A chromosome-level phased genome enabling allele-level studies in sweet orange: a case study on citrus Huanglongbing tolerance

Bo Wu, Qibin Yu, Zhanao Deng, Yongping Duan, Feng Luo, Frederick G. GmitterHorticulture 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a high-quality, chromosome-level phased genome for Valencia sweet orange (DVS). This new resource enables detailed, allele-level studies of gene expression and mutations, revealing how different gene variants contribute to traits like citrus Huanglongbing (HLB) tolerance. This work is crucial for understanding and improving citrus genetics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sweet orange is a complex hybrid of pummelo and mandarin, resulting in a highly heterozygous genome. Understanding how the different versions (alleles) of genes from these parent species interact to influence sweet orange's traits, especially under stress, has been challenging. Previous genome assemblies were often incomplete or not phased, making it difficult to distinguish between alleles and study their individual contributions. This lack of a high-resolution, allele-aware reference genome hindered research into complex traits like disease tolerance, particularly for devastating diseases like citrus Huanglongbing (HLB).

Methods

The core of this work is the assembly of a chromosome-level phased diploid Valencia sweet orange (DVS) genome. This was achieved using PacBio long-read sequencing and a modified assembly pipeline that accounts for the high allelic variance in sweet orange. They also developed an allele-aware transcriptomic profiling pipeline to analyze gene expression at the individual allele level. This pipeline was applied to a large dataset of sweet orange transcriptomes. Additionally, they used long-read sequencing to detect allelic structural mutations in HLB-tolerant and sensitive sweet orange mutants.

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • PacBio long-read sequencing data from a diploid Valencia sweet orange (DVS).
  • 740 sweet orange transcriptomes from various studies (NCBI BioProjects) for allele-aware expression analysis.
  • Long-read sequencing data from two HLB-tolerant/sensitive sweet orange mutants (T19 and T78).
  • Publicly available citrus genome data (pummelo, mandarin, other sweet orange cultivars) for comparative analyses and phylogenetic inference.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The sweet orange genome is a mosaic: The DVS genome clearly shows distinct regions originating from pummelo and mandarin, highlighting the hybrid nature of the species.
  • Allelic expression is common and dynamic: A significant portion of genes in sweet orange show biased expression of one allele over the other, and these patterns are highly influenced by tissue type, developmental stage, and environmental factors like HLB infection.
  • HLB profoundly impacts allele expression: Citrus Huanglongbing significantly alters the expression of hundreds of genes, suggesting a complex molecular response to the disease.
  • Structural mutations can directly drive allele-specific expression changes: In the HLB-tolerant mutant (T19), specific structural mutations (like translocations) were found to directly upregulate certain genes, contributing to its tolerance.
  • Heat shock proteins (HSPs) are key to HLB tolerance: The HLB-tolerant mutant T19 shows a significant upregulation of HSPs, which are hypothesized to maintain protein homeostasis under stress, a crucial mechanism for survival.

Key Results

  • High-quality phased genome: The DVS genome assembly achieved over 99.999% base accuracy and 99.2% gene annotation completeness, with chromosome-level phasing.
  • Widespread allelic bias: On average, 32.5% of genes in sweet orange transcriptomes exhibit significantly biased allelic expression.
  • HLB-induced changes: HLB infection altered the allelic expression of hundreds of genes in leaves and calyx abscission zones.
  • Structural mutations identified: Allelic structural mutations were detected in HLB-tolerant (T19) and sensitive (T78) mutants, with irradiation-induced mutations often involving double-strand breaks and spontaneous mutations being transposon insertions.
  • Direct link between mutations and expression: In mutants, genes with significant allelic expression changes were often directly affected by these structural mutations.
  • T19's tolerance mechanism: Upregulation of specific HSP-related genes (CsDnaJ, CsHSP17.4B, CsCEBPZ) in T19, linked to a translocated segment, is proposed to maintain phloem protein homeostasis under HLB stress.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Completeness of AEP understanding: The authors acknowledge that their study, while revealing many allele-specific expression patterns (AEPs), is "still far from the full scenery in sweet orange."
  • Further investigation of SVs: While they identified and verified several structural variants (SVs), further work could explore the functional impact of all identified SVs.
  • Broader application of DVS: The DVS genome is presented as a foundational tool for future research in citrus, implying that its full potential for understanding various traits and breeding applications is yet to be realized.
  • Mechanisms of spontaneous SVs: While transposon insertions were identified as a source of spontaneous SVs, further research could delve deeper into the specific mechanisms driving their activity in citrus.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sweet orange originated from the introgressive hybridizations of pummelo and mandarin resulting in a highly heterozygous genome. How alleles from the two species cooperate in shaping sweet orange phenotypes under distinct circumstances is unknown. Here, we assembled a chromosome-level phased diploid Valencia sweet orange (DVS) genome with over 99.999% base accuracy and 99.2% gene annotation BUSCO completeness. DVS enables allele-level studies for sweet orange and other hybrids between pummelo and mandarin. We first configured an allele-aware transcriptomic profiling pipeline and applied it to 740 sweet orange transcriptomes. On average, 32.5% of genes have a significantly biased allelic expression in the transcriptomes. Different cultivars, transgenic lineages, tissues, development stages, and disease status all impacted allelic expressions and resulted in diversified allelic expression patterns in sweet orange, but particularly citrus Huanglongbing (HLB) shifted the allelic expression of hundreds of genes in leaves and calyx abscission zones. In addition, we detected allelic structural mutations in an HLB-tolerant mutant (T19) and a more sensitive mutant (T78) through long-read sequencing. The irradiation-induced structural mutations mostly involved double-strand breaks, while most spontaneous structural mutations were transposon insertions. In the mutants, most genes with significant allelic expression ratio alterations (≥1.5-fold) were directly affected by those structural mutations. In T19, alleles located at a translocated segment terminal were upregulated, including <i>CsDnaJ</i>, <i>CsHSP17.4B</i>, and <i>CsCEBPZ</i>. Their upregulation is inferred to keep phloem protein homeostasis under the stress from HLB and enable subsequent stress responses observed in T19. DVS will advance allelic level studies in citrus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2022chromosome,
  author = {Bo Wu and Qibin Yu and Zhanao Deng and Yongping Duan and Feng Luo and Frederick G. Gmitter},
  title = {{A chromosome-level phased genome enabling allele-level studies in sweet orange: a case study on citrus Huanglongbing tolerance}},
  booktitle = {Horticulture},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1093/hr/uhac247},
}
Figure