TL;DR
This paper provides a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of the Food-Energy-Water (FEW) nexus literature, revealing a rapid growth in publications since 2011, particularly after major funding calls. While the research highlights a strong focus on quantitative interlinkages, it identifies a significant gap in understanding qualitative institutional capacities and intersectoral governance challenges.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The world faces increasing pressure on its food, energy, and water resources due to population growth, urbanization, and climate change. Historically, these resources have been managed in isolation, leading to unintended consequences and increased risks. The "FEW nexus" approach aims to address this by examining the complex interconnections between these sectors to foster better understanding and inform policy. However, the rapid emergence of this field raises questions about its trajectory, key research areas, and the actual integration achieved. This paper addresses the need to systematically assess the FEW nexus literature to identify emerging themes, research hotspots, and critically, the extent to which nexus thinking is being translated into actionable strategies, particularly concerning governance and institutional aspects.
Methods
The authors employed a bibliometric analysis approach, utilizing Elsevier's SCOPUS database to identify relevant publications from January 2011 to May 2018. The study involved several key steps:
- Data Collection: A search was conducted using the term "Food, Water and Energy Nexus" and its variations in titles, abstracts, and keywords.
- Bibliometric Analysis: The software BibExcel was used to analyze publication characteristics such as type, journal, region, year, and keywords.
- Term Co-occurrence Network Mapping: VOSviewer was employed to visualize the relationships between terms extracted from abstracts, identifying key concepts and their connections. This involved filtering terms to focus on those co-occurring more than 10 times and with high relevance scores.
- Thematic Analysis: A manual reading and coding of abstracts from all 257 publications were performed to identify key themes and research foci. For a deeper understanding, the entire papers of the top 20 most cited publications were also analyzed.
Datasets
The primary dataset for this study was derived from Elsevier's SCOPUS database, containing 257 publications related to the Food-Energy-Water (FEW) nexus from January 2011 to May 2018. No new datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Exponential Growth Driven by Funding: The FEW nexus literature has experienced exponential growth, with a notable surge in publications around 2015-2016, directly coinciding with major funding calls from agencies like the NSF and the adoption of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). This highlights the significant role of external funding in shaping research agendas.
- Water-Centric Framing: The analysis of keywords and term co-occurrence networks reveals a strong tendency towards a "water-centric" framing of the FEW nexus. This suggests that while the nexus concept aims for integration, the existing scholarly and policy frameworks, particularly those rooted in Integrated Water Resource Management (IWRM), may be influencing how the nexus is conceptualized.
- "Investment" as a Unifying, Yet Superficial, Term: The term "investment" emerged as a central node in the co-occurrence network, frequently linked to many other terms. However, the authors caution that this might reflect its common use in concluding statements ("more investment is needed") rather than indicating a deep, integrated analysis of investment strategies within the FEW nexus.
- Governance and Policy Lag Behind: A striking finding is the weak connection of the term "governance" in the network map, suggesting that research on governance, institutional capacities, and policy integration within the FEW nexus is significantly underdeveloped compared to quantitative and techno-economic aspects. This is identified as a critical gap in translating nexus thinking into action.
- Disciplinary Silos Persist: Despite the interdisciplinary nature of the FEW nexus, the analysis indicates that research often remains confined within disciplinary silos, with limited integration of diverse methods and approaches, particularly a lack of engagement with qualitative social science methods.
Key Results
- Publication Trends: A steady increase in publications from 2011, with a sharp upturn in 2015 and 2016.
- Top Journals: "Environmental Science and Policy" and "Journal of Environmental Studies and Science" were among the top journals publishing FEW nexus research.
- Geographic Focus: Europe and Central Asia, followed by South Asia and North America, were the most studied regions.
- Publication Types: Approximately 83% of the publications were peer-reviewed journal articles.
- Dominant Themes: "Resource interdependencies" was the most dominant theme, followed by "FEW security and climate resilience," and "Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)."
- Keyword Analysis: Water-related keywords like "water footprint" and "basin" were prominent, supporting the observation of a water-centric framing.
- Term Co-occurrence: "Investment" showed strong connections, while "governance" had weak links.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Abstract Reliance: While abstracts provide a good overview, they may not always be fully representative of the entire work. The analysis of top-cited papers aimed to mitigate this.
- Geographic Bias: The study acknowledges a potential bias in case-study region analysis if authors did not include the location in their abstracts.
- Gray Literature: While SCOPUS indexes some gray literature, its coverage is noted as potentially limited.
The paper suggests several avenues for future research:
- Strengthening Governance Research: There is a critical need for more research on governance, intersectoral integration, and policy frameworks to bridge the gap between nexus thinking and action.
- Integrating Qualitative Methods: Future work should incorporate more qualitative social science methods to better understand institutional capacities and stakeholder perspectives.
- Addressing Data and Scale Mismatches: Overcoming data limitations and developing hierarchical frameworks that integrate cross-scalar interactions are crucial for practical implementation.
- Policy and Decision Support: Further development of decision support tools and models that are perceived as credible, salient, and legitimate by decision-makers is essential.
- Beyond Resource Efficiency: While resource efficiency is a focus, more attention is needed on how nexus approaches can address poverty and promote equitable development.
Summary updated