A Bombieri-Vinogradov Theorem for primes in short intervals and small sectors

Tanmay Khale, Cooper O'Kuhn, Apoorva Panidapu, Alec Sun, Shengtong ZhangJournal of Number Theory 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

The distribution of prime numbers is a central theme in analytic number theory. Two classical directions of study involve counting primes in "short intervals" $[x, x+h]$ and counting primes that satisfy specific geometric constraints, such as belonging to "small sectors" defined by the norm forms of a number field. While the Bombieri-Vinogradov theorem provides a powerful tool for understanding the distribution of primes in arithmetic progressions on average, extending this result to primes subject to both short interval and small sector constraints has historically been a significant challenge.

This paper establishes a new Bombieri-Vinogradov type theorem for primes in a general finite Galois extension $K/\mathbb{Q}$. By combining sophisticated inclusion-exclusion arguments with refined zero-density estimates for Hecke $L$-functions, the authors provide an asymptotic count for these primes and demonstrate their equidistribution in arithmetic progressions.

The Challenge of Simultaneous Constraints

To understand the scope of this work, one must consider the three distinct constraints being applied:

  1. Short Intervals: Primes $p$ are restricted to the range $[x, x+h]$, where $h$ is significantly smaller than $x$.
  2. Small Sectors: Primes are restricted by the geometry of the number field $K$. For example, if $K = \mathbb{Q}(i)$, this might mean $p = a^2 + b^2$ where the components $(a, b)$ satisfy a geometric constraint (e.g., $|a| < p^{1/2-\delta}$).
  3. Arithmetic Progressions: Primes must satisfy $p \equiv a \pmod q$.

Previous research, notably by Coleman and Duke, successfully handled these conditions for imaginary quadratic extensions. However, extending these results to general number fields $K$ of higher degree $n$ is non-trivial. The primary difficulty lies in the complex relationship between rational primes and prime ideals in $K$, and the need for robust zero-density estimates for the associated $L$-functions.

Methodology

The authors utilize a multi-faceted approach to overcome these technical hurdles:

Inclusion-Exclusion and Galois Theory

A critical contribution of this paper is the rigorous treatment of the correspondence between rational primes and prime ideals. In a general Galois extension $K/\mathbb{Q}$, a rational prime $p$ may split into multiple prime ideals. The authors identify that previous attempts in the literature to establish a one-to-one correspondence were insufficient for general fields. They resolve this by implementing a combinatorial inclusion-exclusion argument over the Galois group $\text{Gal}(K/\mathbb{Q})$, ensuring that each rational prime is counted exactly once.

Hecke $L$-functions and Smoothing

The "small sector" condition is captured analytically using Hecke characters. To manage the "sharp edges" of the intervals and sectors—which typically introduce technical difficulties in contour integration—the authors employ smooth minorants and majorants. By using Mellin transforms and Selberg’s functions, they create a smoothed version of the counting function that is more amenable to analytic techniques.

Zero-Density Estimates

The proof of the main Bombieri-Vinogradov result (Theorem 1.2) hinges on bounding the number of "bad" zeros of Hecke $L$-functions. The authors adapt and refine zero-density estimates originally developed for lower-degree cases, extending their validity to handle the increased complexity of general Galois extensions.

Key Results

The paper presents two primary theorems that characterize the distribution of these constrained primes.

Theorem 1.1: Asymptotic Count

For a Galois extension $K/\mathbb{Q}$ of degree $n$, the authors derive an asymptotic formula for the weighted count of primes in a short interval $[x, x+h]$ that fall into a narrow sector. The count is shown to be roughly proportional to the size of the interval and the volume of the sector: $$\sum_{p \in \text{Sector} \cap [x, x+h]} \log p \sim \frac{c \cdot x^{-(n-1)\delta} h}{|\mathcal{I}|}$$ where $\delta$ represents the "smallness" of the sector and $h$ is the length of the interval.

Theorem 1.2: Bombieri-Vinogradov Type Result

The authors prove that these sector-restricted primes are well-distributed in arithmetic progressions $p \equiv a \pmod q$ on average for $q \le x^\theta$. Specifically, they show that the mean error term is small, which is the hallmark of a Bombieri-Vinogradov type result. This holds provided the parameters for the interval shortness ($\delta'$), sector smallness ($\delta$), and progression level ($\theta$) satisfy the balancing condition: $$2\theta + \max(\delta, \delta') < \frac{2}{5n}$$

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work represents a significant generalization of prime distribution theory, moving beyond quadratic fields to any finite Galois extension. However, certain limitations remain. The requirement that $K/\mathbb{Q}$ be Galois is essential for the current method of counting rational primes. Additionally, the range of parameters is currently limited by the $\frac{2}{5n}$ threshold, a constraint imposed by the state-of-the-art in zero-density estimates. Future improvements in the zero-free regions or density hypotheses for Hecke $L$-functions could potentially allow for even more restrictive constraints on the intervals and sectors.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{khale2021bombieri,
  author = {Tanmay Khale and Cooper O'Kuhn and Apoorva Panidapu and Alec Sun and Shengtong Zhang},
  title = {{A Bombieri-Vinogradov Theorem for primes in short intervals and small sectors}},
  journal = {Journal of Number Theory},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jnt.2021.04.004},
}
Figure