Abstract
In multiagent environments, forms of social learning such as teaching and imitation have been shown to aid the transfer of knowledge from experts to learners in reinforcement learning (RL). We recast the problem of imitation in a Bayesian framework. Our Bayesian imitation model allows a learner to smoothly pool prior knowledge, data obtained through interaction with the environment, and information inferred from observations of expert agent behaviors. Our model integrates well with recent Bayesian exploration techniques, and can be readily generalized to new settings.
Introduction
In multiagent reinforcement learning (RL), agents can significantly accelerate their learning process by observing and imitating experts, or "mentors," rather than relying solely on blind exploration. However, traditional imitation learning often assumes that agents can explicitly communicate or directly observe the exact control actions of the mentor. Such assumptions are frequently unrealistic in competitive, uncooperative, or heterogeneous environments.
"Implicit imitation" addresses this by allowing an agent to learn from a mentor's outward state transitions—for example, observing a robot's path without knowing the specific motor torques applied. While useful, existing implicit imitation methods often rely on ad-hoc tuning parameters to merge observational data with the agent's own experience. This research proposes a principled, mathematically rigorous Bayesian model-based framework to pool an agent's prior knowledge, its own trial-and-error experience, and mentor observations.
Methods
The proposed framework builds on model-based RL, where an agent maintains a probability distribution (specifically, factored Dirichlet distributions) over the possible transition dynamics of the environment.
The core innovation is the Bayesian imitation update rule. When a learning agent observes a mentor transition from one state to another, the specific action taken by the mentor remains unknown. To incorporate this data, the model calculates the expected probability of the mentor's actions based on the learner's current beliefs about the mentor's policy. The agent then updates its own environmental model by effectively adding the mentor's observed state transitions to its own experience, weighted by these probabilities.
This imitation technique is integrated with Bayesian exploration, which uses the agent's uncertainty about the environment to guide optimal exploration. At each step, the agent observes its own state transition and the mentor's, updates its density over environmental models, updates its value function, and selects its next action.
Experimental Evaluation
The approach was evaluated across several simulated RL environments, including standard benchmarks like Loop and Chain, as well as more complex domains:
- FlagWorld: A grid-world navigation task requiring agents to collect flags before reaching a goal.
- Tutoring Domain: A non-spatial task involving optimal scheduling of concepts for a simulated student with exponential forgetting.
- No-South Domain: A grid-world with restricted movements designed to test the agent's ability to overcome misleading prior beliefs about spatial connectivity.
Key Results and Insights
The experiments yielded several critical insights:
- Overcoming Misleading Priors: In the "No-South" domain, standard Bayesian explorers often get trapped in dead ends due to flawed prior assumptions of full connectivity. The imitating agent successfully uses mentor observations to quickly correct these internal models and avoid traps.
- Robustness to Differing Goals: Learners do not need to share the mentor's exact objectives. By extracting environmental dynamics rather than just copying policies, an agent can watch a mentor head toward one goal and apply that knowledge to reach its own separate goal.
- Elimination of Ad-Hoc Parameters: The Bayesian approach eliminates the need for manual parameter tuning (common in $\epsilon$-greedy strategies), as it adapts locally and instantly to new evidence.
In the FlagWorld domain, the Bayesian Imitator with Bayesian Exploration (BEBI) achieved the fastest convergence to the optimal policy, outperforming both non-imitating and non-Bayesian imitating agents. Similar success was observed in the Tutoring domain, where BEBI and its $\epsilon$-greedy variant (EGBI) learned optimal policies that non-Bayesian imitators failed to reach.
Discussion and Future Work
While effective, the current model assumes "homogeneous actions," meaning the observer assumes it can duplicate the mentor's actions. Additionally, the Bayesian updates, specifically the sampling required to estimate the mentor's policy, are computationally intensive, though still more efficient than full Bellman sweeps over all states.
Future research will focus on extending the framework to heterogeneous action settings by incorporating feasibility testing. Other avenues include adapting the model for continuous state/action spaces, discovering correspondences between different agents' action spaces, and introducing game-theoretic elements to handle competitive scenarios where mentors might intentionally obscure information.
Summary updated