TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel bounding surface plasticity model that accounts for both anisotropy and structure in soils, extending its application to both saturated and unsaturated conditions. This model is crucial for accurately predicting the complex mechanical and hydraulic behavior of structured soils, which are prevalent in many geotechnical engineering applications.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Many existing soil models struggle to accurately capture the behavior of structured soils, especially when considering both anisotropy (directional dependence of soil properties) and the effects of saturation levels. Structured soils, common in natural deposits, exhibit unique mechanical properties due to their inherent fabric and cementation, leading to higher strength and compressibility compared to reconstituted soils. Existing models often focus on either saturated conditions or isotropic behavior, failing to capture the combined effects of anisotropy and structure under varying degrees of saturation. This gap is critical because many real-world soil deposits are both structured and anisotropic, and their behavior is significantly influenced by water content.
Methods
The authors propose a bounding surface plasticity model that builds upon established frameworks but introduces key novelties:
- Bounding Surface Plasticity: This framework allows for plastic deformation even when the stress state is within the bounding surface, enabling the capture of gradual yielding.
- Anisotropy and Structure Integration: The model explicitly incorporates the effects of both inherent and stress-induced anisotropy, as well as soil structure, on mechanical behavior. This includes accounting for the loading collapse (LC) bounding surface and structure degradation.
- Anisotropy-Dependent Soil Water Retention: A new equation is introduced to describe the soil water retention curve (SWRC) that accounts for the influence of anisotropy on water retention capacity. This is a significant advancement, as previous models often overlooked this aspect.
- Complementary Bonding Variable: A bonding variable ($\xi$) is used to model the additional suction effects arising from water menisci at inter-particle contacts, which stabilize the soil skeleton.
- Radial Mapping Rule: This rule is employed to describe the evolution of plastic strain rates, particularly for capturing the gradual yielding of overconsolidated soils.
Datasets
The paper validates its model against extensive experimental data from the literature, including:
- Isotropically consolidated Lower Cromer Till (LCT) specimens (Gens, 1982).
- Ko consolidated LCT specimens.
- Kc consolidated LCT specimens.
- Compacted Speswhite Kaolin under various suctions (Al-Sharrad, 2013).
- Intact and reconstituted Taihu clay (Liu et al., 2013).
- Intact and compacted loess under saturated and unsaturated conditions (Ng et al., 2017).
No new datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Anisotropy Significantly Impacts Water Retention: The model's success in capturing experimental data highlights that anisotropy plays a crucial role in how much water a soil can retain at a given suction, a factor often overlooked in simpler models.
- Structure Degradation is Coupled with Anisotropy Evolution: The model demonstrates how plastic deformation not only degrades soil structure but also influences the evolution of anisotropy, leading to complex changes in soil behavior.
- Bounding Surface Plasticity is Key for Gradual Yielding: The use of a bounding surface framework is essential for accurately simulating the gradual yielding observed in many structured and anisotropic soils, which is not captured by classical plasticity models.
- Unified Approach for Saturated and Unsaturated Conditions: A major achievement is the development of a single model that can handle both saturated and unsaturated states, providing a more holistic understanding of soil behavior.
Key Results
The model's performance was validated through simulations of various triaxial tests on different soil types. Key findings include:
- The model accurately captures the stress-strain behavior, volumetric deformation, and degree of saturation for both anisotropic and isotropic soils under saturated and unsaturated conditions.
- It successfully simulates the influence of anisotropy on the loading collapse (LC) curve and the soil water retention curve (SWRC).
- The model demonstrates good agreement with experimental data for various soil types, including clays and loess, under different stress paths and saturation levels.
- The model shows that neglecting anisotropy can lead to significant differences in predicted yielding behavior and structure degradation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Radial Mapping Rule for High OCR: The authors note that the applied radial mapping rule might not be entirely appropriate for soils with very high overconsolidation ratios (OCR), leading to slight deviations in deviatoric stress predictions for certain cases.
- Limited Experimental Data for Structure Effects on SWRC: The simplification of structure effects on the SWRC is due to limited experimental data. More research is planned in this area.
- Scanning Curves: The current model can model the main drying and wetting curves but cannot simulate scanning curves in the SWRC.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that for cyclic loading, alternative mapping rules might be considered. Further experimental and theoretical studies are planned to investigate the influence of structure degradation on water retention curves.
Summary updated