A cellular census of healthy lung and asthmatic airway wall identifies novel cell states in health and disease

Felipe A. Vieira Braga, Gouri Sankar Kar, Marijn Berg, Orestes A. Carpaij, Krzysztof Polański, Lukas M. Simon, Sharon Brouwer, Taísa Godoy Gomes, Laura Hesse, Jian Jiang, Eirini S. Fasouli, Mirjana Efremova, Roser Vento‐Tormo, Karen Affleck, Subarna Palit, Paulina M. Strzelecka, Helen V. Firth, Krishnaa T. Mahbubani, Ana Cvejic, Kerstin B. Meyer, Kourosh Saeb‐Parsy, Marjan Luinge, Corry‐Anke Brandsma, Wim Timens, Ilias Angelidis, Maximilian Strunz, Gerard H. Koppelman, Antoon J. van Oosterhout, Herbert B. Schiller, Fabian J. Theis, Maarten van den Berge, Martijn C. Nawijn, Sarah A. TeichmannbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses single-cell transcriptomics to create a detailed cellular map of the human lung in both health and asthma. They identified novel epithelial cell states and a new type of T cell, revealing how these cells change and interact differently in asthma, particularly highlighting the role of Th2 cells and cytokines in disease progression.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human lung is a complex organ with a critical role in gas exchange and immune defense. Maintaining lung homeostasis relies on intricate interactions between structural and immune cells. However, our understanding of the diverse cell types within the lung, especially their specific states and how they communicate, is incomplete. This knowledge gap limits our ability to understand and treat lung diseases like asthma. Previous research has identified some specialized cells, like ionocytes, but a comprehensive cellular census across different lung regions and in disease states was lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a detailed single-cell atlas of the lung's cellular landscape in health and disease.

Methods

The researchers employed single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq), a powerful technique that allows them to analyze the gene expression of individual cells. They utilized multiple scRNA-seq platforms (10x Genomics Chromium, SmartSeq2, and Drop-seq) across different research centers to ensure robust data.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Comprehensive Tissue Sampling: They collected samples from the upper airways (nasal brushes), lower airways (bronchial brushes and biopsies), and lung parenchyma (tissue pieces from deceased donors).
  • Bioinformatic Analysis: Advanced computational methods were used for data processing, including:
  • Quality Control and Filtering: Removing low-quality cells and doublets.
  • Clustering: Grouping cells with similar gene expression profiles to identify distinct cell types and states.
  • Differential Expression Analysis: Identifying genes that are uniquely expressed in specific cell types or conditions.
  • CellPhoneDB: A tool for inferring cell-cell communication networks based on receptor-ligand interactions.
  • Pseudotime Analysis: Inferring developmental trajectories of cell differentiation.
  • Integration with External Databases: They cross-referenced their findings with databases like OMIM (Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man) to link cell types to Mendelian diseases and with GWAS (Genome-Wide Association Studies) data to connect cell-type specific gene expression to asthma susceptibility.

Datasets

The study utilized human lung tissue samples from:

  • Healthy Volunteers: Collected via nasal brushes, bronchial brushes, and biopsies.
  • Asthma Patients: Collected via bronchial biopsies.
  • Deceased Organ Donors: Lung parenchyma tissue was obtained from lung transplant donors.

The paper also references and utilizes data from the Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM) database and the GWAS Catalog for disease association analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lung Zonation is Real: The study confirms that epithelial cell states vary significantly across different anatomical locations within the lung (upper airways, lower airways, parenchyma). This suggests a specialized functional organization.
  • Novel Epithelial Cell States: They identified new epithelial cell states, including a "mucous ciliated cell" state that appears to be a key contributor to mucous cell hyperplasia in asthma.
  • A New T Cell Subset: A novel subset of "Tissue Migratory CD4 T cells" (TMC) was identified, distinct from classical Tissue Resident Memory (TRM) T cells, suggesting a more dynamic immune cell population in the airways.
  • Asthma's Th2 Dominance: The research strongly implicates type-2 cytokines (like IL-4 and IL-13) in driving epithelial changes in asthma, particularly the mucous ciliated cell state.
  • Shift in Cell Communication: In healthy lungs, structural cells dominate communication. In asthma, this shifts dramatically towards Th2 cells interacting with both immune and structural cells, indicating a major change in the airway's communication landscape.
  • Disease Relevance: The study links specific cell types to Mendelian diseases (e.g., ionocytes to cystic fibrosis) and identifies cell-type specific expression of asthma-associated genes.

Key Results

  • Cellular Census: Identified at least 21 main cell types in the normal human lung, with further subdivisions into fine-grained cell states.
  • Mucous Cell Metaplasia in Asthma: Demonstrated that mucous cell hyperplasia in asthma stems from a novel mucous ciliated cell state and goblet cell hyperplasia.
  • Pathogenic Effector Th2 Cells: Found an enrichment of pathogenic effector Th2 cells in asthmatic airways, characterized by specific cytokine expression profiles and transcription factors.
  • Altered Cell-Cell Interactions: Revealed a significant reduction in epithelial-mesenchymal communication in asthmatic airways, replaced by a Th2-dominated interactome.
  • GWAS Gene Association: Showed that asthma GWAS genes are broadly expressed across airway epithelial cell types, with high expression in ciliated and mucous ciliated cells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size for Asthma: While the study provides a detailed cellular map, the number of asthma patients analyzed for specific cell types (e.g., CD4 T cells) might be limited, potentially affecting the statistical power for certain findings.
  • Innate Lymphoid Cells: Innate lymphoid cells (ILCs) were not detected as distinct clusters, likely due to their low numbers in the analyzed samples. Further purification and analysis of these cells are suggested for future studies.
  • Mucous Ciliated Cell Fate: The exact fate of mucous ciliated cells (whether they lose FOXJ1 expression and transdifferentiate into goblet cells) remains to be firmly established.
  • Notch Signaling in Asthma: The study suggests that mucous cell metaplasia in mild asthmatics is likely NOTCH-independent, driven by type-2 cytokines. However, conflicting data on Notch signaling's role in goblet cell metaplasia in other contexts warrants further investigation.
  • TMC vs. TRM Comparison: While TMC cells were identified, further studies are needed to properly compare them with previously reported TRM subsets and to fully elucidate their role and potential for transit between lung and blood.
  • Innate Lymphoid Cells: The paper notes that innate lymphoid cells were present in too low numbers to be analyzed and suggests they need to be purified for further characterization in future studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary Human lungs enable efficient gas exchange, and form an interface with the environment which depends on mucosal immunity for protection against infectious agents. Tightly controlled interactions between structural and immune cells are required to maintain lung homeostasis. Here, we use single cell transcriptomics to chart the cellular landscape of upper and lower airways and lung parenchyma in health. We report location-dependent airway epithelial cell states, and a novel subset of tissue-resident memory T cells. In lower airways of asthma patients, mucous cell hyperplasia is shown to stem from a novel mucous ciliated cell state, as well as goblet cell hyperplasia. We report presence of pathogenic effector Th2 cells in asthma, and find evidence for type-2 cytokines in maintaining the altered epithelial cell states. Unbiased analysis of cell-cell interactions identify a shift from airway structural cell communication in health to a Th2-dominated interactome in asthma.
BibTeX
@misc{braga2019cellular,
  author = {Felipe A. Vieira Braga and Gouri Sankar Kar and Marijn Berg and Orestes A. Carpaij and Krzysztof Polański and Lukas M. Simon and Sharon Brouwer and Taísa Godoy Gomes and Laura Hesse and Jian Jiang and Eirini S. Fasouli and Mirjana Efremova and Roser Vento‐Tormo and Karen Affleck and Subarna Palit and Paulina M. Strzelecka and Helen V. Firth and Krishnaa T. Mahbubani and Ana Cvejic and Kerstin B. Meyer and Kourosh Saeb‐Parsy and Marjan Luinge and Corry‐Anke Brandsma and Wim Timens and Ilias Angelidis and Maximilian Strunz and Gerard H. Koppelman and Antoon J. van Oosterhout and Herbert B. Schiller and Fabian J. Theis and Maarten van den Berge and Martijn C. Nawijn and Sarah A. Teichmann},
  title = {{A cellular census of healthy lung and asthmatic airway wall identifies novel cell states in health and disease}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/527408},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure