A CASE OF PLEURAL METASTASIS FROM BREAST CANCER WITH CONCURRENT PRIMARY LUNG CANCER DIAGNOSED 17 YEARS AFTER MASTECTOMY

Yozo Kawano, Yutaka Fujitomi, Kenji Fujiyoshi, Kōichi TanakaNihon 2010 · DOI

Abstract

This report describes a 67-year-old female patient who presented with a new primary lung adenocarcinoma 17 years after a mastectomy for breast cancer. During surgery for the lung nodule, unexpected pleural miliary nodules were discovered. Immunohistochemical (IHC) analysis was crucial in distinguishing the two distinct malignancies: the lung nodule was a primary adenocarcinoma (TTF-1 positive, ER/PgR negative), while the pleural nodules were metastatic breast cancer (ER/PgR positive, TTF-1 negative). This case highlights the potential for very late breast cancer recurrence and the importance of thorough pathological evaluation to guide appropriate therapy.

Introduction: Recurrence vs. New Primary

When patients with a history of malignancy present with new tumors, clinicians must distinguish between a recurrence of the original cancer and a second primary malignancy. This distinction is vital for staging and treatment planning. In this case, a patient 17 years post-mastectomy faced a diagnostic challenge when a new lung nodule appeared alongside unexpected pleural dissemination.

Case Presentation

A 67-year-old woman had been under observation for a stable micro-nodule in the right lung. However, a follow-up CT scan revealed a new, faint nodule in the left lung's lingular segment.

Preoperative CT scan showing the left lung nodule (a) and zoomed view (b).

A transbronchial lung biopsy (TBLB) confirmed primary lung adenocarcinoma. Although preoperative CT showed some pleural thickening, it was not initially deemed pathologically significant. During Video-Assisted Thoracoscopic Surgery (VATS), surgeons observed extensive miliary nodules across the entire pleural cavity, including the surface of the lingular tumor.

Intraoperative VATS findings showing multiple miliary nodules on the pleura (a) and the relationship between lung lobes (b).

Pathological Differentiation

The discovery of pleural nodules in a patient with lung cancer typically indicates Stage IV disease, often precluding curative surgery. However, intraoperative pathology suggested these nodules were metastatic breast cancer rather than spread from the lung adenocarcinoma.

Final immunohistochemistry (IHC) confirmed this "collision" of two cancers:

  • Lung Nodule: TTF-1 positive, ER/PgR negative (Primary Lung Adenocarcinoma).
  • Pleural Nodules: ER/PgR positive, TTF-1 negative (Metastatic Breast Cancer).

Discussion and Key Insights

Tumor Dormancy and Late Recurrence

Breast cancer is known for its ability to recur many years after initial treatment, a phenomenon attributed to "tumor dormancy." Recurrence more than 15 years post-mastectomy is rare (approximately 0.4%) but must remain a diagnostic consideration.

The Importance of IHC Markers

This case demonstrates that pleural dissemination in a lung cancer patient is not always synonymous with terminal lung cancer. By using specific markers like TTF-1 (lung-specific) and ER/PgR (breast-specific), the clinical team decoupled the two diagnoses. This allowed for a curative-intent partial resection of the lung tumor and targeted hormone therapy (Anastrozole) for the metastatic breast cancer.

Conclusion

Clinicians should maintain a high index of suspicion for late breast cancer recurrence in patients with a relevant history. Accurate pathological diagnosis using IHC is essential to prevent the misclassification of treatable secondary recurrences as incurable primary disease spread, ensuring patients receive the most effective combined treatment strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

症例は67歳,女性.17年前に乳癌で左乳房切除術の既往あり.5年前の検診CTで右肺S8微小結節指摘され定期通院していた.同部は著変なかったが左舌区に淡い結節出現,TBLBにて肺腺癌の確診が得られ手術となった.術前CTでは一部胸膜肥厚あるも病的意義なしと判断していた.胸腔内観察したところ胸腔内全体に播種と思われる多発粟粒結節あり,舌区腫瘍表面にも播種を認め舌区の部分切除のみ施行した.肺癌の播種は考えにくく,術中病理診においても胸膜病変は乳癌胸膜転移とされた.最終病理においても肺内病変はER,PgR陰性,TTF-1陽性で肺腺癌,胸膜病変はER,PgR陽性でTTF-1陰性であり,類似した組織像であるが乳癌の転移播種と診断した.乳癌晩期再発報告は散見されるが,常にその可能性を念頭に置き精査加療を行わなければならない.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kawano2010case,
  author = {Yozo Kawano and Yutaka Fujitomi and Kenji Fujiyoshi and Kōichi Tanaka},
  title = {{A CASE OF PLEURAL METASTASIS FROM BREAST CANCER WITH CONCURRENT PRIMARY LUNG CANCER DIAGNOSED 17 YEARS AFTER MASTECTOMY}},
  booktitle = {Nihon},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.3919/jjsa.71.2552},
}
Figure