A bidirectional network for appetite control in larval zebrafish

Caroline Lei Wee, Erin Song, Robert E. Johnson, Deepak Ailani, Owen Randlett, Ji-Yoon Kim, Maxim Nikitchenko, Armin Bahl, Chao-Tsung Yang, Misha B. Ahrens, Koichi Kawakami, Florian Engert, Sam KuneseLife 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a bidirectional neural network in larval zebrafish brains that controls appetite by coordinating hunger and satiety states. By mapping neural activity and manipulating specific brain regions, the researchers identified an antagonistic relationship between the caudal hypothalamus (cH) and lateral hypothalamus (LH) that is crucial for regulating feeding behavior and energy balance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The hypothalamus is a key brain region for regulating appetite, with distinct areas historically associated with promoting or suppressing feeding. However, the precise dynamics and functional interactions between these hypothalamic nuclei, particularly how they orchestrate the transition between hunger and satiety, remain poorly understood. This paper aims to elucidate these interactions by investigating the activity patterns and functional roles of specific hypothalamic regions in larval zebrafish, a model organism with a transparent brain that facilitates neural circuit analysis.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Whole-brain activity mapping (MAP-mapping): Using phosphorylated ERK (pERK) staining, they visualized neural activity across the entire brain in response to different feeding states (food-deprived vs. fed). This allowed them to identify brain regions with differential activity.
  • Calcium Imaging: In vivo calcium imaging was used to track the real-time activity of neurons in the caudal hypothalamus (cH) and lateral hypothalamus (LH) in response to sensory cues (prey presentation) and during feeding.
  • Optogenetics: This technique was used to selectively activate or inhibit specific neuronal populations. Specifically, they used channelrhodopsin (ReaChR) to activate cH neurons and observed the effects on LH activity and feeding behavior.
  • Chemogenetic Ablation: They used a nitroreductase-based system to selectively ablate serotonergic neurons in the cH and assessed the impact on feeding behavior.
  • Behavioral Assays: Quantifying food intake (gut fluorescence) and tracking hunting behavior were used to assess the functional outcomes of manipulating neural activity.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as training or evaluation datasets in the context of machine learning. The study utilized datasets generated from their own experiments involving larval zebrafish under various feeding conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Antagonistic Hypothalamic Control: The study strongly supports the idea that the cH and LH act in an antagonistic manner to control appetite. When one is active, the other is suppressed, creating a push-pull system.
  • Dynamic States of Hunger and Satiety: The activity patterns in cH and LH are not static but dynamically shift to reflect distinct internal states of hunger, satiety, and the transition between them.
  • Serotonergic Neurons in Appetite: The research highlights the critical role of serotonergic neurons in the caudal hypothalamus (cH) as a key regulator of appetite, particularly in signaling hunger and satiety.
  • Sensory vs. Consummatory Cues: The study differentiates the roles of sensory cues (detecting prey) and consummatory cues (ingesting food), showing that both influence hypothalamic activity but with different strengths and timing.
  • "Priming" for Feeding: The cH appears to "prime" the LH during hunger, making it more responsive to food cues when they become available, thus facilitating rapid feeding.

Key Results

  • Food Deprivation: During food deprivation, the cH shows increased activity, while the LH shows reduced activity.
  • Food Presentation: Upon presentation of food cues, this pattern reverses: LH activity increases significantly, and cH activity decreases. This reversal is more pronounced after longer periods of deprivation.
  • Optogenetic Activation of cH: Activating cH neurons suppressed LH activity and, in food-deprived animals, led to increased food intake (suggesting priming). In satiated animals, cH activation reduced food intake.
  • Ablation of cH: Ablating cH neurons enhanced food intake, consistent with the idea that the cH normally inhibits feeding.
  • Prey Detection vs. Ingestion: While both sensory and consummatory cues activate hypothalamic regions, ingestion cues (like paramecia) elicited a stronger response, particularly in the mLH.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Transgenic Line Specificity: The authors acknowledge that due to the lack of complete transgene specificity and the use of different lines for stimulation and ablation, it's not always certain they are manipulating the exact same neuronal population.
  • Intermediary Neurons: The precise mechanisms of mutual inhibition between cH and LH are not fully elucidated, with possibilities including direct inhibitory connections or intermediary neurons.
  • Full Circuit Model Validation: The proposed conceptual circuit model is a working hypothesis, and further studies are needed for complete validation.
  • mLH and ILH Perturbation: While the study focuses on the cH and general LH, specific optogenetic perturbation of mLH and ILH is currently limited by the availability of suitable transgenic lines.
  • Other Neuromodulators: The role of other neuromodulators (e.g., dopamine) in appetite control, beyond serotonin, is not ruled out.

Future work could involve exploring the roles of other hypothalamic nuclei, dissecting the precise connectivity between cH and LH, and further validating the proposed circuit model through more extensive experimental manipulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Medial and lateral hypothalamic loci are known to suppress and enhance appetite, respectively, but the dynamics and functional significance of their interaction have yet to be explored. Here we report that, in larval zebrafish, primarily serotonergic neurons of the ventromedial caudal hypothalamus (cH) become increasingly active during food deprivation, whereas activity in the lateral hypothalamus (LH) is reduced. Exposure to food sensory and consummatory cues reverses the activity patterns of these two nuclei, consistent with their representation of opposing internal hunger states. Baseline activity is restored as food-deprived animals return to satiety via voracious feeding. The antagonistic relationship and functional importance of cH and LH activity patterns were confirmed by targeted stimulation and ablation of cH neurons. Collectively, the data allow us to propose a model in which these hypothalamic nuclei regulate different phases of hunger and satiety and coordinate energy balance via antagonistic control of distinct behavioral outputs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wee2019bidirectional,
  author = {Caroline Lei Wee and Erin Song and Robert E. Johnson and Deepak Ailani and Owen Randlett and Ji-Yoon Kim and Maxim Nikitchenko and Armin Bahl and Chao-Tsung Yang and Misha B. Ahrens and Koichi Kawakami and Florian Engert and Sam Kunes},
  title = {{A bidirectional network for appetite control in larval zebrafish}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.43775},
}
Figure