TL;DR
This paper provides a comprehensive 50-year bibliometric analysis of environmental behavior research, revealing a rapid growth in publications and identifying key evolutionary stages and emerging hotspots. The findings highlight "green human resource management" and "environmental awareness" as rapidly growing areas, while "pro-environmental behavior," "sustainability," and "climate change" remain central themes, offering valuable insights for future research and policy.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Environmental behavior is a critical area for achieving sustainable development, as understanding and promoting environmentally friendly actions can significantly mitigate pollution and protect ecosystems. However, the field is interdisciplinary and has evolved considerably over decades. Researchers, policymakers, and practitioners need a clear, systematic overview of this evolution, including its historical trajectory, key research themes, and emerging trends. Previous studies have often been limited by single data sources, short time spans, or a lack of dynamic analysis, leading to an incomplete understanding of the field's development. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a multi-dimensional, long-term bibliometric analysis of environmental behavior research.
Methods
The study employs bibliometric analysis, a quantitative approach to analyze research output. Specifically, it utilizes two software packages: ScientoPy for quantitative analysis and VOSviewer for scientific mapping and visualization. The core methods include:
- Quantitative Analysis: This involves analyzing publication counts, country contributions, journal distributions, and author affiliations to understand the overall landscape and growth trends.
- Scientific Mapping Visualization: This uses techniques like keyword and term co-occurrence analysis to visually represent the knowledge structure, identify research hotspots, and map the evolution of themes over time.
- Diachronic Clustering Analysis: This method was used to identify distinct evolutionary stages of research within the field.
- Trend Factor Analysis: This was applied to keywords to identify emerging and declining research areas based on their publication trends over specific periods.
Datasets
The study analyzed a dataset of 6,524 articles on environmental behavior. These articles were retrieved from two major academic databases:
- Web of Science (WOS): Specifically, the Web of Science Core Collection.
- Scopus:
The data collection spanned from 1974 to 2024, covering a 50-year period. The search strategy involved a comprehensive set of keywords related to environmental behavior and its various facets. After initial retrieval, rigorous duplicate removal and exclusion criteria (e.g., non-English articles, missing author information) were applied to ensure data quality.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Explosive Growth: The volume of literature on environmental behavior has grown dramatically, underscoring its increasing importance and interdisciplinary nature.
- Three Evolutionary Stages: The research field has progressed through distinct phases, each characterized by different thematic focuses and research questions.
- Emerging Hotspots: "Green human resource management" (GHRM) and "environmental awareness" are identified as the fastest-growing and most promising areas for future research.
- Enduring Core Themes: Despite new trends, "pro-environmental behavior," "sustainability," "climate change," and "place attachment" remain consistently important and high-potential research areas.
- Geographical Dominance: China and the United States are leading in terms of publication volume, reflecting their significant investment and research activity in this field.
- Interdisciplinary Nature: Environmental behavior research is inherently cross-disciplinary, drawing from psychology, ecology, sociology, and various other fields.
Key Results
- Publication Volume: The study analyzed 6,524 articles, showing a significant increase in publications from 1 in 1974 to 1,158 in 2024.
- Top Countries: China (1486 publications) and the United States (1325 publications) are the leading countries in research output.
- Top Journals: Sustainability, Journal of Environmental Psychology, and Frontiers in Psychology are among the top journals publishing in this field.
- Key Disciplines: Environmental Sciences & Ecology, Science & Technology - Other Topics, and Psychology are the most prominent disciplines.
- Emerging Trends: "Green human resource management" (GHRM) shows a particularly strong upward trend, with its Normalized Cumulative Frequency (NCF) surging significantly. "Environmental awareness" also shows a positive trend.
- Stable Themes: Keywords like "pro-environmental behavior," "sustainability," and "climate change" consistently show high NCF values and positive trend factors, indicating their continued relevance.
- Declining Trends: Keywords such as "values" and "attitudes" show negative trend factors, suggesting a potential shift in research focus towards more applied and intervention-oriented aspects.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that while the study provides a comprehensive overview, bibliometric analyses inherently have limitations. The study's reliance on specific databases (Web of Science and Scopus) might exclude relevant research published elsewhere. Furthermore, the interpretation of keyword trends is based on statistical patterns and may not capture all nuances of research evolution.
Future work could involve:
- Expanding the analysis to include a wider range of databases and languages.
- Conducting more in-depth qualitative analyses of the content within identified hotspots to understand the specific research questions and methodologies being employed.
- Investigating the impact of emerging technologies and global events on the trajectory of environmental behavior research.
- Further exploring the practical implications of the identified trends for policy-making and real-world interventions.
Summary updated