A Classification Method for Fish Swimming Behaviors under Incremental Water Velocity for Fishway Hydraulic Design

Xiangpeng Mu, Ping Cao, Li Gong, Baiyin Baoligao, Li XiangWater 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the swimming behaviors of juvenile grass carp under increasing water velocities to inform fishway design. By classifying behaviors into four distinct types and dividing the process into four stages, the researchers provide crucial velocity thresholds for different fishway components, aiming to improve fish passage efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fish migration is essential for many aquatic species, but human-made hydraulic structures like dams often block these routes. Fishways are designed to facilitate passage, but their effectiveness hinges on matching hydraulic conditions to fish swimming capabilities. While critical and burst swimming speeds are known indicators, there's a need for a more nuanced understanding of how fish behave under changing water velocities within a fishway. This is particularly important for juvenile fish, which have weaker swimming abilities and are often overlooked in existing research, and for species like the "four major Chinese carps" that are economically significant but face population declines due to blocked migration. This paper aims to bridge this gap by classifying fish swimming behaviors and relating them to specific water velocities relevant for fishway design.

Methods

The researchers employed a homemade, closed-loop recirculating water tank with a controlled incremental water velocity system. Juvenile grass carp were subjected to gradually increasing water speeds using an "incremental water velocity method." This method involved pre-tests to estimate critical and burst swimming speeds, followed by formal tests where water velocity was increased in defined increments over specific time intervals until the fish exhibited fatigue.

To analyze fish behavior, video recordings were meticulously reviewed frame-by-frame. Fish swimming actions were tracked, and based on observations of sustained swimming, pausing, and dashing, four distinct swimming behaviors were classified:

  • Swimming freely: Fish move with the flow or against it without apparent stress.
  • Staying: Fish maintain position against the current.
  • Dashing at a long distance: Fish make significant forward movements (3-5 body lengths) before retreating.
  • Dashing at a short distance: Fish make brief forward movements (less than 1 body length) before retreating.

The entire swimming process under incremental velocity was further divided into four distinct stages, reflecting the fish's adaptation and stress response to increasing water flow. Linear regression was used to establish relationships between body length and swimming speeds.

Datasets

The study utilized juvenile grass carp ( Ctenopharyngodon idellus) collected from a fishery in Beijing. A total of 57 individuals were used, with body lengths ranging from 5.70 to 15.00 cm. The fish were divided into groups for critical and burst swimming speed tests. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation; the study generated its own experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Body Length Matters: Both absolute critical and burst swimming speeds increase linearly with fish body length, while relative speeds (normalized by body length) decrease. This highlights the importance of considering the size of the target species in fishway design.
  • Predictive Relationship: A quantitative relationship was established between absolute critical and burst swimming speeds, allowing for the derivation of one from the other. This could streamline fishway design by reducing the need for extensive testing of both parameters.
  • Behavioral Stages of Stress: Fish don't just swim faster; their behavior changes predictably as water velocity increases. The four identified stages (swimming freely, staying, dashing at a long distance, dashing at a short distance) provide a framework for understanding fish responses to flow stress.
  • Velocity Thresholds for Design: The study proposes specific maximum water velocity recommendations for different fishway components based on these behavioral stages. This is a direct translation of experimental findings into practical engineering guidelines.

Key Results

  • Swimming Speed Trends:
    • Absolute critical swimming speed ($U_{crit}$) = 3.960 * Body Length (BL) + 47.494 (cm/s)
    • Relative critical swimming speed ($U'_{crit}$) = -0.573 * BL + 14.709 (BL/s)
    • Absolute burst swimming speed ($U_{burst}$) = 6.637 * BL + 37.572 (cm/s)
    • Relative burst swimming speed ($U'_{burst}$) = -0.430 * BL + 14.908 (BL/s)
  • Behavioral Stages and Velocity Recommendations:
    • Stage 1 (Initial Adaptation): Max swimming speed ~52-60% of $U_{burst}$. Mainstream velocity should not exceed this range.
  • Stage 2 (Stress Emerges): Max swimming speed ~76-79% of $U_{burst}$. High-velocity areas (slots, orifices) should ideally stay below this.
  • Stage 3 (Dashing Behavior): Max swimming speed ~90-96% of $U_{burst}$. High-velocity areas should absolutely not exceed this.
  • Stage 4 (Near Exhaustion): Max swimming speed ~100% of $U_{burst}$.
  • Behavioral Distribution: At Stage 1, fish spent roughly equal time staying, dashing long distances, and dashing short distances. As velocity increased, "staying" became more dominant in Stage 2, followed by increased dashing in Stage 3, and a more uniform distribution of behaviors near exhaustion in Stage 4.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that the tests were conducted in a controlled, indoor, closed water tank. Future work should explore fish swimming behaviors in open water tank fishways to better understand upstream migration dynamics and their relationship with hydrodynamic conditions. The authors also suggest that this classification method could be applied to other fish species to further understand their swimming abilities and inform fishway design more broadly. The study focused on juvenile grass carp, and further research on adult fish and other species would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

In fishway design, the combination of fish swimming behaviors and suitable fishway hydraulic characteristics increases the fish passage efficiency. In this study, the most representative grass carp among the “four major Chinese carps” was selected. Under conditions similar to the time period for feeding migration, juvenile grass carps were targeted to study the swimming characteristic indicators (i.e., critical and burst swimming speeds) and swimming behaviors that were closely associated with fishway hydraulic design using the incremental water velocity method in a homemade test water tank. (1) The study results reveal that both the absolute critical (Ucrit) and burst (Uburst) swimming speeds increased linearly with increasing body length and both the relative critical (U’crit) and burst (U’burst) swimming speeds decreased linearly with increasing body length. There existed a quantitative relationship between Uburst and Ucrit, which could facilitate the fishway hydraulic design. (2) This study analyzed the effects of water velocity changes on fish swimming behaviors and proposed a classification method for four fish swimming behaviors—swimming freely, staying, dashing at a long distance, and dashing at a short distance—of tested fish during the process of adapting to water velocity changes interspersed with one another. The entire swimming process under the incremental water velocity was divided into four stages. (3) This study suggests that the maximum water velocity of the mainstream in a fishway using grass carp as the major passage fish should not exceed 52–60% Uburst at stage 1. For the high-water velocity areas of a fishway, such as vertical slots and orifices, the optimal water velocity should not be higher than 76–79% Uburst at stage 2 and should absolutely not exceed 90–96% Uburst at stage 3.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mu2019classification,
  author = {Xiangpeng Mu and Ping Cao and Li Gong and Baiyin Baoligao and Li Xiang},
  title = {{A Classification Method for Fish Swimming Behaviors under Incremental Water Velocity for Fishway Hydraulic Design}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/w11102131},
}
Figure