A chamber and artificial dura method for long-term optical imaging in the monkey

Li Min Chen, Barbara Heider, Graham V. Williams, Francine L. Healy, Benjamin M. Ramsden, Anna Wang RoeJournal of Neuroscience Methods 2002 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, non-metallic implantable chamber and artificial dura system for long-term optical imaging in non-human primates. This method allows for repeated, infection-free imaging sessions over several months, overcoming challenges posed by dura regrowth and cortical damage, and enabling more robust studies of brain function.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optical imaging is a powerful technique for mapping brain activity at a fine scale. However, applying this to non-human primates for extended periods presents significant hurdles. To expose the cortex for imaging, the dura mater (a protective membrane) must be removed. This removal, coupled with the brain's natural healing response, leads to the regrowth of dural tissue and a "neo-membrane" that obscures the cortex, degrades signal quality, and increases the risk of infection and mechanical injury. Existing methods often require frequent maintenance, can be invasive, and may not be suitable for long-term studies, especially in awake, behaving animals. This paper aims to provide a practical, low-maintenance solution for chronic optical imaging in primates.

Methods

The core innovation is a two-part implant system:

  • Nylon Imaging Chamber: Constructed from FDA-approved, hardened nylon, this lightweight and MRI-compatible cylinder is inserted into a cranial trephination. It features a threaded interior for a cap and flexible flanges at the base to secure it within the skull.
  • Artificial Dura "Hat": Made from a transparent, soft thermoplastic polyurethane (Tecoflex®), this component is shaped like a hat. Its flat base sits on the cortex to prevent adhesions, while its circular wall fits snugly against the chamber's inner diameter, acting as a barrier against dural regrowth into the chamber.

Implantation involves a precise craniotomy, dural resection, placement of the artificial dura, and insertion of the nylon cylinder, sealed with a minimal amount of acrylic cement. For imaging, the chamber is filled with agar or silicone to stabilize the cortex, or sometimes imaged directly through the artificial dura.

A key methodological contribution is an image alignment program that uses blood vessel landmarks to create a 2D spatial transformation between images from different sessions, allowing for precise comparison of functional maps over time, even with variations in magnification or minor distortions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses data from three non-human primates (Macaca fascicularis) undergoing the described imaging procedure.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-metallic implant advantage: The use of nylon and polyurethane offers significant benefits, including reduced weight, MRI compatibility, and a lower risk of tissue irritation compared to traditional metal chambers.
  • Artificial dura's dual role: The "hat" design effectively prevents dural ingrowth into the chamber while also serving as a protective layer for the exposed cortex.
  • Neo-membrane management: While neo-membrane growth is unavoidable, it can be managed by periodic, careful resection. The artificial dura can be easily removed and replaced, facilitating this maintenance.
  • Long-term stability: The method allows for repeatable functional mapping (ocular dominance and orientation maps) over extended periods (up to 6 months observed), demonstrating the viability of the approach for chronic studies.
  • Image alignment is crucial: The development of a robust image alignment algorithm is essential for comparing functional data acquired at different time points, enabling longitudinal studies of brain plasticity and function.

Key Results

  • The chamber and artificial dura implant remained infection-free for up to 4-6 months in the studied animals with minimal maintenance.
  • Optical imaging sessions could be performed repeatedly, with functional maps (ocular dominance and orientation) showing consistent structure over a period of 60 days.
  • The developed image alignment program successfully transformed maps from different sessions, showing good correspondence of functional domains.
  • Histological evaluation after 4 months showed healthy cortical tissue in one hemisphere, though some degeneration was observed in the other, potentially due to initial surgical damage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Neo-membrane growth: While manageable, neo-membrane growth over the cortex is not entirely prevented and can eventually degrade signal quality. The authors suggest that a larger base for the artificial dura might help mitigate this.
  • Potential for cortical damage: Initial surgical trauma or aggressive neo-membrane removal could lead to cortical degeneration, as observed in one hemisphere. Careful surgical technique and timing of neo-membrane removal are critical.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that the non-metallic nature of the implant opens possibilities for MRI studies post-implantation. Further research into more effective methods for preventing or managing neo-membrane growth could enhance the longevity and quality of imaging. The method is presented as a practical solution for both anesthetized and awake, behaving animals, paving the way for more extensive behavioral studies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{chen2002chamber,
  author = {Li Min Chen and Barbara Heider and Graham V. Williams and Francine L. Healy and Benjamin M. Ramsden and Anna Wang Roe},
  title = {{A chamber and artificial dura method for long-term optical imaging in the monkey}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience Methods},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1016/s0165-0270(01)00475-7},
}
Figure