A Case of Vascular Pulsatile Tinnitus in the Left Ear Occurred 4 Years after the Operation of Vascular Pulsatile Tinnitus in the Right Ear

Hai Zhao, Bi Yao, Li YongtuanJournal of Otolaryngology and Rhinology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This case report documents a rare occurrence where a patient developed vascular pulsatile tinnitus (VPT) in her left ear four years after successfully undergoing surgery to fix the same condition in her right ear. The findings suggest that the sigmoid sinus—a major venous channel in the skull—is not a static anatomical structure, but one that can remodel over time due to changes in blood flow pressure and velocity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pulsatile tinnitus (PT) is a rhythmic sound perceived by the patient that synchronizes with their heartbeat. Unlike "ringing in the ears," PT is often caused by physical vascular issues, such as a thinning of the bone wall (dehiscence) or a small pouch-like protrusion (diverticulum) in the sigmoid sinus. When the bone separating this large vein from the middle ear thins out, the sound of rushing blood is "eavesdropped" by the inner ear.

While surgical reconstruction of the sinus wall is a known effective treatment, this paper addresses a puzzling clinical phenomenon: why would a patient, cured on one side, develop a brand-new lesion on the opposite side years later? The authors explore whether surgical intervention on one side of the cranial venous system can trigger anatomical changes on the other.

Methods

As a clinical case report, the "methods" involve a longitudinal diagnostic workup of a single patient (a 35-year-old female):

  • Imaging: High-resolution temporal bone CT (HRCT) was used to identify bone wall defects. Intracranial vessel MRA and jugular vein ultrasound were used to rule out other vascular masses or arterial issues.
  • Audiology: Pure tone audiometry and Auditory Brainstem Response (ABR) testing were performed to ensure hearing thresholds were normal.
  • Surgical Intervention: For the initial right-ear complaint, surgeons performed a sigmoid sinus bone wall reconstruction using a multi-layered approach: abrading the mastoid cavity, stripping the sinus from the bone, and reinforcing the wall with fascia, auricular cartilage, and bone wax.
  • Comparative Analysis: The authors performed a retrospective review of the patient’s 2018 CT scans to confirm that the left-side lesion was truly new and not a missed diagnosis from four years prior.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. (This is a single-patient clinical case report rather than a large-scale data study.)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Dynamic Anatomy" Hypothesis: The most significant insight is that the sigmoid sinus and its surrounding bone are not "congenital and invariable." The authors argue that these structures are plastic and can be reshaped by hemodynamic forces after birth.
  • Hemodynamic Ripple Effects: The authors speculate that the successful surgery on the right side indirectly altered the blood flow pressure and velocity in the left sigmoid sinus. Over four years, this altered pressure likely promoted bone absorption and thinning on the left side, eventually forming a diverticulum.
  • Diagnostic Vigilance: The case highlights that even if a patient’s contralateral ear appears normal on an initial CT, clinicians should remain aware that new vascular lesions can develop over time, potentially as a long-term consequence of previous surgeries or shifting venous pressures.

Key Results

  • Initial Success: The 2018 surgery on the right ear was completely successful, with no recurrence of tinnitus on that side for the duration of the follow-up.
  • Contralateral Emergence: In 2022, the patient presented with identical symptoms in the left ear. CT imaging confirmed a new sigmoid sinus diverticulum that was definitively absent in the 2018 scans.
  • Clinical Confirmation: The left-side tinnitus could be temporarily stopped by applying gentle pressure to the left neck (compressing the jugular vein), confirming the venous origin of the sound.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: As a single case report, the findings are anecdotal. It is difficult to definitively prove a causal link between the right-side surgery and the left-side lesion without a larger cohort study.
  • Speculative Mechanism: The exact fluid dynamics (pressure/velocity changes) following the first surgery were not measured. Future research could involve computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modeling of the cranial venous system before and after such surgeries to predict "at-risk" areas for new lesions.
  • Need for Longitudinal Data: The authors call for more reports of similar cases to determine if this is a rare fluke or a predictable, albeit delayed, complication of unilateral venous sinus surgery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Vascular pulsatile tinnitus is a rare tinnitus. Sigmoid sinus related lesion is found one of the important causes of venous pulsatile tinnitus in recent years. This study reports a case of vascular pulsatile tinnitus in the left ear occurred 4 years after the operation of vascular pulsatile tinnitus in the right ear.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2024case,
  author = {Hai Zhao and Bi Yao and Li Yongtuan},
  title = {{A Case of Vascular Pulsatile Tinnitus in the Left Ear Occurred 4 Years after the Operation of Vascular Pulsatile Tinnitus in the Right Ear}},
  journal = {Journal of Otolaryngology and Rhinology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.23937/2572-4193.1510151},
}
Figure