A Characterization of n-Player Strongly Monotone Scheduling Mechanisms

Annamária Kovács, Angelina VidaliIJCAI 2015

Abstract

This paper provides a complete mathematical characterization of truthful (incentive-compatible) mechanisms for scheduling $n$ players with two tasks. The authors discover a brand-new class of mechanisms called "player-grouping minimizers," which generalizes the well-known affine minimizers and helps bridge the gap in our understanding of multi-parameter mechanism design.

Introduction

In the field of algorithmic mechanism design, the "unrelated machine scheduling" problem is a fundamental challenge. With $n$ machines (players) and $m$ tasks, where each player has a private cost for each task, the goal is to design a mechanism that incentivizes players to report their true costs. While single-parameter problems are well-understood, multi-parameter problems—where players have different costs for different tasks—remain notoriously difficult to characterize. This paper addresses the specific case of $n$ players and 2 tasks, seeking to define the space of truthful mechanisms.

Geometric Characterization and Methods

The authors employ a geometric approach, analyzing the "bid-space" where each point represents reported costs. They focus on mechanisms satisfying Strong Monotonicity (SMON), alongside assumptions of decisiveness (all possible allocations are achievable) and continuity of payments.

A central part of their analysis involves examining the boundaries where task allocations change. They demonstrate that if a boundary depends on multiple variables in an additively separable manner (e.g., $f(x) + g(y)$), the underlying geometry of truthful mechanisms necessitates that these functions be linear. This linearity is a key technical bridge to deriving the functional form of the entire mechanism.

Geometric boundaries between allocations illustrating additive separability.

Player-Grouping Minimizers and Key Results

The primary contribution is the discovery of "player-grouping minimizers." This new class generalizes affine minimizers by allowing players to be partitioned into groups. Within groups, affine minimization is used; between groups, non-linear but strictly increasing functions determine which group "wins" the tasks.

The paper proves a "binary choice" for two-task mechanisms: they must be either task-independent (treating each task as a separate auction) or follow the player-grouping minimizer structure. There is no "middle ground" for continuous, decisive SMON mechanisms.

Comparison of allocation boundaries: (a) and (c) show grouping minimizers, while (b) represents a task-independent mechanism.

Theorem 1 provides the complete characterization for $n$ players and 2 tasks, generalizing previous results that were limited to the 2-player case. This offers a global, closed-form description of these mechanisms, a significant step forward from the "local" descriptions usually provided by monotonicity.

Limitations and Future Work

The current characterization is strictly restricted to $m=2$ tasks and relies on the SMON property. While the authors conjecture that the results extend to $m > 2$, suggesting they are products of grouping minimizers and task-independent parts, the proof for higher dimensions remains an open problem. Additionally, extending these findings to mechanisms that only satisfy Weak Monotonicity (WMON) or lack the decisiveness assumption represents a major hurdle for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kovacs2015characterization,
  author = {Annamária Kovács and Angelina Vidali},
  title = {{A Characterization of n-Player Strongly Monotone Scheduling Mechanisms}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2015},
}
Figure