A belowground perspective on the nexus between biodiversity change, climate change, and human well‐being

Nico Eisenhauer, Karin Frank, Alexandra Weigelt, Bartosz Bartkowski, Rémy Beugnon, Katja Liebal, Miguel D. Mahecha, Martin F. Quaas, Djamil Al‐Halbouni, Ana Bastos, Friedrich J. Bohn, Mariana Madruga de Brito, Joachim Denzler, Hannes Feilhauer, Rico Fischer, Immo Fritsche, Claudia Guimarães‐Steinicke, Martin Hänsel, Daniel B. M. Haun, Hartmut Herrmann, Andreas Huth, Heike Kalesse‐Los, Michael Koetter, Nina Kolleck, Melanie Krause, Marlene Kretschmer, Pedro J. Leitão, Torsten Masson, Karin Mora, Birgit Müller, Jian Peng, Mira L. Pöhlker, Leonie Ratzke, Markus Reichstein, Solveig Richter, Nadja Rüger, Beatriz Sánchez‐Parra, Maha Shadaydeh, Sebastian Sippel, Ina Tegen, Daniela Thrän, Josefine Umlauft, Manfred Wendisch, Kevin Wolf, Christian Wirth, Hannes Zacher, Sönke Zaehle, Johannes QuaasJournal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This review highlights the critical, yet often overlooked, role of soil biodiversity in the interconnected web of climate change and human well-being. It argues for integrated solutions that recognize soils as vital regulators of climate, carbon sinks, and reservoirs of biodiversity, emphasizing the need for sustainable land management and societal engagement to address these intertwined challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical knowledge gap and the urgent need for integrated solutions concerning the complex interplay between soil biodiversity, climate change, and human well-being. While the impacts of biodiversity loss and climate change on society are widely recognized, the specific and profound role of the soil ecosystem – the largest reservoir of terrestrial biodiversity – is often underestimated. Human activities are driving both biodiversity loss and climate change, creating a feedback loop that degrades ecosystems and threatens human livelihoods. The paper aims to synthesize current understanding and identify key research frontiers to foster a more holistic approach to environmental sustainability.

Methods

This paper is a comprehensive review article. It synthesizes existing scientific literature from various disciplines, including ecology, soil science, climate science, economics, and social sciences. The authors draw upon a broad range of studies, meta-analyses, and reports (e.g., IPBES, IPCC) to build their arguments and identify research gaps. They do not present new experimental data but rather analyze and integrate findings from published research to provide a cohesive perspective on the soil biodiversity-climate change-society nexus.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Soil as a Nexus: Soils are not just inert substrates but are central to the intricate interplay between biodiversity, climate, and society, acting as a critical hub for these interconnected systems.
  • Hidden Biodiversity: Soil harbors an immense diversity of life (bacteria, fungi, invertebrates, etc.) that underpins essential ecosystem functions like nutrient cycling, decomposition, and soil structure maintenance.
  • Climate Regulation Powerhouse: Soils play a crucial role in regulating climate by influencing energy and water cycles, and most importantly, by acting as a massive carbon sink.
  • Vicious Cycle: Climate change exacerbates soil biodiversity loss by altering habitats and increasing extreme weather events. Conversely, soil degradation and biodiversity loss weaken the soil's ability to regulate climate, amplifying global warming.
  • Integrated Solutions are Key: Addressing soil biodiversity loss and climate change requires a holistic approach that moves beyond siloed solutions. Sustainable land management, policy interventions, technological innovation, and societal engagement are all vital components.
  • Societal Role is Crucial: Individual choices, collective action, policy advocacy, and education are essential drivers for promoting sustainable land management and conserving soil biodiversity.

Key Results

As a review paper, it does not present quantitative results in the traditional sense. Instead, it synthesizes qualitative findings from numerous studies to highlight:

  • Soil's Multifunctionality: Soils are vital for nutrient cycling, soil fertility, ecosystem resilience, and carbon sequestration.
  • Threats to Soil: Human activities like habitat destruction, pollution, intensive land use, and climate change are significant threats to soil biodiversity and its functions.
  • Climate Feedbacks: Changes in soil carbon dynamics can exacerbate climate change, particularly through permafrost thaw and land degradation.
  • Potential of "Climate-Smart Soils": Targeted soil management can influence climate-carbon feedback loops, helping to mitigate climate change.
  • Research Gaps: The paper identifies ten key research frontiers, emphasizing the need for more interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research to understand and address the complex nexus.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that empirical evidence for some feedback loops between soil biodiversity loss and climate change is still scarce, highlighting a need for more research in this area. They also point out the challenges in integrating local knowledge with scientific research, particularly in the Global South.

Future work should focus on:

  • Interdisciplinary Research: Fostering collaborations between scientists, policymakers, practitioners, and local communities.
  • Technological Innovations: Developing and applying technologies for monitoring soil biodiversity, assessing carbon stocks, and implementing sustainable practices.
  • Policy and Governance: Designing effective policies and governance mechanisms that promote sustainable land use and biodiversity conservation.
  • Societal Engagement: Increasing public awareness, education, and fostering collective action for environmental stewardship.
  • Modeling: Developing integrated modeling schemes that incorporate soil biodiversity dynamics, climate impacts, and societal responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Soil is central to the complex interplay among biodiversity, climate, and society. This paper examines the interconnectedness of soil biodiversity, climate change, and societal impacts, emphasizing the urgent need for integrated solutions. Human‐induced biodiversity loss and climate change intensify environmental degradation, threatening human well‐being. Soils, rich in biodiversity and vital for ecosystem function regulation, are highly vulnerable to these pressures, affecting nutrient cycling, soil fertility, and resilience. Soil also crucially regulates climate, influencing energy, water cycles, and carbon storage. Yet, climate change poses significant challenges to soil health and carbon dynamics, amplifying global warming. Integrated approaches are essential, including sustainable land management, policy interventions, technological innovations, and societal engagement. Practices like agroforestry and organic farming improve soil health and mitigate climate impacts. Effective policies and governance are crucial for promoting sustainable practices and soil conservation. Recent technologies aid in monitoring soil biodiversity and implementing sustainable land management. Societal engagement, through education and collective action, is vital for environmental stewardship. By prioritizing interdisciplinary research and addressing key frontiers, scientists can advance understanding of the soil biodiversity–climate change–society nexus, informing strategies for environmental sustainability and social equity.
BibTeX
@article{eisenhauer2024belowground,
  author = {Nico Eisenhauer and Karin Frank and Alexandra Weigelt and Bartosz Bartkowski and Rémy Beugnon and Katja Liebal and Miguel D. Mahecha and Martin F. Quaas and Djamil Al‐Halbouni and Ana Bastos and Friedrich J. Bohn and Mariana Madruga de Brito and Joachim Denzler and Hannes Feilhauer and Rico Fischer and Immo Fritsche and Claudia Guimarães‐Steinicke and Martin Hänsel and Daniel B. M. Haun and Hartmut Herrmann and Andreas Huth and Heike Kalesse‐Los and Michael Koetter and Nina Kolleck and Melanie Krause and Marlene Kretschmer and Pedro J. Leitão and Torsten Masson and Karin Mora and Birgit Müller and Jian Peng and Mira L. Pöhlker and Leonie Ratzke and Markus Reichstein and Solveig Richter and Nadja Rüger and Beatriz Sánchez‐Parra and Maha Shadaydeh and Sebastian Sippel and Ina Tegen and Daniela Thrän and Josefine Umlauft and Manfred Wendisch and Kevin Wolf and Christian Wirth and Hannes Zacher and Sönke Zaehle and Johannes Quaas},
  title = {{A belowground perspective on the nexus between biodiversity change, climate change, and human well‐being}},
  journal = {Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/sae2.12108},
}
Figure