A Chattering-Suppression Sliding Mode Controller for an Underwater Manipulator Using Time Delay Estimation

Minghao Liu, Qirong Tang, Yinghao Li, Changhui Liu, Min YuJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "chattering-suppression sliding mode controller" for underwater manipulators that doesn't require a precise mathematical model of the system. By combining time-delay estimation with a specially designed reaching law, the controller achieves robust and accurate trajectory tracking even in the presence of uncertain water disturbances, a common challenge for underwater robots.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Underwater manipulators are crucial for tasks like pipeline repair and scientific sampling. However, controlling them precisely is incredibly difficult. This is because their dynamics are heavily influenced by complex factors like water currents, waves, and the movement of the vehicle they're attached to. Creating an accurate mathematical model of these systems is a significant challenge, making traditional control methods struggle. Existing solutions often require detailed models or suffer from "chattering" – rapid oscillations in the control signal that can damage the manipulator. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a high-precision control solution that bypasses the need for exact modeling and actively suppresses chattering.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is a Time Delay Estimation (TDE) combined with a Sliding Mode Control (SMC) strategy, specifically a Novel Reaching Law Sliding Mode Controller (NRLSMC).

  • Time Delay Estimation (TDE): Instead of relying on a perfect model, TDE estimates the unknown system dynamics (including external disturbances) by using intentionally time-delayed control inputs and system states. This allows the controller to "learn" and compensate for uncertainties without explicit modeling.
  • Sliding Mode Control (SMC): SMC is known for its robustness to disturbances and ease of implementation. However, it typically suffers from chattering.
  • Novel Reaching Law (NRL): To combat chattering, the authors introduce a new reaching law that uses a combination of a special "fin" function (which smooths the control near the origin) and a hyperbolic tangent function. This design aims to reduce the time it takes for the system to reach the desired sliding surface while simultaneously minimizing oscillations.

The controller integrates these components to estimate system states, compensate for disturbances, and drive the manipulator's joints to follow desired trajectories accurately and smoothly.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a custom-built 2-DOF underwater manipulator and its experimental validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Model-Free Control is Feasible for Underwater Manipulators: The paper demonstrates that high-precision control of complex underwater systems is achievable without a precise mathematical model, which is a significant practical advantage.
  • TDE as a Powerful Tool for Uncertainty Compensation: Time-delay estimation proves to be an effective way to handle the inherent uncertainties in underwater environments, making the controller adaptable.
  • Chattering Suppression is Crucial for Practicality: The novel reaching law effectively addresses the chattering problem, which is critical for the longevity and safe operation of underwater manipulators.
  • Integrated Approach Outperforms Individual Techniques: The combination of TDE and NRLSMC yields superior results compared to controllers that use only SMC, NRLSMC, or TDE-SMC, especially in the presence of disturbances.

Key Results

The paper presents both simulation and experimental results:

  • Simulations:
    • In a disturbance-free environment, the proposed TDE-NRLSMC controller produced smooth control inputs, unlike the oscillating inputs of the TDE-SMC.
  • In a wave environment with model uncertainties, TDE-NRLSMC achieved significantly lower Root Mean Square Errors (RMSEs) for both joints compared to SMC, NRLSMC, and TDE-SMC. For Joint 1, the RMSE was 0.299 rad (vs. 0.6934 for SMC), and for Joint 2, it was 0.3795 rad (vs. 0.8681 for SMC).
  • Experiments:
    • The experimental results on a self-developed 2-DOF underwater manipulator in a wave pool confirmed the simulation findings.
  • TDE-NRLSMC demonstrated the lowest average RMSE across both joints (0.3393 rad), showing a reduction of 57% compared to SMC, 25% compared to NRLSMC, and 8% compared to TDE-SMC.
  • The controller effectively tracked desired trajectories within 1 second in the wave environment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that while the controller is robust, the standalone capability of a single underwater manipulator is inherently limited due to the complex nature of underwater tasks.
  • The experimental setup involved tethering the vehicle to immobilize it, which simplifies the problem by removing the vehicle's own dynamics from the manipulator's control challenge.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest developing collaborative control strategies for multiple manipulators to address the limitations of individual manipulator capabilities. This would involve coordinating several manipulators to tackle more complex tasks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Underwater manipulators are pivotal in diverse applications, encompassing underwater pipeline repairs, salvage operations, and scientific sampling missions. However, attaining high-precision control mandates the establishment of precise mathematical models. Specifically, developing an accurate dynamic model for the underwater manipulator affixed to underwater robots proves exceptionally demanding, primarily attributed to the uncertainties arising from water currents and the perturbations induced by the vehicle’s motion. This paper presents a novel sliding mode controller with time delay estimation for the high-precision control of an underwater manipulator mounted on an underwater vehicle. The presented controller circumvents the requirement for an exact mathematical model of the underwater manipulator, enhancing its control precision even without detailed modeling information. Moreover, the proposed controller guarantees robustness against uncertain water flow disturbances, effectively preserving the performance of the underwater manipulator under challenging underwater conditions. The proposed controller comprises two key elements. Firstly, a time delay estimator is employed to estimate the system states using feedback from intentional time-delayed control inputs and a pre-designed matrix. Additionally, a specially designed reaching law is incorporated to reduce reaching time and prevent chattering in the sliding mode control. The controller offers several advantages, including easy implementation, insensitivity to model uncertainties, and robustness in the underwater environment. Simulations and experiments demonstrate the ability of the proposed controller to effectively mitigate disturbances, eliminate chattering, and ensure precise trajectory-tracking performance. The experiments are conducted on a fully self-developed 2-degree-of-freedom (2-DOF) underwater manipulator, showcasing the superiority of the proposed controller over other alternatives.
BibTeX
@article{liu2023chattering,
  author = {Minghao Liu and Qirong Tang and Yinghao Li and Changhui Liu and Min Yu},
  title = {{A Chattering-Suppression Sliding Mode Controller for an Underwater Manipulator Using Time Delay Estimation}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11091742},
}
Figure