham stimulation group (P &lt; 0.05). Conclusion: 1Hz rTMS treatment safely and effectively improved motor and balance function in patients with post-stroke lower limb motor dysfunction.
BibTeX
@article{huang2024clinical,
  author = {Kaiqi Huang and Xizhen Jie and Xiaoyan Li and Zhaoming Liang},
  title = {{A Clinical Randomized Controlled Study of Low-Frequency rTMS Therapy on Lower Limb Motor Dysfunction after Stroke}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical and Nursing Research},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.26689/jcnr.v8i2.5899},
}
Figure